2012 Oscars: Winners, Analysis, and Reviews

  • Comments: ↓ 7 user comments
  • Publish Date: February 27, 2012

Quelle surprise

Image
Films with Most 2012 Oscar Wins
1 The Artist 5 wins
  Hugo 5 wins
3 The Iron Lady 2 wins

As expected by, well, everyone, The Artist triumphed at the 84th Annual Academy Awards on Sunday night, taking home the trophy for best picture among the five awards it earned overall. The first silent film to earn best picture honors since the very first Oscar awards in 1929, The Artist also won in the directing and lead actor categories. Martin Scorsese's Hugo matched The Artist's total of five Oscars, though Hugo's wins all came in the technical categories.

In just a moment, we'll see how accurate the experts (and Metacritic users) were in making their predictions, and we'll also sample the critical response to the broadcast and the performance of host Billy Crystal. But first, let's look at the evening's winners and losers.

The winners and losers

If the night's biggest Oscar "surprise" is Meryl Streep winning for best actress, it's safe to say that this year's awards were pre-ordained. Streep's win—her third in a career that has produced a record 17 nominations—actually was a bit unexpected; many experts predicted The Help's Viola Davis to win instead. The other categories mostly went as scripted, save for the two documentary awards and a few technical categories, but in all cases, the film or person who ultimately won the Oscar was typically the experts' second or third choice. In other words, there wasn't a single out-of-left-field shocker in the entire ceremony.

Listed below are this year's winners in each of the 24 categories, compared to the consensus predictions of industry experts (more on that in a moment).

Category Predicted Winner Actual Winner
Best Picture y The Artist The Artist
Director yMichel Hazanavicius
The Artist
Michel Hazanavicius
The Artist
Lead Actress n Viola Davis
The Help
Meryl Streep
The Iron Lady
Lead Actor yJean Dujardin
The Artist
Jean Dujardin
The Artist
Supporting Actress y Octavia Spencer
The Help
Octavia Spencer
The Help
Supporting Actor yChristopher Plummer
Beginners
Christopher Plummer
Beginners
Original Screenplay y Woody Allen
Midnight in Paris
Woody Allen
Midnight in Paris
Adapted Screenplay y Alexander Payne and
Nat Faxon & Jim Rash
The Descendants
Alexander Payne and
Nat Faxon & Jim Rash
The Descendants
Animated Feature y Rango Rango
Animated Short y The Fantastic Flying Books of Mr. Morris Lessmore The Fantastic Flying Books of Mr. Morris Lessmore
Documentary Feature n Paradise Lost 3: Purgatory Undefeated
Documentary Short n The Tsunami and the Cherry Blossom Saving Face
Foreign-Language Feature y A Separation A Separation
Live-Action Short y The Shore The Shore
Original Score y Ludovic Bource
The Artist
Ludovic Bource
The Artist
Original Song y "Man or Muppet"
The Muppets
"Man or Muppet"
The Muppets
Art Direction y Hugo Hugo
Cinematography n Emmanuel Lubezki
The Tree of Life
Robert Richardson
Hugo
Costume Design y The Artist The Artist
Film Editing n The Artist The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
Makeup y The Iron Lady The Iron Lady
Sound Editing y Hugo Hugo
Sound Mixing yHugo Hugo
Visual Effects nRise of the Planet of the Apes Hugo

How accurate were the predictions?

As you can see above, the experts we surveyed last week did fairly well as a group, with their consensus picks proving to be correct in 18 of the 24 Oscar categories. While many actually finished with lower success rates individually, out of the 45 experts we tracked, five correctly forecast as many as 19 out of 24 (79%) winners. Those experts were:

  • Brad Brevet, Rope of Silicon
  • Pete Hammond, Deadline Hollywood
  • Tom O'Neil, Gold Derby
  • Sasha Stone, Awards Daily
  • Kris Tapley, In Contention

As a group, Metacritic users were much less precise, correctly predicting just 14 of the 24 (58%) categories. But one user out-predicted all of the experts, while several matched the most successful professionals. The most accurate individual participants in our Oscar poll were:

  • Aaron Sinner: 20 of 24 (83%) correct
  • Paul James, David Siudzinski, Hermes Vago Jr, and one anonymous user: 19 of 24 (79%) correct

How was the telecast?

