Ten Years of Metacritic: The Best Music of the Decade

  • Comments: ↓ 226 user comments
  • Publish Date: December 15, 2009

The top albums of the decade

ImageHappy to be at #1

Naturally, when you think '00s, one artist jumps immediately to mind: Brian Wilson. Okay, so maybe the former Beach Boy seems an unlikely chart-topper for the current decade, but his 2004 album SMiLE -- a mere 37 years in the making -- tops our chart of the best-reviewed albums of 2000-09. Long considered one of the great lost albums in rock history, this "teenage symphony to God" proved to be equally acclaimed once it surfaced. Is it really the top album of the decade? We have a feeling there may be some comments posted below about that topic.

Beach Boys aside, the genre most represented in our list of highest-scoring albums below is "indie/alternative" (again, if this is indicative of anything, it's of the types of albums both covered by Metacritic and favored by music critics), occupying 17 of the 40 spots. Rap was next, with nine albums (including two from OutKast, the only artist to appear twice in the top 10), followed by electronic, with seven.

The 40 Best-Reviewed Albums on Metacritic.com, 2000-09
  Album Year Metascore Users
1SMiLE by Brian Wilson2004977.9
2Van Lear Rose by Loretta Lynn200497 9.0
3Stankonia by OutKast2000958.4
4Savane by Ali Farka Toure2006948.2
5Madvillainy by Madvillain2004938.7
6Love And Theft by Bob Dylan2001938.8
7Boy In Da Corner by Dizzee Rascal200492 9.0
8Elephant by The White Stripes2003928.2
9A Grand Don't Come For Free by The Streets2004917.7
10Speakerboxxx/The Love Below by OutKast2003919.1
11Canto by Los Super Seven200191 8.0
12From Here We Go Sublime by The Field2007906.5
13Illinois by Sufjan Stevens2005908.8
14Original Pirate Material by The Streets2002908.9
15Alice by Tom Waits2002909.5
16Is This It? by The Strokes2001908.6
17Funeral by Arcade Fire2004909.4
18London Zoo by The Bug200890 6.0
19Untrue by Burial2007907.4
20XTRMNTR by Primal Scream2000908.7
21Z by My Morning Jacket2005908.2
22Since I Left You by The Avalanches2001899.3
23Rounds by Four Tet2003898.9
24Neon Golden by The Notwist200389 9.0
25Modern Times by Bob Dylan2006898.4
26Miss E... So Addictive by Missy Elliott2001897.9
27HoboSapiens by John Cale2004899.5
28Bachelor No. 2 (or, the last remains of the dodo) by Aimee Mann2000899.4
29Fed by Plush2008897.6
30Last Exit by Junior Boys2004898.2
31Merriweather Post Pavilion by Animal Collective2009898.5
32Songs For The Deaf by Queens of the Stone Age2002899.2
33Wearemonster by Isolée2005898.3
34Hell Hath No Fury by Clipse200689 8.0
35Chutes Too Narrow by The Shins2003889.2
36Yours, Mine & Ours by Pernice Brothers2003889.2
37Hypermagic Mountain by Lightning Bolt2005886.2
38Ta Det Lugnt by Dungen2004889.3
39Dear Science, by TV on the Radio2008889.1
40Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt. II by Raekwon200988 9.0

Albums released between January 1, 2000 and December 31, 2009 and having 7 or more reviews in Metacritic's database were eligible for the above list. Reissues, EPs, live albums, holiday albums, greatest hits albums, and other compilations are excluded. All Metascore data is from December 11, 2009. The Metascore is a weighted average of scores from top professional critics, on a scale from 0 (bad) to 100 (good). User scores represent an average of scores assigned by Metacritic.com site visitors.

Next, let's look at the decade's top-scoring albums in various categories and genres. We'll start with debut albums, a group that contains some genuine classics. Note that the same fine print beneath the table above applies to all of the lists below as well.

