God of War III: Inside the Reviews

  • Comments: ↓ 22 user comments
  • Publish Date: March 16, 2010

Another great game? It's no myth

The final installment in an action-adventure trilogy that began in 2005 and has sold close to 6 million units worldwide, Sony's God of War III 93 is the best-reviewed PS3 game of 2010. That's no surprise; its predecessors are among the most acclaimed games ever released.

Whereas the first and second games were released for the Playstation 2, GOW3 is the first title in the series (which also spawned a mobile phone game and a PSP prequel, Chains of Olympus 91) designed for the newest-generation console. All GOW games are based on Greek mythology, and the action in GOW3 picks up where GOW2 left off, centering mainly around Mount Olympus.

How does the newest installment in the God of War trilogy compare with its predecessors? As it turns out, the three games match up almost identically in terms of critical reception, as you can see from the comparison below:

Comparing Reviews: God of War Trilogy
 
  God of War God of War II God of War III
Platform / Year Playstation 2 (2005) Playstation 2 (2007) Playstation 3 (2010)
Metascore 94 93 93
User Score 9.0 8.8 9.2
Units Sold 3.21 million 2.61 million ???
"Great" Reviews 69 (92%) 63 (90%) 54 (90%)
"Good" Reviews 5 (7%) 6 (9%) 6 (10%)
"Mixed" Reviews 1 (1%) 1 (1%) 0
"Bad" Reviews 0 0 0

All data is from March 15, 2010. The Metascore is a weighted average of scores from top professional critics, on a scale from 0 (bad) to 100 (good). User Scores represent an average of scores assigned by Metacritic.com site visitors on a scale from 0 (bad) to 10 (good). "Great" reviews have an individual grade of 90 or higher; "good" reviews have grades between 75 and 89; "mixed" represents grades between 50 and 74, and "bad" reviews have grades of 49 or lower.

Here's how God of War III compares to other releases for the PS3 (through March 15th):

2010's Best Games So Far - Playstation 3
  Game Publisher Genre Metascore User Score
1 God of War III Sony Action-Adventure 93 9.2
2 Battlefield: Bad Company 2 Electronic Arts First-Person Shooter 89 9.0
3 BioShock 2 2K Games First-Person Shooter 88 9.0
4 MLB 10: The Show Sony Sports 88 9.7
5 Heavy Rain Sony Adventure 87 6.0

Games must have at least 7 reviews to qualify for the above high score charts. Games are sorted by Metascore prior to rounding.

All-Time Best Platform Exclusive Titles - Playstation 3
  Game Publisher Year Metascore User Score
1 Uncharted 2: Among Thieves Sony 2009 96 9.3
2 LittleBigPlanet Sony 2008 95 6.4
3 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots Konami 2008 94 8.8
4 God of War III Sony 2010 93 9.2
5 Killzone 2 Sony 2009 91 8.3
6 Demon's Souls Atlus USA 2009 89 8.9
7 Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction Sony 2007 89 8.8
8 Uncharted: Drake's Fortune Sony 2007 88 8.8
9 Ninja Gaiden Sigma Tecmo 2007 88 8.1
10 MLB 10: The Show Sony 2010 88 9.7

The above table includes games exclusive to the PS3 console. Games that were ported to PC or to handheld platforms are eligible to be included, as long as the game was never released on a competing console.

Let's take a closer look at what game reviewers are saying about God of War III, to see why it is scoring so highly with critics.

What's different?

God of War III is not a drastic reinvention of the God of War formula -- in fact, it plays very similarly to its predecessors -- so any major newness comes in terms of setting and story.

Chances are, if you were bothered by things like the button-pressing minigames, the puzzles, the linearity, etc. in previous God of War games, God of War 3 isn't going to change your mind. And if you loved them before, get ready for an incredibly well made follow-up in that same template. --1Up

If you were expecting a revolution in terms of design, you'll be sorely disappointed. But, if you simply wanted more of what has made the series so great up to this point, you're going to be quite happy indeed.  --IGN

God of War III sticks to the strengths already established by its predecessors, but what it lacks in innovation it more than makes up for in execution. --GameSpot

What's Better

In general, the many new weapons and combat moves (especially the new "combat grapple" that allows you to grab baddies with your chains) were greatly appreciated by reviewers. And, as expected, the advanced capabilities of the PS3 means that the new title exceeds the heights established by the first two GOW games in some respects.

