Fall TV Results: The Season's Best & Worst New Shows

  • Publish Date: November 6, 2012
  • Comments: ↓ 2 user comments

Network performance

The five major broadcast networks launched six fewer programs than they did last fall—21 new shows this year, compared to 2011's 27—and the result was a slight overall uptick in average Metascore. Those 21 new programs combined to average 56 this fall, up two points from the average of 54 for last fall's freshman class. Ten of this year's 21 newcomers earned positive reviews from critics, making for a nearly 48% success rate, up from 2011's 44% rate. And just three new networks shows received truly terrible reviews, half the number of lousy shows that viewers were subjected to the previous fall.

Out of the five broadcast networks, ABC had the most positively reviewed programs and the highest average Metascore, a reversal for the network from the past few fall seasons. There was also some good news at the last-place CW, whose Arrow 72 was just the network's second positively reviewed new fall series over the past four years. (Arrow is also the CW's highest-scoring new series in five years.) NBC, however, had the worst success rate with critics, earning solid reviews for just two of its six freshman series. Here's how the networks compared this fall and in fall seasons past:

Broadcast Network Comparison, New Fall Shows by Year
  2012 2011 2010 2009
  Avg Shows Avg Shows Avg Shows Avg Shows
ABC 60 positivepositivepositive
mixed
mixed
53 positivepositivepositive
positivenegativenegative
negative
58 positivepositivepositive
mixedmixed
60 positivepositivepositive
positivemixedmixed
mixednegative
Rank: 1st Rank: 4th Rank: 3rd Rank: 2nd
Fox 59 positivepositivemixed 55 positivepositivepositive
negative
negative
65 positivepositivemixed
62 positivemixedmixed
Rank: 2nd Rank: 2nd Rank: 1st Rank: 1st
CBS 55 positivepositivemixed
negative
58 positivepositivepositive
mixedmixed
58 positivepositivepositive
positivenegative
58 positivemixedmixed
mixed
Rank: 3rd Rank: 1st Rank: 3rd Rank: 3rd
NBC 54 positivepositivemixed
mixedmixednegative
55 positivepositivemixed
mixedmixedmixed
52 positivepositivepositive
mixedmixedmixed
negative
53 positivemixedmixed
mixed
Rank: 4th Rank: 2nd Rank: 5th Rank: 4th
CW 51 positivemixednegative 47 mixedmixedmixed
negative
59 positivemixed 49 mixedmixedmixed
Rank: 5th Rank: 5th Rank: 2nd Rank: 5th

Averages are of Metascores for new primetime shows debuting in the fall of each year. Dots represent each individual new show with colors indicating positive (positive), mixed (mixed), or negative (negative) reviews from critics.

Best and worst new series

Image
2012 Nashville ABC 84
2011 Homeland Showtime 91
2010 Boardwalk Empire HBO 88
2009 Modern Family ABC 86
2008 Life on Mars ABC 74
2007 Pushing Daisies ABC 86
Best Reviewed Fall Shows by Year

If it seems like there weren't many great shows this fall—well, that's because there weren't. ABC's country music drama Nashville was the season's highest-scoring new program, but, at 84, it was the lowest-scoring first-place fall newcomer since 2008. It was also the only new series to surpass the 81 mark that we consider the minimum for a show to have "universal acclaim" from professional critics. That makes two fall seasons in a row where just one show was able to achieve that mark.

This fall also marked the first time in three years that the highest-scoring new series was on broadcast television rather than cable. The cable networks failed to introduce any programs of note this fall, with Cinemax's little-seen Hunted 68 scoring highest among cable newcomers.