The Best-Reviewed Debut Albums on Metacritic.com, 2000-09
  Album Year Metascore Users
1Boy In Da Corner by Dizzee Rascal200492 9.0
2From Here We Go Sublime by The Field2007906.5
3Original Pirate Material by The Streets2002908.9
4Is This It? by The Strokes2001908.6
5Funeral by Arcade Fire2004909.4
6Since I Left You by The Avalanches2001899.3
7Last Exit by Junior Boys2004898.2
8The College Dropout by Kanye West2004889.2
9Arular by M.I.A.2005887.9
10For Emma, Forever Ago by Bon Iver2008889.4
11Fleet Foxes by Fleet Foxes 2008878.5
12Franz Ferdinand by Franz Ferdinand2004878.4
13The Creek Drank The Cradle by Iron & Wine2002878.9
14Mass Romantic by The New Pornographers2000879.7
15Mirrored by Battles2007867.9
16Hercules And Love Affair by Hercules And Love Affair 2008866.4
17 The Decline of British Sea Power by British Sea Power 2003868.6
18Thunder, Lightning, Strike by The Go! Team2005868.6
19LCD Soundsystem by LCD Soundsystem2005867.6
20The Futureheads by The Futureheads2004868.8
The Best-Reviewed Pop/R&B Albums on Metacritic.com, 2000-09
  Album Year Metascore Users
1Robyn by Robyn 2008868.4
2Beautifully Human: Words And Sounds Vol. 2 by Jill Scott2004869.2
3Don't Give Up On Me by Solomon Burke2002859.3
4BLACKsummers'night by Maxwell2009859.2
5The World Has Made Me The Man Of My Dreams by Me'Shell NdegéOcello2007849.1
6Love vs Money by The-Dream2009838.8
7New Amerykah: Part One (4th World War) by Erykah Badu2008838.4
8Love Behind The Melody by Raheem DeVaughn200883 8.0
91st Born Second by Bilal2001829.6
10Cookie: The Anthropological Mix Tape by Me'Shell NdegéOcello2002829.6
11Come Away With Me by Norah Jones2002828.3
12Lay It Down by Al Green2008818.8
13Back To Black by Amy Winehouse200781 8.0
14Anniemal by Annie2005818.4
15St. Elsewhere by Gnarls Barkley2006818.3
16Music by Madonna2000808.8
17Tasty by Kelis2003809.1
18Mama's Gun by Erykah Badu2000809.8
19Confessions On A Dance Floor by Madonna2005808.5
20The Scene Of The Crime by Bettye LaVette200779 9.0
The Best-Reviewed Indie/Alternative Albums on Metacritic.com, 2000-09
  Album Year Metascore Users
1Elephant by The White Stripes2003928.2
2Illinois by Sufjan Stevens2005908.8
3Is This It? by The Strokes2001908.6
4Funeral by Arcade Fire2004909.4
5XTRMNTR by Primal Scream2000908.7
6Z by My Morning Jacket2005908.2
7Neon Golden by The Notwist200389 9.0
8HoboSapiens by John Cale2004899.5
9Bachelor No. 2 (or, the last remains of the dodo) by Aimee Mann2000899.4
10Fed by Plush2008897.6
The Best-Reviewed Rap Albums on Metacritic.com, 2000-09
  Album Year Metascore Users
1Stankonia by OutKast2000958.4
2Madvillainy by Madvillain2004938.7
3Boy In Da Corner by Dizzee Rascal200492 9.0
4A Grand Don't Come For Free by The Streets2004917.7
5Speakerboxxx/The Love Below by OutKast2003919.1
6Original Pirate Material by The Streets2002908.9
7Miss E... So Addictive by Missy Elliott2001897.9
8Hell Hath No Fury by Clipse200689 8.0
9Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt. II by Raekwon200988 9.0
10The College Dropout by Kanye West2004889.2
The Best-Reviewed Electronic/Dance Albums on Metacritic.com, 2000-09
  Album Year Metascore Users
1From Here We Go Sublime by The Field2007906.5
2London Zoo by The Bug200890 6.0
3Untrue by Burial2007907.4
4Since I Left You by The Avalanches2001899.3
5Rounds by Four Tet2003898.9
6Last Exit by Junior Boys2004898.2
7Wearemonster by Isolée2005898.3
8Up In Flames by Manitoba2003888.6
9Arular by M.I.A.2005887.9
10Kala by M.I.A.2007878.2

Finally, let's conclude on a down note -- literally -- with a look at some of the artists whose Metascores trended downward throughout the decade. (There is no corresponding upward chart because there were surprisingly few artists whose scores consistently increased over the past 10 years.)

