Keith Phipps, The A.V. Club
Select another critic »
For 913 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
43% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
54% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 2.5 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Keith Phipps' Scores
- Movies
| Average review score: | 57 |
|---|---|
| Highest review score: |
Critic Score
100
|
| Lowest review score: |
Critic Score
0
|
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 385 out of 913
-
Mixed: 366 out of 913
-
Negative: 162 out of 913
913
movie reviews
- By critic score
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
In the end, Chaos is as compelling as it is confounding, and it's compelling in large part because of the confusion it stirs. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Offers a strange mix of sentimentality and social criticism, sometimes mixing the two to awkward effect. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Roberts' script and direction show sparks of wit, but the plot comes lifted from countless heist films. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
But while Only The Strong Survive is essential viewing for soul fans, as a documentary it never makes the needed connections among the artists, their music, and the lives they lead. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Becomes precisely the sort of film its elements demand. As tearful goodbyes and joyful montage sequences set to lite-jazz saxophoning take over, "neatly winsome" trumps "messy drama" yet again. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
After spending so much time letting the characters' deeds do the talking, the film veers into overkill, which comes as a letdown. But the actions linger longer than the words. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Though typically engaging, Ararat occasionally suffers from what's previously been a virtue in Egoyan's filmmaking. His distancing techniques, rather than sharpening his ability to deal with a subject that lends itself to high emotion -- sometimes just seem distancing. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Its gloomy speculations on the ephemeral nature of art are paradoxically not easily forgotten, and Godard's daring again pays off, or at least comes close enough to get credit for trying. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Though it's tough to find much fault with a film so sweet, Piglet's Big Movie never lives up to its title. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Never finds any forward momentum, but Vysotskaya's sweet performance and the unsubtle but effective use of the war-torn asylum as a stand-in for the former USSR keep it compelling. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
It's clever enough, but it's mostly a contrivance to hide the fact that there's nothing interesting about the story itself. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Even if it weren't a remake, The Italian Job would still look startlingly unoriginal, but in a summer that promises plenty of sold-out showings, it could be the season's breakout pretty-okay-second-choice film. -
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Occasionally, the film invites a more dynamic touch than the careful slowness Cholodenko carries over from "High Art." But that same care gives the movie a seductive quality that would have been lost in a more hurried approach. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Once it reaches the meat of the story, it seems to lose its confidence. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Love Liza needs more than mood on its side. A moment of recognizable human behavior would have been a fine place to start. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
It's a bit more than the film can handle without leaving loose ends dangling, and though it's never preachy, Sayles' political message-sending sometimes comes across too clearly for its own good. He makes valid points, though, particularly when he lets his storytelling do the work for him. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
The unimposing Fiennes may not suggest the burly Luther's plain-talking peasant background, but he at least captures the charisma. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
When the suspense setpieces do come, many of them are staged with considerably less imagination—with cheap jolts underscored by an intrusive score—than would be expected from director Wes Craven. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
When the general pleasantness of the atmosphere and the cleverness of the screenplay don't carry the movie, Wilson does -- at least until a hurried, confounding finale that reveals its casualness as sloppiness. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
The same willingness to plunge into luridness and melodrama allows The Gatekeeper to work as a taut suspense film on its shoestring budget. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
It sputters whenever it has to move the story along, and it too often forgets to pay attention to Cuthbert; it makes a point about the mistake of treating women as sex objects, but it's perfectly content to use her as a plot device for the second and third acts. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Cinematographer Italo Petriccione gives the film a dramatic look, but that never compensates for the lack of actual drama; when so much of the conflict concerns Cristiano's reluctance to betray his father, it might have helped to spend more time on exploring that relationship than on capturing what light looks like when it pours in from a cellar door. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
The lovable characters remain, but they never do much of interest in a sequel that's safely above average but superfluous. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Sure, it quickly turns into a one-note exercise in laughing at the yokels, but at least it has a vision. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
At times, this makes the film easier to appreciate than it is to watch: The story is perfectly clear, but the film's style takes its cues from the characters' oblique emotions in a way designed to freeze viewers out. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Conceptually compelling, but the interest ends there, in part because the humans get squeezed to the margins in favor of pseudo-history and clashing battleaxes. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
The second Pierce Brosnan-fronted James Bond movie settles into the groove of unspectacular convention-adhering that has marked the series for the last couple of decades. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Garden State coasts on this considerable charm until it hits a brick wall in its final segments. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
It's a stylish, cleverly plotted, perpetually unpredictable film with another electric (albeit brief) performance from Penn. So why is it so unaffecting? -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
It's clumsy, but also strangely refreshing. To children raised on "Spy Kids" and "SpongeBob SquarePants," it may look as primitive as a daguerreotype, but never underestimate the persuasive powers of a cute animal. -
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Tying The Knot's central point remains insistently stated. It would be hard for anyone to watch it and still think of the demand for same-sex marriage as a mere passing fancy. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