In a word, dull. That seems to be the consensus opinion of the TV critics who watched the Brian Grazer-produced telecast. Not even a Cirque du Soleil performance or a pre-filmed segment featuring Christopher Guest and much of his mockumentary crew were able to liven things up. Here is a sampling of the critical reception:

"The result could hardly be called exciting, but after the pre-telecast fireworks Academy mavens were perhaps slightly relieved to be a little bit boring. If that was an unspoken goal -- other than some unscripted moments displaying genuine emotion -- they got their wish."

--Brian Lowry, Variety

"The Oscar telecast has truly come to suck. Sunday night's 84th Annual Academy Awards was actually painful to watch. I cannot think of any major TV franchise that has become so disconnected from cultural relevancy as the Oscar telecast has in recent years. And this one with Billy Crystal was truly pathetic."

--David Zurawik, Baltimore Sun

"A lifeless show featuring a bunch of pre-ordained winners and Crystal looking repeatedly surprised that his jokes were dying. ... It would help if the host wasn't recycling the same material he's been doing since the early '90s, and if the show didn't at times seem to be holding its nose and trying to ignore the unpleasant odor it found emanating from this year's nominated films. "

--Alan Sepinwall, HitFix

"Billy Crystal ... seemed to be overseeing a cruise ship dinner show designed to appeal to the over-50 travel club. Early on, it hit the rocks and started to list. Almost everyone drowned."

--Hank Stuever, Washington Post

"Obvious jokes were the style of the night ... [and] the show was packed with filler."

--Gail Pennington, St. Louis Post-Dispatch

"Last year's Oscar show may have been a headlong collision, but at least a crash has curiosity value. This year's show was as lively and colorful as cold oatmeal."

--Caryn James, IndieWire

"Sunday's show was awfully boring, in part because it strived so desperate to be popular when it should have just embraced good. It played it safe by rolling out the same old tributes to old films, which only created the impression that Hollywood's best days are behind it."

--Tim Molloy, The Wrap

"The veteran emcee... left his A game at home Sunday. At least Crystal's mediocre monologue was consistent with a mediocre 84th installment of Hollywood's biggest awards ceremony."

--Lori Rackl, Chicago Sun-Times

"The whole night looked like an AARP pep rally ... For a town that prides itself on tinsel and titillation, the night was pretty tame."

--Alessandra Stanley, The New York Times

"Somewhere, against all odds, James Franco is buying drinks for everybody. The colossal hosting disaster from last year is now forgotten by the safe, unfunny, retro-disaster that was Crystal making jokes that he laughed at repeatedly and overseeing an Oscars telecast that was as poorly paced as any in recent memory."

--Tim Goodman, The Hollywood Reporter

"You may have smiled much of the way, but with Crystal we're used to laughing from beginning to end."

--Robert Bianco, USA Today

Bianco was actually happy to have Crystal back (especially compared to last year's hosts), and, like him, not every critic was uniformly negative about the broadcast; a few had some praise for the verteran comedian in his ninth Oscar hosting gig (second to only Bob Hope):

"A classy and orderly -- if less than eventful -- telecast. What the affable Crystal brings to Oscar night -- aside from his sharp timing, comedic creativity and good-natured barbs -- is an unparalleled sense of ease. Viewers and the nominees seem to relax knowing they're in experienced, capable hands. But after an eight-year absence, could the 63-year-old Crystal still bring it? Yes, for the most part, but perhaps with not quite as much zip on his fastball."

--Chuck Barney, Contra Costa Times

"It was a jolly good show, probably as good a show as any that lasts more than three hours and is obliged to run commercials for GCB and which bestowed its biggest awards upon a movie only a tiny percentage of the TV audience has seen."

--Ken Tucker, Entertainment Weekly

"Crystal recaptured smartly the formula that worked for him in the past ... It wasn't the kind of performance that had millions of thumbs hovering over the Twitter buttons all night — that was Ricky Gervais back on the Golden Globes, silly — but it kept the show percolating, kept the focus on the movies and served up a few laughs in a show that at times felt longer than the Republican primary season."

--David Hinckley, New York Daily News

"There was nothing new or unexpected in his act, mind you. But it was comfortable for all. ... To no one's surprise, he stewarded a sleek and entertaining Oscarcast."