Going Down: Artists With Consistently Decreasing Metascores, 2000-09
Artist Metascores (in Chronological Order) Total Decline
The Dandy Warhols 80 73 57 46 ↓34
Jesse Malin 84 76 67 61 ↓23
Outkast95 91 72↓23
Badly Drawn Boy 78 77 60 57 ↓21
The Strokes90 78 69↓21
Eminem 79 75 64 59 ↓20
Jurassic 577 76 57 ↓20
Devendra Banhart 88 82 79 69 68 ↓20
Jet 70 62 51 ↓19
Richard Ashcroft70 61 52 ↓18
Xzibit75 59 57 ↓18
Bob Dylan93 89 76↓17
Buck 6585 71 68↓17
Busta Rhymes 77 65 64 60 ↓17
Franz Ferdinand87 83 70↓17
Dizzee Rascal 92 87 78 75 ↓17
Sugar Ray 71 68 54 ↓17
Trembling Blue Stars 78 73 61 ↓17
Polyphonic Spree84 70 68↓16
Asobi Seksu80 69 64↓16
M8386 76 70↓16
Plaid81 72 65↓16
Dolly Parton86 73 70↓16

Coming soon ...

We'll continue our best music of the decade coverage with a roundup of lists from top music critics and publications.

We're sorry, but comments are closed for this article.

Comments (226)

  • Don  

    It seems strange that there is so much metacritic list bashing considering they put forward no opinion on the music they list themselves but just aggregate everybody else's opinion, most of which is already numeric anyway. You can't really hassle them for missing certain bands out. Aren't I stating the obvious here?

  • Meow  

    So when is metacritic going to round up all the decade ending best album lists? I think we'll be seeing a new album at number 1 cough...Kid A...cough.

  • Al  

    no my morning jacket on this list = (almost) no credibility

  • 10 Best Health-Relat  

    [...] of the year” and “best of the decade” lists – from fashion to games to music to film and everything in between. As someone who loves to watch films and is passionate about [...]

  • Andrew Darwitan  

    Kelly Clarkson's "Breakaway" is missing from the database. I believe it's a critic favorite and would've given her a much higher average rating had it been taken into account. On another side note, poor Bjork, now if she didn't release those pointless soundtrack albums...

  • Our Most Anticipated  

    [...] Austin. But if Transference on the whole is deserving of its opening address, then Spoon’s decade-plus run of excellence may just glide forward another year. –Elias [...]

  • Daniel Reichberg  

    The sources may be many, but the results still somewhat meager. No hard rock/metal, no prog rock.

    Here's my top-50, bottom to top:

    50. Beardfish "Destined Solitaire" 2009
    49. Dream Theater "Black Clouds and Silver Linings "2009
    48. Saga "Trust" 2005
    47. Magic Pie "Circus of Life" 2007
    46. Marillion "Happiness is the Road" 2008
    45. Rolling Stones "A Bigger Bang" 2006
    44. Ritual "Think Like A Mountain" 2003
    43. The Flower Kings "The Sum of No Evil" 2007
    42. Dio "Magica" 2000
    41. Status Quo "The Party Ain't Over Yet" 2005

    40. Puhdys "Abenteuer" 2009
    39. Moon Safari "Blomljud" 2008
    38. Indukti "Idmen" 2009
    37. King Crimson "The Construcktion of Light" 2000
    36. Arena "Pepper's Ghost" 2005
    35. Roine Stolt "Wall Street Voodoo" 2005
    34. Spock's Beard "Spock's Beard" 2006
    33. Kaipa "Angling Feelings" 2007
    32. Neal Morse "Sola Scriptura" 2008
    31. Agents of Mercy "The Fading Ghosts of Twilight" 2009

    30. Porcupine Tree "The Incident" 2009
    29. The Cardigans "Long Gone Before Daylight" 2003 28. IQ "Dark Matter" 2004
    27. Conspiracy "The Unknown" 2003
    26. ACT "Last Epic" 2003
    25. Puhdys "Zufrieden" 2001
    24. Spock's Beard "V" 2000
    23. Transtalantic "SMPTe" 2000
    22. Gene simmons **** 2004
    21. Porcupine Tree "Deadwing" 2005