Here's how all the new fall shows ranked with critics:

Metascore Ranking of New Primetime Series - 2012 Fall Season
  Show (Network) Genre Metascore Users
1Nashville (ABC) Drama846.6
2Call The Midwife (PBS)Drama807.7
3 Last Resort (ABC) 2nd Look reviews Action, Drama74 8.0
4 Elementary (CBS) 2nd Look reviewsDrama736.3
5Arrow (The CW) Action, Drama72 8.0
6 The Mindy Project (Fox) 2nd Look reviewsComedy696.7
7Hunted (Cinemax) Action, Drama686.7
8 Vegas (CBS) 2nd Look reviewsDrama676.3
9Ben & Kate (Fox)Comedy676.5
10 Go On (NBC) 2nd Look reviewsComedy66n/a
11 Revolution (NBC) 2nd Look reviews Action, Drama645.4
12 666 Park Avenue (ABC) 2nd Look reviews Drama, Fantasy617.2
13Breaking Amish (TLC)Reality61n/a
14The New Normal (NBC)Comedy60 6.0
15Underemployed (MTV)Comedy, Drama555.3
16Chicago Fire (NBC) Action, Drama494.8
17 Animal Practice (NBC) *Comedy48n/a
18Emily Owens, M.D. (The CW)Drama473.3
19The Houstons: On Our Own (Lifetime)Reality43n/a
20 Made in Jersey (CBS) *Drama434.3
21 The Mob Doctor (Fox) Drama423.4
22The Neighbors (ABC)Comedy414.3
23Malibu Country (ABC)Comedy417.7
24Guys With Kids (NBC)Comedy384.5
25Partners (CBS)Comedy375.1
26Beauty and the Beast (The CW)Drama34 4.0

* Show has been canceled.
Includes all shows debuting in the U.S. this fall with a minimum of 7 reviews from professional critics as of November 6, 2012. Shows are ranked by Metascore prior to rounding.

What do you think?

What new shows are you enjoying this fall? What did critics get right and wrong? Let us know in the comments section below.

Comments (2)

  • conditionals  

    Elementary is awesome, the spiritual successor to House. Mindy Project and Go On are pretty OK, but can't touch established comedies like Parks & Recreation or Happy Endings. Revolution is... well, I'm watching it and it's on TV. Those are the two things I can say about Revolution.

  • Cilliandrew  

    THE NEIGHBORS is criminally underrated. Best new comedy of the season. I am surprised by the high ratings for "LAST RESORT". It's silly, but i enjoy it on that level. "ARROW" is surprisingly solid so far. It's DARK KNIGHT light, but it works. I also find i enjoy "REVOLUTION" despite the weak lead actress.

New in Metacritic Features

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/predict-the-2016-emmy-awards Image
    Predict the 2016 Emmy Award Winners
    July 19, 2016 - 5 comments
    1. zembowerboy : Still bitter that Denis O'Hare didn't get a nom for his fantastic work in AHS: Hotel. Super stoked that this is... Read »
    2. Hufter : The Americans, all over. Far out Read »
    3. aydge89 : American Crime deserves to win best limited series along with Felicity Huffman or Lili Taylor for best actress. The... Read »
    4. emilyay : I also want Mr. Robot to win. It was one of the best first season of any show I've ever seen. It had flaws, but it... Read »
    5. DanBurrito : I want Mr. Robot to win best drama. Most engaging and addictive tv show in recent memory. Read »
  2. /feature/68th-primetime-emmy-award-nominations Image
    2016 Emmy Nominations
    July 14, 2016 - 5 comments
    1. DetonNation : Yes. What about Penny Dreadful. Besides Eva Green, every actor in the series put in a ground-breaking performance... Read »
  3. /feature/summer-movie-metascore-predictions-2016 Image
    Your Metascore Predictions for 30 Summer Movies
    May 4, 2016 - 23 comments
    1. Blanche : Seems that the user scores are - usually - far more accurate to the predicted score as per normal. Read »
  4. /feature/now-streaming-on-amazon-instant-video Image
    What to Watch Now on Amazon Instant Video
    July 20, 2016 - 6 comments
    1. MaryJames007 : thank you for the info. I waited for this amazon feature for a long time. http://www.how-to-program-in-java.com/ Read »
  5. /feature/tv-premiere-dates Image
    2016 Summer/Fall TV Premiere Calendar
    May 10, 2016 - 112 comments
    1. SuburbanGal : FOOD NETWORK'S CAMP CUTTHROAT - Premieres Wednesday August 24, 2016 @ 10 PM Read »
  6. /feature/dexter-series-finale-reviews Image
    Episode Review: Dexter Series Finale
    September 22, 2013 - 8 comments
    1. jldavis : It's been days since I finished watching the eight seasons of Dexter. To say that the finale left me unsettled is an... Read »