The Best TV Shows of 2009 ... and the Decade

  • Publish Date: January 2, 2010
  • Comments: ↓ 245 user comments

The best and worst new shows of 2009

ImageCongratulations

The story of 2009 in television? Quality control. While ABC's "Modern Family" was far and away the best-reviewed new series of the year (indeed, only 2005's "Everybody Hates Chris" out of all new network programs in the past five years received better reviews), a total of 36 out of 78 (46%) of all first-year primetime series on broadcast networks or cable in 2009 received generally positive reviews from critics. (This number excludes shows with fewer than seven reviews.) That's right: almost half of all new shows in 2009 were actually good.

More strikingly, only six new programs -- a miniscule 7.7% -- received mostly negative reviews from critics (i.e., they received a Metascore of 39 or below). Compare that total to previous years: eight crummy shows in 2008, 19 in 2007, and 23 in 2006. Either critics are getting less picky, or programmers are passing on the most terrible shows. (We hope it's the latter.)

Before we get to the critics' picks for best shows of 2009, let's look more closely at the programs that premiered during the past 12 months, starting with the best of the bunch.

Best Reviewed New Television Series, 2009
  Show (Network) Genre Metascore Users
1 Modern Family (ABC) Comedy 86 8.6
2 Men of a Certain Age (TNT) Comedy/Drama 79 8.1
3 White Collar (USA) Drama 78 8.6
4 Glee (Fox) Musical 77 8.3
5 Nurse Jackie (Showtime) Comedy/Drama 76 7.2
6 The Good Wife (CBS) Drama 76 8.6
7 The Electric Company (PBS) Family 74 8.0
8 FlashForward (ABC) Sci-Fi 72 7.0
9 Important Things With Demetri Martin (Comedy Central) Comedy 71 7.9
10 The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency (HBO) Drama 71 9.5

American television series with seven or more reviews and debuting between January 1, 2009 and December 31, 2009 were eligible for the above list. Shows are scored and ranked based on reviews published at the time of the original first season debut; returning series are excluded from this list. The Metascore is a weighted average of scores from top professional critics, on a scale from 0 (bad) to 100 (good). Although scores have been rounded to the nearest whole number, movies are ranked prior to rounding. User scores represent an average of scores assigned by Metacritic.com site visitors on a scale from 0 (bad) to 10 (good).

Note that two first-year series finished in Nielsen's list of top-ten shows in 2009. Both were on CBS, but only one received mostly positive reviews: the Julianna Margulies drama The Good Wife 76, which finished 10th in the ratings. The bigger hit was the spinoff NCIS: Los Angeles 59, which finished sixth in the ratings for the past year in spite of mixed reviews from critics. You won't find any of the following programs near the top of the ratings chart, however.
Worst Reviewed New Television Series, 2009
  Show (Network) Genre Metascore Users
1 The Jeff Dunham Show (Comedy Central) Comedy 20 2.4
2 The Cougar (TV Land) Reality 33 2.4
3 13: Fear Is Real (CW) Reality 33 4.2
4 Surviving Suburbia (ABC) Comedy 35 2.8
5 Hank (ABC) Comedy 37 4.4

What becomes noticeable again from the chart below (other than the fact that despite a shift to a year-round schedule, a large proportion of shows still premiere in the fall) is just how few "bad" new shows there were in 2009. Of course, those big yellow bars reveal that there were plenty of mediocre programs, receiving mixed reviews form critics. The median score for all new programs fell in this "mixed" range, at 59.

Totals of New Primetime Television Series by Month of Premiere, 2009

Only first-year shows with at least seven reviews in Metacritic's database are included. Both cable and broadcast shows are included. Green represents the number of positively-reviewed shows (Metascore of 61 or higher). Yellow represents shows receiving mixed or average reviews (40-60). Red represents negatively-reviewed shows (0-39).

A roundup of television critic Top 10 lists for 2009

ImageDressed for success

A winner of virtually every television award for Best Drama over the past year, AMC's "Mad Men" was also a winner with critics, who added the third-year show to their year-end Best of 2009 lists more often than any other program. In fact, "Mad Men" didn't just appear on those lists; it tended to appear in the #1 position.