    20. David Gilmour "On An Island" 2006
    19. Trettioåriga Kriget "I början och slutet" 2007
    18. Eggs and Dogs "You Are" 2009
    17. Transatlantic "The Whirlwind" 2009
    16. Helloween "The Dark Ride" 2000
    15. ACT "Imaginary Friends" 2001
    14. Status Quo "Heavy Traffic" 2002
    13. Deep Purple "Bananas" 2003
    12. Ayreon "The Human Equation" 2004
    11. David Bowie "Reality" 2003

    10. Transatlantic "Bridge Across Forever" 2001
    9. Masterplan "Masterplan" 2003
    8. Ritual "The Hemulic Volountary Band" 2007
    7. Status Quo "In Search for the Fourth Chord" 2007
    6. The Flower Kings "Paradox Hotel" 2006
    5. Marillion "Marbles" 2004
    4. Yes "Magnification" 2001

    3: MAGIC PIE "MOTIONS OF DESIRE" 2005
    2: THE FLOWER KINGS "SPACE REVOLVER" 2000
    1: THE FLOWER KINGS "UNFOLD THE FUTURE" 2002

  • Review: Transference  

    [...] The aggregate criticism site Metacritic, forever on the lookout for new ways to crunch data, crowned Spoon as their best musical artist of the decade. This wasn’t an editorial choice; they received [...]

  • Bob Dylan  

    I'm Bob Dylan and even I think a lot critics over rated Love and Theft. But hey, I'm Bob Dylan.

  • Cius  

    Fantastic List, would even go as far as saying best of the best of lists!!
    Why, because it's the most accurate (or reflective of my personal taste)?? Not a chance. Probably more flawed than most of the lists I've seen out there. But just to read all the comments above has been hilarious (and often thought provoking). Surely a list that you don't either dismiss as appalling immediately or conversely agree with everything it says is how it should be....

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/best-new-streaming-movies-and-tv-september-2014 Image
    What to Watch Now: Best New Streaming Movies & TV at Netflix, Amazon, iTunes, and Hulu
    September 18, 2014 - 2 comments
    1. MarcDoyle : Netflix Picks: Blue Ruin, Sling Blade, Ordinary People, School of Rock, Silver Linings Playbook, There Will Be Blood,... Read »
    2. LamontRaymond : If you've got Hulu, Bellflower is one of my all-time faves.... Great soundtrack.... Read »
  2. /feature/critics-reassess-youre-the-worst-the-leftovers-the-bridge- Image
    Second Opinions: TV Critics Re-Evaluate the Summer Shows
    September 17, 2014 - 6 comments
    1. johnstonedlove : Rising Star is superb Read »
    2. maridanilidou : Outlander's last episode received rave reviews, you should add the show as critics only received the first 6 episodes. Read »
    3. urkobg : Outlander, Penny Dreadful and the Leftovers have been the 3 stand out dramas of the summer for me. All three are... Read »
  3. /feature/film-festival-reviews-2014-tiff-venice-telluride Image
    2014 Fall Film Festival Recap: The Verdict on Films Screening at TIFF, Telluride, and Venice
    September 15, 2014 - 3 comments
    1. dfwforeign : nice list and some good films. I have my own list and many films are not in your database. why are your films not... Read »
  4. /feature/videogame-scorecard-fall-2014 Image
    Video Game Release Calendar & Scorecard - Fall 2014
    September 23, 2014 - 1 comment
    1. LamontRaymond : NHL 15 is having a rough fall.... Read »
  5. /feature/destiny-ps4-xbox-early-reviews-and-observations Image
    Destiny: Early Impressions From Critics
    September 9, 2014 - 22 comments
    1. norhavic : I completed destiny in two days, solod the story, have done various strikes, what there is of them anyway, i now have... Read »
  6. /feature/best-albums-of-2014-so-far Image
    The Best Albums of 2014 So Far
    July 3, 2014 - 10 comments
    1. Senay : Coldplay - Ghost Stories Very beautiful Read »
  7. /feature/tv-premiere-dates Image
    Fall TV Premiere Calendar
    August 7, 2014 - 14 comments
    1. cbwdoug : How about Transporter: The Series October 18th at 9 and the Librarian December 7th at 8. Both have been listed in TV... Read »