15 Movies the Critics Got Wrong

While the critical consensus can be a helpful indicator of the overall quality of a given film, there certainly are times when professional reviewers fail to appreciate the merits of a worthy film. We asked frequent Metacritic contributor Nick Hyman to dig through Metacritic's vast film database and select 15 poorly-reviewed movies (with Metascores of 39 or below) that are better than their scores would indicate. His picks are listed below, in alphabetical order.

Not so bad after all

Poor critical reviews are often justified, but sometimes a film is too unique, left-of-center, or just ahead of its time to convince critics of its merits. At other times, a terrible film succeeds despite itself. Here are a few of these low-rated flicks that have overcome bad press and sometimes worse scripts or direction.

15 (+ 1) Low-Scoring Movies Worth Seeking Out
Movie Netflix Year Metascore Users
Ace Ventura: Pet Detective 1994 37 8.2

Jim Carrey became a superstar for his all-in, rubber-faced, butt-cheek-talking performance of the titular character, who helps the animal woes of the likes of Courtney Cox, Sean Young, and Dan Marino.

Why it's good: Carrey’s hilariously manic energy as Ventura matched that of his In Living Color characters Fire Marshall Bill and Vera de Milo. Alllllllrighty then!

U.S. Gross: $72M
But I'm A Cheerleader 2000 39 9.6

Natasha Lyonne stars in this light and frothy comedy about a teenager who is sent to rehab for being a lesbian.

Why it's good: Critics who balked at the queer and campy film completely missed the deadpan charm exhibited by not only Lyonne but also co-stars Michelle Williams, Cathy Moriarty, Bud Cort, Mink Stole, RuPaul, Melanie Lynskey, and Clea DuVall.

U.S. Gross: $2M
Cabin Boy 1994 21 6.9

From David Letterman’s cameo to Chris Elliott’s daffy lead performance as the fancy Nathaniel Mayweather, the aquatic fantasy comedy is a uniquely hilarious adventure.

Why it's good: Director and co-writer Adam Resnick worked with Elliott on Late Night with David Letterman and short-lived series Get A Life and their singular brand of comedy carries over to the big screen. Appearances by Andy Richter (as Kenny), Alfred Molina, and Russ Tam add to the fun. “You wanna buy a monkey?”

U.S. Gross: $4M
Clue 1985 36 8.5

This murder mystery ensemble comedy starring Tim Curry, Madeline Kahn, Martin Mull, Christopher Lloyd, and other ’80s comedy staples was based on the popular board game.

Why it's good: In a clever conceit, the film had three different endings depending on what theater you saw it in (all endings are available on DVD). Pitch-perfect camp, including groan-inducing one-liners and sight gags, make this film an ideal midnight movie. There’s also talk of a remake.

U.S. Gross: $15M
Final Destination 2000 36 7.2
Final Destination 2 2003 38 6.6

Attractive youngsters who unwittingly escaped a gory end are eventually hunted down by Death in entertainingly complex ways. Former X-Files writers/producers James Wong and Glen Morgan kicked off a franchise that had no discernable villain but fate itself.

Why it's good: The elaborate suspense/action set pieces from the first two films are more impressive than most, in particular the intricately crafted highway scene that opens the second film.

U.S. Gross:
(1st/2nd)
$53M
$47M
Flashdance 1983 35 3.0

Pittsburgh welder Alex (Jennifer Beals) pursues her dream to be a dancer while dealing with her dramatic friends and suitor Nick (Michael Nouri) in this Adrian Lyne-directed and Simpson/Bruckheimer-produced drama about a “small-town girl on a Saturday night, locking rhythm to the beat of her heart.”

Why it's good: While critics rejected the MTV-esque mixture of slick, sexy images set to slick, sexy music, audiences loved it.

U.S. Gross: $93M
Freddy Got Fingered 2001 13 6.4

Tom Green’s late ’90s MTV success led to a big screen comedy to rule them all. He stars as skateboarder Gord, who is creates his own cartoon show, finds love with a cripple, and torments his father (masterfully played by Rip Torn).

Why it's good: This deeply polarizing film gets major points for railing against the norms of studio comedies, becoming something that’s part gross-out, part insanity, and dare I say part brilliant.