While not dwelling on plot eventually gets P.S. in trouble during the slack finale, it gives Linney and Grace plenty of room to maneuver. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Caine played Alfie as an incorrigible S.O.B. who at least made for good company. Law makes him a delicate boy with self-control problems who can't stop talking, and his charm runs out long before the film ends. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
For those who like Carrey and are waiting for a film they can honestly say they enjoyed through and through, this ain't it. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
A slow, meditative movie-an appropriate choice given the subject matter-that ultimately fails, in spite of clearly heartfelt good intentions, because of its almost inhuman detachment. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
It looks good. It seems to work. It occasionally coheres into a priceless moment. But in the end, the pieces don't all fit together as they should. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
When it unexpectedly shifts back into its initial thriller mode, Walk On Water loses in human drama what it gains in tidiness, revealing itself as a film that carries more weight in its light scenes than its heavy moments can sustain. -
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Brown probably captures enough to satisfy hardcore enthusiasts, but everyone else might end up wondering why he ignored the glory for the dust. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
By the film's halfway point, the subplots have all started to head in the most obvious directions imaginable, which is too bad, since they all have real potential. Ferrera's story of spending the summer as an out-of-place ethnic element in the milk-white suburbs stays interesting the longest, in large part thanks to her performance. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Director Chris Terrio adapts Amy Fox's play with flashes of wit, moments of insight, and some fine performances. But Heights' characters move along such preordained paths and perform such familiar movie actions that they might as well sport antennae. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Director Thomas Balmès mostly just tags along for the ride, but the incidental details he picks up taint the sense of guarded hopefulness. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
The drama loses shape before it really develops, but the sense of place--all wood paneling and animal knick-knacks--and the memorable performances keep it worth watching. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Mackenzie's film could almost use one or two lurid touches in place of its stately distance. Then again, a more stylized approach might have allowed less room for Richardson, whose unsparing performance makes other elements almost irrelevant. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Panayotopoulou's background in photography shows in the way she lets her chiaroscuro lighting mirror her characters' emotions. It also shows in the still-life quality that Hard Goodbyes never quite gets beyond. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
As Ouimet, the always-terrific Shia LeBeouf is an oasis of depth in a film that otherwise can't pass up a sports-film cliché. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Only a truly great director can make a film of high artistic merit, filled with personality and memorable scenes, that's still a borderline disaster. (Think One From The Heart or 1941.) So the heartfelt and woefully miscalculated Elizabethtown may be the film that marks Cameron Crowe's arrival as a truly great director. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 60
Though he (Jordan) directs with admirable skill, his usual touches don't drive the film--which occasionally threatens to lose its shape. -
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
That love triangle is Coastlines' center. Trouble is, it plays more like canned heat than blazing inferno. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
It's well-acted and strikingly shot, and its depiction of contemporary Spanish squalor is hard to forget, but it never quite reconciles its high-drama situations with its low-key approach. It whispers when it really wants to shout. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Its a stupid thrill for a while, but the high wears off, and the anything-goes approach gets headache-inducing. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Why do Ewing and Grady feel the need to tip their hand by underscoring it all with creepy ambient music or by using Air America host Mike Papantonio as a Greek Chorus expressing the voice of reason? -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
As usual, Thornton remains fully committed to the performance. Viewers could make a game of scanning his face for even the slightest hint of warmth. By the end of the film, that may be the surest source of entertainment. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
A filmed Sunday-school lesson that favors a dry, by-the-Book approach over even a suggestion of dramatic interpretation. It's more Christmas pageant than movie. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Unfortunately, that story isn't particularly well told, and after a while, the strength of the two leads' work and the popping soundtrack can't hide the fact that Lemmons doesn't really have much to say about the material. -
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
The Golden Compass does manage the job of bringing Pullman's world to the screen. With luck, any future entries will try harder to get the job done right. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Too bad the story is all over the place. One second, it focuses on a love triangle between students; the next, it's about Washington's efforts to unionize the local farmers. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
It's not without laughs--Poehler and Fey, as ever, have strong chemistry, and there's a truly bizarre scene in which Martin offers Fey a strange "reward" for a job well done--but there's a lot of arid space between them. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Video veteran Sanaa Hamri directs with smooth competence, and the leads all go pleasantly through their paces, but there are no surprises. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
It's the perfect end-of-summer film, and a sign that summer needs to end soon. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
What does a film called Hotel For Dogs need in order to avoid being a watch-checker for grown-ups? Whatever it is, Hotel For Dogs doesn't have it. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
The action scenes don't always get the balance between flash and danger right, but the movie remains agreeably dopey--presenting street-racing culture as a hotbed of colorful stereotypes and lipstick lesbianism--until a climax that just isn't there. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
It's an agreeably unambitious comedy that might be called a romp, if that word didn't imply a little too much energy. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
The series kept it going for one more entry, but throws its commitment to the era away with movie number three, a ploy sure to anger Ice Age purists everywhere. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Lee’s movie is pleasant enough, but it’s too swept up in the spirit it’s celebrating to ask the relevant questions. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Mann reduces a legendary game of cat-and-mouse to the size of a standard police procedural. His refusal to mythologize Dillinger’s exploits is audacious, but too much of Public Enemies feels disappointingly smaller than life. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
