Ranked: Best and Worst Horror Videogames

  • Comments: ↓ 123 user comments
  • Publish Date: October 25, 2010

Our Horror Week coverage continues with a look at the highest- and lowest-scoring horror videogames in our database. Later this week, we'll also examine the best and worst horror films of the past decade.

Shocks for your system

Though the newest re-boot of Splatterhouse (out Nov. 23 for 360, PS3) is coming a bit too late for Halloween this year, any gamer looking for scares right now can find them in the back catalogs for virtually every gaming platform ever released. In fact, even the Atari 2600 boasted a horror-related title, Haunted House (sort of a more dimly-lit variation on the system's earlier title Adventure), though few players accustomed to the blood and gore of today's cinematically dark, violent, and frightening games would find that 1981 release scary.

Yet horror-themed videogames have evolved in the ensuing three decades to become as frightening as anything you might see on the big screen. And we're not just talking about "survival horror," the most prevalent form of videogame horror that involves battling against a large group of much more powerful -- and typically supernatural -- enemies in a terrifying environment. Indeed, other staples of the horror genre, from haunted houses and zombies to werewolves and vampires, have haunted numerous games over the years, while even some of the darker fantasy releases have demonstrated the gore, supernatural terror, and and pervasive feeling of dread more closely associated with horror.

Best horror games for any platform

Let's start by looking at the 13 best-reviewed horror games in our database. Note that when a game has been released on multiple platforms, we have averaged those scores together to determine the rankings on this list. (Averaged scores are denoted with an asterisk below.) And, yes, you'll notice that while we do have some games from the 1990s in our database, others (and games from the 1980s) are not included, so a few horror classics did not make the list.

The Best-Reviewed Horror Videogames

1. BioShock 95* (2k Games, 2007)

Released for:
xbox Xbox 360 96
pc PC 96
playstation PlayStation 3 94
Image

"BioShock hearkens back to a time of fantasy and wonder, blending elements of Jules Verne and John Carpenter into a cinematic masterpiece of sci-fi horror that you won't want to miss."

-- Game Chronicles

Building on the innovative cyberpunk adventure series System Shock, Irrational Games' award-winning 2007 release blends elements of the survival horror genre into a visually stunning -- and spooky -- first-person shooter set in the underwater dystopia of Rapture. While this descent into hell presents players with numerous physical challenges, it is BioShock's confrontation of morality that elevates it to one of the best games ever released for current platforms.

2. Castlevania: Symphony of the Night 93 (Konami, 1997)

Released for:
playstation PlayStation 93
Image

"One of the best games available for the original PlayStation."

-- JustRPG

Considered by many fans of Castlevania to be the best game in the long-running series, the 2D action-adventure Symphony of the Night ditched some of the standard platforming structure of prior releases in favor of more open-ended gameplay, while retaining -- and giving an interesting twist to -- the usual Dracula's castle setting. The game was also re-released for the 360 via Xbox Live Arcade in 2007.

3. Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem 92 (Nintendo, 2002)

Released for:
xbox GameCube 92
Image

"It's the little things that start to freak you out. Pounding doors, bleeding walls, out of focus shadows, voices, moving statues, and then things get really messed up."

-- Cheat Code Central

The spookiest title ever released on the GameCube, Eternal Darkness boasted a gripping story set in a haunted mansion. But it was the game's "sanity effects" that were its biggest calling card, slowly messing with players' minds as the game progressed by adding frightening sound effects, altering visuals, and simulating console and TV malfunctions.

(tie) 4. Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow 91 (Konami, 2003)

Released for:
gba GameBoy Adv 91
Image

"An amazing, exciting, must-have game that'll keep you entertained for many, many years."

-- GameZone

The series' third (and best-looking) GBA release updates the setting from the Middle Ages to the year 2035, where a young student and his companions battle evil in Dracula's castle. At the time of its release, Aria of Sorrow was hailed by many reviewers as second only to Symphony of the Night among all Castlevania games.

(tie) 4. Castlevania: Circle of the Moon 91 (Konami, 2001)

Released for:
gba GameBoy Adv 91
Image

"Set against a myriad of beautifully rendered 2D environments, the detailed visuals convey a feeling of dread."

-- GamePro

The very first Castlevania title released for Game Boy Advance, Circle of the Moon was praised for its challenging gameplay, though many reviewers weren't quite so fond of the game's too-dark graphics.

(tie) 4. Planescape: Torment 91 (Interplay, 1999)

Released for:
playstation PC 91
Image

"If you don't mind some weirdness, have a penchant for the macabre, and love the idea of role-playing in a setting where death is a doorway instead of a slammed door, then Planescape: Torment is just what the (witch) doctor ordered."

-- Computer Games Magazine

Though this story-driven role-playing game was based on the rules of Advanced Dungeons & Dragons, its brand of fantasy was much darker than similar RPG titles, ditching the usual assortment of elves and dragons for an immortal, nameless protagonist moving through a bleak, multi-dimensional world that incorporates touches of both science fiction and horror (the latter though the presence of zombies and gore more than its ability to frighten). Critics praised its originality, but its emphasis on story and dialogue over action and combat turned off some players.