U.S. Gross: $14M
Happy Gilmore 1996 31 9.0

Sandler’s juvenile Happy must trade his love of hockey for golf in order to win a championship to help pay his grandmother’s back taxes.

Why it's good: The film’s supporting cast is its strong suit; Carl Weathers as Happy’s tutor Chubbs and Christopher McDonald as dastardly villain Shooter McGavin are standouts, but Ben Stiller’s evil retirement home manager and Bob Barker playing himself nearly steal the show in what may be Sandler’s best comedy.

U.S. Gross: $39M
Hudson Hawk 1991 20 7.2

Heathers director Michael Lehmann and screenwriter Daniel Waters teamed up once again with this ambitious comedy about a cat burglar forced to steal priceless works by Leonardo Da Vinci.

Why it's good: The over-the–top, cartoonish vibe rubbed many the wrong way, but the film succeeds largely on its own infectious energy and on star Bruce Willis’ charm. Supporting turns by Danny Aiello and especially Richard E. Grant and Sandra Bernhard as tongue-lashing villains help turn a star's pet project into an entertaining ride.

U.S. Gross: $17M
The Outsiders 1983 38 7.3

Francis Ford Coppola adapted the S.E. Hinton novel in this teen drama about the conflict between two groups of ’60s Tulsa youth, the well-to-do socs and the wrong-side-of-the tracks greasers.

Why it's good: The melodramatic art film’s future-star-laden cast includes C. Thomas Howell, Matt Dillon, Ralph Macchio, Diane Lane, Patrick Swayze, Rob Lowe, Emilio Estevez, and Tom Cruise. Enough said? Stay gold, Ponyboy.

U.S. Gross: $26M
Predator 1987 36 8.5

Take one part Arnold Schwarzenegger, one part Alien, and a dash of The Most Dangerous Game, and you have Predator, a clever and suspenseful tale of a human trophy-hunting alien invader.

Why it's good: Critics had had enough of the omnipresent Arnold in the late ’80s, but he’s in classic alpha male form here, along with fellow future governor Jesse Ventura and the amazing Carl Weathers.

U.S. Gross: $60M
Scrooged 1988 38 9.5

Bill Murray’s selfish television exec Frank Cross gets a wake-up call when he’s visited by three ghosts in director Richard Donner’s ’80s take on the Dickens classic A Christmas Carol.

Why it's good: The sly Hollywood behind-the-scenes setting was ahead of its time, and supporting performances by Karen Allen, Carol Kane, Bobcat Goldthwait, Alfre Woodard, and David Johansen are both hilarious and heartfelt. Critics should have put a little love in their hearts.

U.S. Gross: $60M
Speed Racer 2008 37 7.8

The Wachowski brothers followed up their much-maligned Matrix sequels with the even more maligned adaptation of Japanese anime series Speed Racer.

Why it's good: The hyper-cartoonish style of the film -- balked at by some -- was deliberate. While the film is a tad too long, its masterful opening backstory sequence, a standout performance by star Emile Hirsch, and great turns by John Goodman, Susan Sarandon, Matthew Fox, and Christina Ricci make Speed Racer a cult film in the making. 

U.S. Gross: $44M
Summer School 1987 27 8.8

Carl Reiner directed this absurd ’80s comedy about a coach forced to teach a rag-tag bunch of kids in summer school. Mark Harmon starred as the affable Mr. Shoop and his fellow teacher Ms. Bishop was played by a shoulder-padded Kirstie Alley.

Why it's good: The now-beloved, superbly executed music montages, plus horror film and Fangoria magazine worshippers Chainsaw and Dave (Dean Cameron, Gary Riley) have earned the film many fans over the years.

U.S. Gross: $36M
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me 1992 28 8.3

After the all-too-soon cancellation of his TV series Twin Peaks, David Lynch created an R-rated big screen prequel that showed the last seven days of series icon Laura Palmer, turning down the quirk and amping up the horror.

Why it's good: This descent into high-school hell is a tragically phantasmagoric epic that contains an extreme performance by Sheryl Lee as the doomed homecoming queen.

U.S. Gross: $4M

What do you think?