ABC's single-camera sitcom "Modern Family" led a crop of four freshman programs that landed in the top 10 of top-10-list mentions, with Fox's hit musical "Glee," NBC's struggling Amy Poehler comedy "Parks and Recreation" and Showtime's Edie Falco dramedy "Nurse Jackie" filling out that group. "Modern Family" also earned honors as the most-saluted comedy of the year. For "Parks and Recreation," the turnaround in critical reception is noticeable; the show received a mediocre Metascore of 59 when it debuted in April, but critics (and any remaining viewers) have noticed a marked jump in quality in Season 2.

The remaining shows that appeared with some frequency on the critic lists are tallied in the table below. Remember that our summary list is not weighted or scored in any way; shows are simply ranked by the frequency with which they appear in critic Top 10 lists, in any position on those lists. (The number of times they appear in the #1 position is indicated as a convenience.) A full list of publications used -- with links to many of the individual lists -- appears beneath the table. And keep in mind that this isn't an exact science; some critics had definite rankings, while the order of shows in other lists was a bit fuzzier.

TV Shows with Most Mentions in Year-End Critic Top 10 Lists, 2009
  Show (Network) Genre # 1's Top Ten Lists
1 Mad Men (AMC) Drama 10 20
2 Lost (ABC) Drama 2 14
3 Modern Family (ABC) Comedy 2 13
4 Glee (Fox) Musical 2 12
5 Breaking Bad (AMC) Drama 0 11
5 Friday Night Lights (DirectTV 101/NBC) Drama 0 11
5 Nurse Jackie (Showtime) Comedy/Drama 1 11
8 Big Love (HBO) Drama 0 10
8 Parks and Recreation (NBC) Comedy 1 10
8 True Blood (HBO) Fantasy 1 10
11 Sons of Anarchy (FX) Drama 0 8
12 30 Rock (NBC) Comedy 0 7
12 Dexter (Showtime) Drama 1 7
14 The Good Wife (CBS) Drama 0 6
14 The Office (NBC) Comedy 0 6
16 Chuck (NBC) Action/Comedy 0 5
16 Party Down (Starz) Comedy 0 5
18 Battlestar Galactica (Syfy) Sci-Fi 0 4
18 Curb Your Enthusiasm (HBO) Comedy 1 4
18 The Big Bang Theory (CBS) Comedy 0 4
18 The Middle (ABC) Comedy 0 4
18 Torchwood: Children of Earth (BBC America) Sci-Fi 0 4

The 25 individual Best of 2009 lists used to compile the above data were from (with their #1 overall pick indicated):

The following lists are not included in the results above because they either are divided into multiple categories or offer an alternative take on the year (e.g., worst shows, best episodes, etc.).

What are your favorites?

What are your picks for the best shows of 2009 and the decade? What did the critics miss? (South Park? Family Guy? How I Met Your Mother? House? It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia?) Let us know in the comments section below.

We're sorry, but comments are closed for this article.

Comments (245)

  • Bryan  

    The Mentalist should never be on any best of list. It's a shameless rip-off of Psych. Right now I can't get enough of the Wire and Breaking Bad. I think one day Breaking Bad has the potential to be considered one of the best ever.

  • David S  

    Heres the List
    Drama:
    1. The Wire
    2. LOST
    3. Dexter
    4. The Sopranos
    5. True Blood

    Comedy:
    1. Seinfeld
    2. Curb Your Enthusiasm
    3. The Office (US)
    4. Extras
    5. Friends

  • rob  

    I lost over 60 hours that i will not get back, from watching sopranos. over rated is a under statement. these are my top 10:
    1. lost (one of the best storys)
    2. the wire (awsome characters)
    3. dexter (finale = unthinkable)
    4. oz (best prison show)
    5. 24 (none stop action, acting kinda sucks)
    6. true blood (can't wait to see more)
    7. house (pots always the same, but good acting and writers)
    8. deadwood (finale sucked, but good other than that)
    9. two and a half men 10. bones heroes started off alright, last two season nothing really has happened.

