For 78 reviews, this critic has graded:
  • 43% higher than the average critic
  • 7% same as the average critic
  • 50% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 0.8 points lower than other critics. (0-100 point scale)

Scott Tobias' Scores

  • Movies
Average review score: 59
Highest review score:
Critic Score 95
Lowest review score:
Critic Score 10
Score distribution:
  1. Positive: 32 out of 78
  2. Negative: 8 out of 78
78 movie reviews
    • Metascore: 63
    • Scott Tobias 65
    The film is frequently masterful, suggesting the turbulent inner state of an American sociopath who believes himself to be a good guy.
    • Metascore: 54
    • Scott Tobias 65
    Oblivion occupies an awkward no-man's-land between escapist space adventure and heady science fiction, but it's neither thrilling enough nor intellectually stimulating enough to satisfy devotees of either.
    • Metascore: 60
    • Scott Tobias 60
    The only character who stands out is a relentlessly clowning man-child named Taloche (James Thierree), but only as a symbol for the irrepressible spirit of an entire people.
    • Metascore: 74
    • Scott Tobias 60
    Based on its thrillingly fractured first half - not to mention "Moon" in its entirety - Jones seems much smarter than he allows the film to be in the end. It wriggles out of its own intriguing puzzle.
    • Metascore: 66
    • Scott Tobias 60
    A documentary that focuses rigorously on process and atmosphere at the expense of context and engagement.
    • Metascore: 67
    • Scott Tobias 60
    The good news about Outrage, his grisly return to the genre, is that Kitano doesn't have to shake the rust off - his impeccable compositions and clean, minimalist sound design are still calibrated for maximum impact. Even as dozens of bodies pile up, each act of violence feels as bracing as the sound of a gunshot ripping through the night air.
    • Metascore: 65
    • Scott Tobias 60
    For all their brutality, the fights are so seductive and exciting that their consequences - the physical and mental toll exacted from the men and their families - sometimes fail to register.
    • Metascore: 67
    • Scott Tobias 60
    Following up his acclaimed debut feature "Down Terrace," a gangster drama that also mixed genre shocks with dark comedy and explosive family spats, Wheatley gives Kill List a discordant tone that makes it feel like a horror film even when it isn't.
    • Metascore: 54
    • Scott Tobias 60
    Best of all is the half-surreal, half-touching scene of the couple ordering Chinese delivery - needless to say, the tip is sizable - and inviting the courier to Skype his family one last time and share in a moment of common humanity.
    • Metascore: 63
    • Scott Tobias 60
    The trouble with A Cat in Paris lies not in its orchestration, which is mostly impeccable, but with what little is being orchestrated. It's well plotted but a little rote, clever but a far cry from ingenious, attractive but not particularly evocative. When it ends, it leaves behind the faintest of paw prints.
    • Metascore: 53
    • Scott Tobias 60
    It's a cold-blooded business — and all sentiment aside, it's clear that Pineda is as replaceable as anyone.
    • Metascore: 61
    • Scott Tobias 60
    It's glorious while it lasts, but then the film goes back to figuring out how to keep its oversized vessel from taking on water.
    • Metascore: 58
    • Scott Tobias 55
    Heartless seems eternally at war with its own genre, unwilling to succumb to bloody mayhem yet neither smart nor coherent enough to transcend horror convention.
    • Metascore: 63
    • Scott Tobias 55
    Rio
    Name the first things that come to anyone's mind about Rio de Janeiro - samba, soccer, sunbathing, Carnival - and those are the building blocks of this movie. Expect the expected.
    • Metascore: 55
    • Scott Tobias 55
    So long as Exporting Raymond sticks to the headaches of adapting Everybody Loves Raymond into Everybody Loves Kostya, it's a funny and revealing look at the immense chasm between the two cultures.
    • Metascore: 59
    • Scott Tobias 55
    On a technical level, The Tree marks a significant advance over the humble utility of Bertuccelli's previous film, drinking in Australia's pastoral majesty with an abundant eye for beauty that falls just short of the intended poetry. Yet the characters aren't nearly as resonant.
    • Metascore: 51
    • Scott Tobias 55
    Nothing about it lingers, not even the sulfuric stench of a bum scene or a particularly hammy performance.
    • Metascore: 53
    • Scott Tobias 55
    Delicacy is phony in ways that might seem drearily familiar to audiences weaned on American romantic comedies.
    • Metascore: 64
    • Scott Tobias 55
    But a few mild misgivings aside, Spurlock has made, in essence, a 90-minute promo reel for the convention, a paean to fanboy (and fangirl) enthusiasm that could double as an orientation video, if such a thing were necessary. It's a brisk and cheery overview, sweet but superfluous.
    • Metascore: 52
    • Scott Tobias 55
    There's a better documentary to be carved out of Hit So Hard, but not necessarily a great one, because the gossip and drug-fueled capers offered up by Love are simply more compelling than the tremulous course of Schemel's life. Here, as then, Schemel plays backup to history.
    • Metascore: 53
    • Scott Tobias 55
    Once the colorful anecdotes sprawl out into an actual narrative, the film gets convoluted and loud, amplifying the weirdness without doing much to clarify it.
    • Metascore: 52
    • Scott Tobias 55
    Whatever lizard-brain fun might have been had in watching Johnson do battle against a drug cartel is weakened by the occasional hard tug at the social conscience. The film winds up divided against itself.
    • Metascore: 46
    • Scott Tobias 50
    The lesson at the core of Goethe's poem -- that powerful spirits are not to be taken lightly, and should only be conjured by those who can control them -- goes out the window, and the mentor-student relationship gets swallowed up in the action. Bruckheimer may be the dark lord of Tinseltown, but he's the Mickey Mouse of this scenario, and the mops and brooms get the best of him.
    • Metascore: 37
    • Scott Tobias 50
    Mirren cuts the figure of a bodice-ripping paperback heroine, a withering desert flower who blooms in the arms of a swarthy prizefighter roughly half her age. Mirren embodies the fantasy beautifully -- but Hackford's feature-length valentine to her all but sabotages the rest of the movie.
    • Metascore: 47
    • Scott Tobias 50
    A little focus might have helped. Or not: The Dry Land seems intent to tick off a checklist of PTSD symptoms without animating them with fresh details or creative life. It's cloaked in an earnestness that suffocates.
    • Metascore: 51
    • Scott Tobias 50
    La Soga isn't without redeeming qualities: Superfluous flashbacks aside, Crook keeps the action moving at a fast clip, cutting fluidly from the streets of Santiago to its criminal pipeline in Washington Heights, and he gets a sinister turn from Calderon, a veteran character actor who plays Rafa with a soulful swagger.
    • Metascore: 50
    • Scott Tobias 50
    Though Eat Pray Love never loses the sour whiff of unexamined first-world privilege, its heroine does at least immerse herself in different cultures rather than expecting them to adapt to her.
    • Metascore: 61
    • Scott Tobias 50
    What's really missing from Conviction are the thorny questions it refuses to take up with any depth.
    • Metascore: 46
    • Scott Tobias 50
    Shapeless and overlong, How Do You Know unfolds in a heap of unprocessed ideas and emotions, as if Brooks started production two or three drafts too early.
    • Metascore: 63
    • Scott Tobias 50
    The lack of authenticity underlines the thinness of their conceit: Without a plausible backdrop, all that's left of Love Crime are the power games between two duplicitous women and the serpentine plotting that results. And even that, under the slightest scrutiny, frays like a thin layer of tissue paper.