(tie) 4. Resident Evil 91* (Capcom, 1996)

Released for:
playstation PlayStation 91
cube GameCube * 91
* Updated 2002 edition
Image

"It tests your reflexes, satiates your bloodlust, stretches your mind (and temper) and leaves you both thrilled and drained."

-- TotalGames.net

While Resident Evil 4 (see below) might be a better game, its hard to understate the importance of the original Resident Evil to the "survival horror" genre; indeed, it was the first videogame ever marketed using that term. This graphically violent and undeniably scary 3D game set in a secluded mansion overrun by mutants asked players to solve puzzles and explore in addition to slaughtering zombies, spiders, and other horrific creatures.

8. Resident Evil 4 90* (Capcom, 2005)

Released for:
cube GameCube 96
playstation PlayStation 2 96
wii Wii 91
pc PC 76
Image

"This is simply the best survival horror game ever created."

-- IGN

Eliminating the puzzle aspects of previous titles in favor of more action and an emphasis on rapidly blasting zombies (or in this case, parasitically-controlled humans known as Los Ganados), Resident Evil 4 is arguably more of a standard action game or third-person shooter than a survival horror title. Still, it was a highly successful and influential one; nearly every such shooter to follow emulated its style. And the enemies contained within RE4 were scarier than anything that had come before.

9. Demon's Souls 89 (Atlus, 2009)

Released for:
playstation PlayStation 3 89
Image

"Probably the best and most frightening role-playing game this generation so far."

-- Gamer 2.0

One of the best PlayStation 3 exclusives to date, this extraordinarily challenging fantasy-RPG is set in a gloomy fog-infested land where demons feast on the souls of inhabitants. Though Demon's Souls may be too much of a fantasy game (yes, there be dragons here) to appeal to gamers looking for more conventional horror, it is certainly filled with tension and scares throughout, as any good horror game should be.

(tie) 10. Left 4 Dead 89* (Valve, 2008)

Released for:
xbox Xbox 360 89
pc PC 89
Image

"A redefining moment for the survival-horror genre."

-- The Onion A.V. Club

Another groundbreaking title in the history of survival horror (though, like RE4, it is more shooter than horror title), Left 4 Dead added something new to the usual zombie-blasting exercise: competitive multiplayer. What it lacked it variety it made up for in its cinematic environment, attention to detail, and replayability.

(tie) 10. Left 4 Dead 2 89* (Electronic Arts, 2009)

Released for:
xbox Xbox 360 89
pc PC 89
Image

"The Southern setting has made the game even scarier, with the redneck look of the Infected creating a more unnerving bestiary of creatures to contend with."

-- Destructoid

This quick sequel added the variations in weaponry, locations, and gameplay modes lacking in the original Left 4 Dead, though it didn't introduce any major new concepts. That didn't stop the game from becoming a critical and commercial hit.

(tie) 10. The Beast Within: A Gabriel Knight Mystery 89 (Sierra Studios, 1995)

Released for:
pc PC 89
Image

"A great horror adventure, driven by a script that puts the competition to shame."

-- PC Gamer

The second of three Gabriel Knight releases was a werewolf tale rendered in full-motion video. While that meant that storytelling was fixed and linear, the story itself was strong, and the graphics and sound were better than those of many other games of the day.

(tie) 10. Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow 89 (Konami, 2005)

Released for:
ds Nintendo DS 89
Image

"A delightful trip through a macabre fun house full of blood and assorted horrors that should not be missed by anyone who enjoys playing games."

-- Modojo

The first Castlevania game for the DS was a direct sequel to Aria of Sorrow, bringing back that game's hero (Soma Cruz) who now must fend of a cult seeking to kill him to bring back Dracula.

Best horror games for current consoles

Here are the top horror titles for each of the current-generation consoles:

playstationXbox 360
1 2 3 4 5
Image Image Image Image Image
BioShock Plants vs. Zombies Left 4 Dead 2 Left 4 Dead Dead Space
2007 96 2010 89 2009 89 2008 89 2008 89
playstationPlayStation 3
1 2 3 4 5
Image Image Image Image Image
BioShock Demon's Souls Dead Space BioShock 2 Resident Evil 5
2008 94 2009 89 2008 88 2010 88 2009 86
wiiWii
1 2 3 4 5
Image Image Image Image Image
Resident Evil 4 Dead Space: Extraction Silent Hill: Shattered Memories The House of the Dead: Overkill Castlevania: The Adventure ReBirth
2007 91 2009 82 2010 79 2009 78 2009 78

Horrific in all the wrong ways

Continue to the next page for our look at the worst horror videogames in our database ...

We're sorry, but comments are closed for this article.

Comments (123)

  • JJ  

    Castlevania? Horror?

    HaHaHaHaHaHaHaHaHa

  • Aly  

    Also a lot of you should go back and reread the intro. It pretty much addresses what everyone is **** about, particularly this last sentence "And we’re not just talking about "survival horror," the most prevalent form of videogame horror that involves battling against a large group of much more powerful — and typically supernatural — enemies in a terrifying environment. Indeed, other staples of the horror genre, from haunted houses and zombies to werewolves and vampires, have haunted numerous games over the years, while even some of the darker fantasy releases have demonstrated the gore, supernatural terror, and and pervasive feeling of dread more closely associated with horror."