Everything's bigger, grander and more elaborate. --Eurogamer

God of War  III surpasses the first two God of War games  in almost all possible ways; it has higher production values, high-definition graphics with an outstanding attention to detail, more expansive environments, more characters and enemies than ever, and a deep plot. --Cheat Code Central

God of War III recaptures the one thing that God of War II was missing for me; it forced me to once again reconsider what I thought was possible for a video game to accomplish. --Game Informer

God of War III’s new weapons and powers are better – better-implemented, more useful and much more fun to use than those in previous games. --Games Radar

It's not quite as focused as GOW1, nor is it as lengthy and moment-packed as GOW2, but it's the most consistent and varied of the three, and when it's at its best the first two can't touch it. --1Up

What's Worse

Surprisingly (or not), not much. You won't find too many examples of a game critic talking about God of War III's failings in comparison to the previous installments -- and that's rare for a sequel. If there's one area where the new title doesn't quite match up to the prior games, it is in the story -- and we'll have more on that in just a moment.

Overall concept and story

GOW2 ended in a cliffhanger; GOW3 continues the story from the precise moment where that previous game left off. We won't get into many details about where the story goes -- that's for you to discover -- but if the new game has a weakness, it might be its lack of focus in the story department. Of course, with a game so combat-driven and visceral (that "v" word appears in many reviews, by the way), story isn't a major emphasis to begin with.

[GOW3 delivers] a weak and uneven narrative that's full of plot holes; it's a small vulnerability in an otherwise stellar game. ... There is an admirable attempt made to tie up all the loose ends and give some meaning to Kratos' struggle, but the narrative lacks the sense of momentum and drive that made the series so special.  --GamePro

Despite how relatively simplistic the previous story entries were, they were told extremely well. Everything made sense and there was a clear purpose of what was happening and why. Here, the story (and therefore the game's progression) seems to buckle under its own weight at times. --IGN
The only area where God of War III didn’t blow away my expectations is the story. Previously, Kratos was driven by a thirst for vengeance against a single target – a concept that kept the narrative focused. In God of War III, that singular purpose is diluted by the number of characters, agendas, and objectives on the playing field at once. --Game Informer
The plot manages to derail itself into cheesy, mawkish sentimentality about “hope” more than once. --Games Radar

Remember the titans

A unique feature of God of War III is the size of some of the characters you'll face off against: colossal. Not only must you battle these titans, but they also serve as gameplay environments themselves -- making for some memorable locations that you won't find in other games.

The scope of some of these sequences is nothing short of astounding, with playable sequences that take place on creatures the size of a skyscraper. --IGN

1Up actually finds this part of the game a bit too successful:

That's the unfortunate thing about the titans on the whole, actually -- they make everything else seem less important. Whenever I was indoors solving a puzzle or fighting bosses only twice my height, I wanted to get back outside and see what was going on with the giants on the wall. And since there aren't very many titan levels/fights over the course of the game, I found myself wanting more. 

The ending

When a beloved series concludes its ongoing story, there are bound to be a few complaints, and, indeed, the finale of GOW3 was its weakest part (relatively speaking), according to some critics.

It may not be quite the ending you were hoping for. ... Throw in a viciously cheap final boss and a too-long sequence that steals liberally from Max Payne’s overdose-fueled nightmares, and you’ve got an endgame that skirts awfully close to satisfying, but never quite gets there.

--Games Radar

It falters, certainly, in closing things out as neatly as they began, but the more I thought about the implications of the ending and the series as a whole and what this game has brought to it, I honestly couldn't help but love the end result.

--TotalPlayStation

GamePro is also bothered by the title's "anti-climactic" ending:

That God of War III fumbles the opportunity to leave a deep and lasting impression is especially unfortunate because it's been improved in just about every other way.

As a fan who actually cares about Kratos and his plight, I found it to be a bit of a letdown. Even though I thoroughly enjoyed the journey, I can't help but feel disappointed by the way Kratos chose to say goodbye at the end of it

Not every publication disliked the ending. GameSpot, for one, is a fan, citing GOW3's closing portion as one of its highlights:

For much of the game, the story hits just this one note. But things open up late in the quest, giving the game the heart it so desperately needs. When Kratos reveals a side beyond violent retribution, it makes his character more empathetic and gives the story much more weight. Freed from its overreliance on cold-blooded vengeance, Kratos' story becomes powerful and moving in unexpected ways, peaking in a thrilling conclusion that successfully touches on many different emotions and provides closure for this epic tale.

The Telegraph also loved the conclusion:

The game’s denouement is one of the most exquisitely directed finales you’ll see, bringing the curtain down on a thrilling trilogy.

Gameplay

Gameplay is similar to the first two installments -- and, if anything, it's better than before, with a few enhancements and refinements. Virtually every critic loves the combat mechanics (and the combat itself is even more brutal and bloody than ever).

If you’ve played the previous games in the series, you’ll find everything you love about Kratos’ blade-slinging style intact, but even better than before thanks to the seamless integration of items.

--Game Informer

The gameplay has evolved quite a lot when you really dig into it. It's readily apparent after playing through the God of War Collection and then jumping right into III. --Gaming Age

They've eliminated most of the clutter that plagued the past two titles. --GamePro

Whether you're peppering a harpy with arrows, deftly rolling away from a fire-breathing Cerberus, or countering a sword strike from an undead skeleton, every one of your actions is responsive and entertaining.