After a while, Daybreakers settles into the lulling rhythms of too many horror movies, as the characters ponder what to do in darkened rooms instead of doing much of anything. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Zombie does a lot extremely well. Maybe someday he’ll find a movie into which it all fits. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
The best adaptations have found ways to put a personal stamp on the familiar stories. Others have simply reproduced an Alice facsimile in the image of their own era. Surprisingly, Tim Burton’s Alice In Wonderland belongs to the latter camp. That doesn’t necessarily make it a bad movie, just another frustratingly impersonal one from a director who once had trouble compacting his personality down to movie size. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
The crazies themselves could be a lot more terrifying. Without the rotting ickiness of proper zombies, they just seem like methed-out Iowans looking for a fix. That’s scary, but not scary enough. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
It’s a time-waster with brains, but ultimately not enough brains, and one that wastes too much time. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
It all goes awry in the end, but for a good stretch, Chloe neatly fixes Egoyan’s career-long obsessions with identity and communication to the familiar framework of the erotic thriller. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Vaughn opts for comic-book bigness—big fights, big laugh lines, big explosions—but without a Spider-Man or Batman at the front of the action, Kick-Ass’s heroes and villains look smaller-than-life in a larger-than-life world. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Image for image and shot for shot, Scott is still one of the most striking directors around, but in Robin Hood, the cohesive particles keeping those images together--frills like a compelling plot and sculpted characters--prove unstable. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
"Happiness" was, in its own dry, muted way, a howl of fatalistic despair discernible to anyone who's ever felt life had run out of cruel tricks to play. Life During Wartime is less a reprise of that howl than its echo. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
The film ultimately feels like a well-trod journey to a familiar destination with not enough wonder along the way. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Make no mistake. In spite of its worthy subject matter and good intentions, Made In Dagenham remains mediocre to the core.- Posted Nov 18, 2010
- Read full review
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Faster starts to lay on a heavy-handed message about the importance of forgiveness. That isn't what anyone showed up to see.- Posted Dec 13, 2010
- Read full review
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
It's a strange, shapeless, rarely satisfying, but generally amiable movie in which everyone appears to be faking it as they go along, and almost-almost-getting away with it.- Posted Jan 13, 2011
- Read full review
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Rowan Joffe (son of Roland Joffe) provides busy, if never particularly distinctive direction, but it's the leads that continually threaten to sink the film.- Posted Aug 24, 2011
- Read full review
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Whatever its basis in fact, there's nothing to Young Goethe In Love's story that dozens of other films haven't done before, and better. But Fehling keeps his Goethe just on the right side of obnoxious, and Stein invests a lot of character and gawky charm into what easily could have been just "the girl."- Posted Nov 2, 2011
- Read full review
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
This time out, Shelton seems to be playing the part of someone who doesn't know how to finish what she started.- Posted Jun 13, 2012
- Read full review
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
Viewers who dislike movies in which all drama hinges on one character withholding information from another for no reason beyond the need to keep the plot chugging along should stay far away from People Like Us. The film does have its charms, but getting to them means seeing past a Buick-sized contrivance.- Posted Jun 27, 2012
- Read full review
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
The Odd Life Of Timothy Green attempts to stage a modern fairy tale in Middle America. But in spite of an abundance of earnestness, the pixie dust needed to create magic remains out of the film's reach.- Posted Aug 14, 2012
- Read full review
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 58
There really ought to be a lot more movies like Hit & Run, but only if they're just a little bit better.- Posted Aug 22, 2012
- Read full review
-
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
Company almost seems like the product of a post-Sept. 11 world. Like a cartoon version of a real threat, the villains are terrorists of a non-specific nationality with an ill-defined anti-American agenda and a tendency to spout complaints too clichéd to take seriously. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
In the end, it becomes the cinematic equivalent of one of the songs Tunney adores: enjoyable enough while it lasts, but so thin that its ingratiating charms seem as much a source of frustration as pleasure. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
Shaw and Kingsley both create crisp, comic performances, but Sorvino remains a problem throughout. Her physical transformation falls short of the "Boys Don't Cry" standard, to put it mildly. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
Hartley's most ambitious film, but it's also among his most uneven, shifting away at moments when its characters should be allowed to connect, underemphasizing some themes, overemphasizing others, and letting a general clash of ideas stand in for momentum. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
The characters are funny and the cast's characterizations right on, but the movie repeatedly lets them down. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
Ultimately, writer-director Joseph Cedar has created a film that resembles a subtitled very special episode of "JAG." -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
Tries for that series' breezy matinee atmosphere but the results turn out far too forced. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
A situation of such inherent drama only suffers from the director's attempts to intensify it, and eventually, the scenes of professional and personal rejection begin to suffer from an overabundance of pathos. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
It works for a little while, but an Irons-narrated slideshow of the region would have worked just as well. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
If its star were more consistently funny, it might have worked, but the film opens with a string of dreadful Sept. 11 gags and takes a while to recover. -
-
-
Keith Phipps 50
Over in a breeze, padded out by a generous collection of outtakes, and filled with characters who disappear virtually unnoticed, View is an inoffensive comedy that feels like the victim of too much fiddling. -