  • Aly  

    A lot of horror IS campy, and horror as a genre isn't necessarily synonymous with scary. Scary is relative. There are plenty of games, books and movies that are in the horror genre that I don't find particularly scary, but they are still considered horror. I doubt anybody alive today and over a certain age would find Nosferatu scary but it's still a horror movie. Conversely, a lot of books and movies I find scary aren't horror at all. You may as well go to Netflix and Gamefly next and rip apart their classification systems.

  • Da Man  

    This is poorly, poorly written. Whoever did this needs to go and do some research. Okay, Resident Evil 1 was good, but RE 2 was so much better. And all the castlevania games? I think not! L4D wasn't scary, and don't even get me started on the fact that Silent Hill isn't on the list. It beats dead space by far. Idiots.

  • LichiGo  

    no F.E.A.R??and why is Aria Of Sorrow even on this list?!!

  • JDB4RDR  

    This is a good list, Dead Space had to be on there. I'm also glad to see Resident Evil 4 here as well, because it is a masterpiece of survival horror. Imagine being in Leons position, NOT NICE.

  • TopNotch playa  

    Have any of yous eva thought that they wrote this just to see yall all wild out and go crazy , just to see ya heads explode @ this joke of an artical , guys c'mon yo its obviously a joke , we shouldn't be haten on this piece we should be sayin good job, that was a good joke lmao it made me laugh , plants vs zombies & bioshock ,how could anybody even feed this lmao moment with anger . We don't get mad @ jokes ...we laugh @ um . Good 1 guys .

  • horrible  

    horrible list. since when Castlevania is horror ? Demon's Souls is also horror ?

  • Adam  

    Yes, this is an absolutely horrible piece of work. No Silent Hill games and really no mention of any real horror titles. I'd seriously consider not trusting ANY reviews by Metacritic if this is the kind of thing they produce. It seems like the internet has brought the level of quality down for a lot of things in general.

    I just recently played the Silent Hill 4 demo, having played all the way through SH 2 and much of the first. Barely into this game, there is a moment that totally unnerved me: I came back out of a portal from the famous room that the title is named for and into a subway restroom, and see a white, corpse-like mannequin with bloody forearms sitting in the open stall as the scene pops up. It is hard to explain in writing, but there's no darkness, a totally lit environment, yet seeing this image was very disturbing to me and I just froze and stared at it a moment. What also ended up being horrifying, is that the figure appears to be an image of the character you have as a companion in this part of the game and who ends up dying soon after. Silent Hill not being on here IS a complete joke!

    Really, the horror part of this is the (non)research and production of this article. Having all the Castlevanias on this list, though rightly deserving praise as quality games, is absolutely amazing. Commercialism knows no bounds.

  • Liviu  

    I'm an avid horror games players. I can tell you in all honesty that Amnesia is a masterpiece of the genre.

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/movie-trailers-and-news-for-week-ending-may-17-2013 Image
    Film Friday: This Week's Movie News and New Trailers
    May 17, 2013 - 1 comment
    1. rebel6794 : Christopher Nolan... James Bond... (Would that mean Hans Zimmer might score? Weird to consider...) That would be... Read »
  2. /feature/the-office-nbc-series-finale-reviews Image
    Episode Review: The Office (Series Finale)
    May 17, 2013 - 2 comments
    1. robinm : @oceansroar I'm jealous that you were able to avoid talk of Carell's return that broke late last week. I would have... Read »
    2. oceansroar : i love it, but i have loved it through the valleys as well. Yes, it may have been a bit too sentimental, but i think... Read »
  3. /feature/music-releases-for-the-week-of-may-13-2013 Image
    Music Monday: This Week's New Albums and Videos
    May 13, 2013 - 7 comments
    1. Zepfanman : Yep, this is definitely my go-to place for new releases. Got me faked out with the wording of "ALBUM Random Access... Read »
    2. XMoUhX : Let me double-second that! Love this feature and I always look forward to it..Keep up the good work, guys! Read »
    3. Emmanuel : And yet you still don't have the said album release in your database.. Come on Read »
    4. jethibea : Let the third that, love Music Monday, it's my favorite feature of metacritic and I lament weeks when it is absent.... Read »
    5. LamontRaymond : Let me second what @conditionals says: it's a great weekly music rundown on a single page keep it coming! Read »
  4. /feature/summer-movie-preview-2013 Image
    Summer Movie Preview: A Guide to Over 40 Key Films from Star Trek Into Darkness to Elysium
    May 2, 2013 - 4 comments
    1. TheFineBro : My most anticipated SUMMER movies are: 10) Star Trek 2, 9)Despicable Me 2, 8) The Worlds End, 7) The Hunger Games 2,... Read »
  5. /feature/video-game-preview-2013 Image
    The Most Anticipated Video Games of 2013
    January 15, 2013 - 25 comments
    1. Calamebe : Ima be playing pokemon x and y Read »