  • TS  

    There's a consensus, Dexter should be on this list.

  • Andrew  

    I agree with Sammy V and the others who think Entourage should've been on the list. The show has been great all six seasons and I can't wait for the 7th to come out. I don't want to make a list, but in my opinion it is just as good as The Sopranos, The Wire and Dexter

  • Sammy V  

    I do think that Entourage deserves some recognition...Jeremy Piven is brilliant as Ari.

  • anonymous  

    WHERE IS THE MENTALIST!!!! THE BEST SHOW EVER WITH SEXY SIMN BAKER

  • Brian L  

    1 Keen Eddie
    2 Firefly
    3 House
    4 Burn Notice
    5 Wiseguy (if we're gonna mention Sienfeld)
    6 24
    7 Chuck (I'm a firefly fan)

    If there were new episodes of Mission Impossible, Streets of San Francisco or the Fugitive I'd be watching those.

  • David  

    In no specific order:-
    Alias
    24
    Dexter
    Southpark!!

  • Anna  

    In my opinion, LOST should be at number one. I know that many people stopped watching the show when it got too confusing for them, and that is impossible for someone to start watching the show now if they haven't seen the previous five seasons, but LOST has provided a whole new kind of show. It makes you think while watching the program, instead of a half-hour or hour of entertainment that vanishes from your head once the next show comes on. LOST should be rated number one, but that is just my opinion.

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/reviews-for-david-lettermans-final-late-show Image
    Episode Review: Late Show With David Letterman Series Finale
    May 21, 2015 - 1 comment
    1. EFYevan : It was a great sendoff for a good, sincere man. As funny Wednesday as he has been ever! Well done Dave and everyone... Read »
  2. /feature/mad-men-series-finale-reviews Image
    Episode Review: Mad Men Series Finale
    May 17, 2015 - 3 comments
    1. hollyhocktoo : I thought Weiner wrote a very sweet ending. Weiner really loves these characters. Don Draper going to a retreat was... Read »
    2. FleshWorld : No, the ending was not a triumph like the Justiified finale was, but it certainly did not harm the series legacy.... Read »
  3. /feature/cw-upfront-2015-16-schedule-and-new-shows Image
    Upfronts: The CW's New Shows and 2015-16 Schedule
    May 14, 2015 - 2 comments
    1. FleshWorld : I'll give legends of tomorrow a shot, I suppose. Read »
  4. /feature/nbc-upfront-2015-16-schedule-and-new-shows Image
    Upfronts: NBC's New Shows and 2015-16 Schedule
    May 10, 2015 - 3 comments
    1. FleshWorld : NBC did a wise thing by hiring the lead actors from Cinemax's "Strike Back" to headline two of its new shows. Read »
  5. /feature/best-movies-of-the-21st-century Image
    The Best Movies of the 21st Century (So Far)
    March 26, 2015 - 11 comments
    1. micic00 : Really? So far? I thought you can see the **** future! Read »
  6. /feature/best-new-tv-shows-of-2014 Image
    The Best (and Worst) New TV Shows of 2014
    December 23, 2014 - 14 comments
    1. sliderh2o : All these shows ( True Detective excluded ) are worthless. You need to do a user top ten, not a sorry ass critic... Read »
  7. /feature/25-best-ps4-games Image
    Quarterly Report: The 25 Best PlayStation 4 Games
    March 31, 2015 - 8 comments
    1. njuttabi : Great collection http://games-gameworld.blogspot.com Read »
  8. /feature/tv-premiere-dates Image
    Summer TV Premiere Calendar
    May 6, 2015 - 42 comments
    1. Splatman : Star Wars Rebels season 2 will premier June 20 at 9pm EST. Read »
  9. /feature/40-video-games-with-disappointing-reviews Image
    Critical Misfires: 40 High-Profile Games with Disappointing Reviews
    October 4, 2012 - 29 comments
    1. leaveit : I guess these games were high-profile, but there is not one on the list that I was surprised about when the reviews... Read »