Are there any poorly-reviewed movies that you have wound up enjoying? Does anyone agree with our selections above? Let us know in the comments section below.

We're sorry, but comments are closed for this article.

Comments (234)

  • Jacob  

    the film "Screwed". They definetly got that wrong. and "Sorority Row". That was amazing an had amazing actors.

  • Alec  

    What about the trailer park boys ; P (Meta 38/100 User 86/100

  • S may  

    Ok whoever said both boondock saints movies is offically my favorite person on this site. Probably some of the best movies ever and were blasted by idiot critics.

  • Robyn F.  

    Addition to my post above...I ADORE "CLUE"! It ranks right up there with being one of the BEST movies that Tim Curry ever did.The First being "The Rocky Horror Picture Show". How this movie became underrated is a head scratcher especially considering that It was MEANT to be the way it was..Camp at its finest.... Get a Clue People!

  • Robyn F.  

    I loved "But I'm a Cheerleader", "Flashdance" Predator" and "The Outsiders"...These four movies were apparently rated by some Critic that probably only watched the trailer and based a review on that. I hate when Critics think that their word IS the ONLY one that matters.

    I have to add "The Runaways" as another VERY underrated movie...Just because a few Rotten Apples hated It because of WHO played Joan Jett certainly doesn't mean that its a bad movie. Movies should be reviewed by people that actually want to see it in the first place and that would be People like me.

  • John Flush  

    Speed Racer - No that one deserved to bomb. Deliberate or not, 70's **** anime was never worth watching...

    The only one I think you got right was Clue. The acting worked, the premise worked, and it was funny. Happy Gilmore is a favorite of mine, but the acting is trash and the plot only goes from bad to worse. Just because the rating is low doesn't mean it wasn't enjoyful though.

  • Michael  

    How in god's name is terminator not on this list?

  • hey  

    Grown ups, a recent one released. It was rated i think a 3.2 but when I saw it in the theaters it was a good movie. (i saw it before reading that it was a low rating) It sorta depends on how you think but it wasn't a bad movie at all.

  • niko  

    predator was so incredibly awesome that only avatar and predators can beat it!

  • Billy  

    HAPPY GILMORE WAS AN INSTANT CLASSIC!! How could they rate so low for it?!!

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/predict-the-summer-movie-metascores-2014 Image
    Predict the Metascores for Summer's Biggest Movies
    April 16, 2014 - 3 comments
    1. jrs71991 : Two Michael Bay films? Well that obviously will get a score lower than 40. Read »
    2. GuillermoBosque : Godzilla and Maleficent will be great! where's Into the Storm? Read »
    3. LamontRaymond : Love that you put the trailers right there - I hadn't heard of several of these. Read »
  2. /feature/movie-trailers-and-news-for-week-ending-april-11-2014 Image
    Film Friday (4/11): This Week's New Trailers + News
    April 11, 2014 - 4 comments
    1. TheQuietGamer : 22 Jump Street and Neighbors still look absolutely hilarious. Definitely my most anticipated movies of the year. Read »
    2. Will : "It began with Twilight..." Don't forget Harry Potter. Read »
    3. Will : "Spoiler Alert! If you don’t want to know what happens to Juliette Binoche...." Yeah, great spoiler alert, Metacritic. Read »
    4. silasbodnick : There is just something about the sound effects in the new Godzilla trailer that make me really want to see that... Read »
  3. /feature/25-best-ps4-games Image
    Quarterly Report: The 25 Best PlayStation 4 Games
    March 24, 2014 - 3 comments
    1. lemminguk : Glad to see the a lot of PS+ games high up. Couldn't understand all the complaints about them (especially don't... Read »
  4. /feature/dvd-release-calendar-april-2014 Image
    DVD Release Calendar: April 2014
    March 27, 2014 - 1 comment
    1. silasbodnick : Ride along is much funnier than the critics gave it credit. Definitely take a chance on it if you are up for a little... Read »
  5. /feature/breaking-bad-episode-514-ozymandias-reviews Image
    Episode Review: Breaking Bad, "Ozymandias"
    September 15, 2013 - 15 comments
    1. dgroberts27 : Look at the one critic review that wasn't "extremely positive" and see what it says. "Last night's 'Ozymandias'... Read »