--Frazier Moore, Associated Press

Aside from Crystal's ill-advised use of blackface (in a brief Sammy Davis Jr. impersonation), which is drawing criticism online, the only other buzz the Oscars seemed to cause on Sunday night was literal: numerous sound problems during the broadcast had Twitterers voicing complaints.

What do you think?

Were you happy with the Academy's selections? What did you think of the broadcast, and Crystal as the host? Let us know in the comments section below.

Comments (7)

  • Nora  

    The Academy awards wasn t of new style but I think it was funny. Steven Spielberg deserved more. The begginner seem very intelligent for me. The actors opinions were very boring to me.The happyness of Jean dujardin was as Roberto benigni . Angelina Jolie shows her extremely thin leg and jennifer Lopez and Cameron Diaz do the same with their backs. I don t like that.
    In general the ceremony was better than the last year but nothing special.

  • LamontRaymond  

    The sound problems made an already-boring show annoying. You'd figure with all of those industry professionals in one room, they'd be able to solve that feedback issue on the fly.

  • warfield  

    Emma Stone the only fun moment of the night, even if acting a script.

  • Babimiami  

    First of all, the best animation picture, Rio, was not even indicated. Anyone who saw this movie agrees that it was much superior than the others. The music received a nomination but lost to Muppets.... Unbelievable!!! A judgement from a very conservative team. George Clooney who has been there for several years and was nominated several times in the past, lost for a totally unknown man who just did 1 movie and, maybe, is all he can interpret at his best. Who can trust Academy voters after that???

  • Critic2012  

    The 84th Oscars were dull and uninteresting. There were no real contenders- thus there was no thrill at the announcement of the winner. There were no tense moment, where you held your breath and clenched your fists, praying for a particular nominee. It was routine and boring= The Artist, not surprisingly, wins several. Technical categories are, for the most par, placid, and the acceptance speeches were forced. Three stars out of five for a decent, but predictable, Oscar ceremony.

  • Babimiami  

    Crystal was not as good as expected. He used to be funnier and acted more naturally.

  • Babimiami  

    The show was boring and without emotions. Used to be much better.

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/best-tv-shows-of-2013-2014-season Image
    Best TV Shows of the 2013-14 Season
    July 22, 2014 - 1 comment
    1. dunker : Orphan Black is truly an orphan when it comes to receiving the recognition it deserves. And that Tatiana Maslany is... Read »
  2. /feature/tca-television-critics-awards-2014-winners Image
    Television Critics Announce 2014 TCA Award Winners
    July 20, 2014 - 1 comment
    1. Ahiru77 : LOST can't even get a heritage award?! Son of a gun. Cranston doesn't need this though. Read »
  3. /feature/new-movies-and-trailers-for-the-weekend-of-july-18-2014 Image
    Film Friday (7/18): This Week's New Movies & Trailers
    July 18, 2014 - 1 comment
    1. Duke_Challenger : Please do a faithful adaptation of Frankenstein for once. Read »
  4. /feature/best-new-streaming-titles-july-2014 Image
    What to Watch Now: Best New Streaming Movies & TV at Netflix, Amazon, iTunes, and Hulu
    July 16, 2014 - 1 comment
    1. TheQuietGamer : Been meaning to check out Grand Piano for a while now. Netflix just made that easier to get around to. Another great... Read »
  5. /feature/2014-primetime-emmy-nominees Image
    2014 Emmy Nominations
    July 10, 2014 - 3 comments
    1. Nareth : I don't understand why The Walking Dead has yet to be nominated for any acting or best show emmys!!! The show, while... Read »
    2. pescetarian : The game is on... This is the year of the thrones. Read »
    3. gustav71 : Well, can we say that critics metascore about those terrible nominations is a 25? Read »
  6. /feature/best-albums-of-2014-so-far Image
    The Best Albums of 2014 So Far
    July 3, 2014 - 7 comments
    1. leetaylor15202 : You can't track down 15 reviews of Miranda Lambert's Platinum? For real? Read »
    2. twaddle : Toehider - What Kind Of Creature Am I? Wax Fang - The Astronaut Antemasque - Antemasque Band Of Skulls - Himalayan... Read »
    3. Italian10 : I THINK THAT " ULTRAVIOLENCE CD " BY POP SUPERSTAR LANA DEL REY SHOULD BE INCLUDED IN THE " TOP 25 CD LIST ". IT... Read »