--GameSpot

Even players new to the GOW series should be able to jump right in and play.

God of War 3 ... does a fantastic job of instructing you to use -- and swap between -- the various items/weapons/moves. It never feels like you're going through a training sequence, but you remain clearly aware of when it's best to use which of your toys.. --1Up

Although GOW3, like its two predecessors and many other games, utilizes "quick time events" Games Radar, for one, feels they are handled in an unobtrusive manner here, and writes that, overall, the new game is "mercifully short on 'press X to not die' moments." Other publications agree:

Combat is fluid and responsive, and the context-sensitive sequences are even better without the buttons overlaid on top of the action.

--Games Informer

God of War III pulls off another damned-impressive stunt: Making the oft-reviled Button-Press/'Quick-Time Event' seem not only not lame, gimmicky and distracting, but also totally engaging and integrated with the experience.

--Game Revolution

Like other God of War titles, III features an assortment of puzzles in addition to its numerous combat sequences. These were generally well-liked (although Game Daily calls some of them "cookie cutter"), and don't detract from the combat portion of the game.

[The puzzles] while certainly more taxing and better designed than what we saw in the recent Dante's Inferno, aren't brain benders by any stretch of the imagination, but they work well in the context of the game and generally make sense rather than seemingly randomly placed to give players something else to do. --VideoGamer.com

God of War III's puzzles aren't so convoluted that you're left frustrated by overly complex solutions, but also not so easy that the answer becomes painfully apparent as soon as you set foot in a puzzle room.

--Total Video Games

Many reviewers feel that the game is incredibly well-paced overall (the game is, if anything, relentless), and Game Daily, for one, likes its quick start:

Unlike the competition, it doesn't take several hours to get going, or burden the player with laborious upgrades.

On average, the story has been taking reviewers about 10 hours to complete. More than one reviewer suggests that the game has some replay value, although others point out that the additional playtime might not be as compelling as the first play-through.

While there is the opportunity to pick up items throughout your first playthrough that can only be used in subsequent playthroughs (on a higher difficulty), there isn't quite as much depth to inspire a subsequent replay as you might find in Bayonetta, for example. Admittedly though, the traditional Challenge mode and an unlockable Combat Arena do add a few hours of supplementary entertainment.  --Total Video Games

Graphics

Well, there's no need to worry here: many critics are raving about GOW3's visuals, which appear to be in a class of their own. If you own a PS3, it appears that this is the game to put on to show the console off to your friends.

The most impressive visuals this console generation has seen. ... If you leave God of War 3 feeling let down by its visuals, you really need another hobby. --VideoGamer.com

The animation and camera angles make the cut-scenes better than you see in most movies ... the visuals almost make it worth playing on their own. --1Up

Best looking console game ever made? Stablemate Uncharted 2 may have a few words to say, but for sheer scale –where even the vast, scorched backdrops that stretch into the distance are ferociously alive- God of War III is peerless. --Telegraph [UK]

The graphics and camera work are among the very best gaming has to offer. --Game Informer

It's a dazzling visual feast comprised of epic set pieces designed to make you say only one word: wow. --Game Daily

The effects and production values are insane as expected, and the environments and set pieces are pretty much without equal - Uncharted 2 possibly being the exception.

--Gaming Age

There are scenes that look like they were ripped straight out of WETA Digital's render farm with lighting so immaculate that your eyes will drop out of their sockets. --IGN

There are a few minor nitpicks, however. IGN adds:

There are a couple areas of the game that just don't match up to the most impressive stuff, creating an uneven feeling in the visual presentation.

Sound

You'd expect great sound to go with the stellar visuals, and you'd be right.

The audio [is] a dazzling mix of screams, torn flesh and smashed rocks, combined with a Hollywood caliber soundtrack that hits all the right notes, especially during the more dramatic moments.

--Game Daily

The music is as dramatic and memorable as ever, and always a treat to listen to.

--Gaming Age

The vocal cast, which includes Malcolm McDowell, Rip Torn, Linda Hunt, Kevin Sorbo, and Adrienne Barbeau, was also well-received.

Other thoughts

If there's one overriding theme in most of these reviews, it's that God of War III is a truly special game.

Something awesome is constantly happening in God of War III. --Game Informer
God of War 3 is a brutal, blood-soaked experience. --VideoGamer.com
 God of War III is like nothing you've ever seen or experienced in gaming. ... It truly redefines "epic" in shocking and unexpected ways you may not have thought were possible. --Destructoid
There are no branching paths, no complex decisions, and no multiplayer modes, but this particular game is all the better for it, since the results are rich and focused rather than drawn-out and a little ragged. Ultimately, if you want to revel in old-school pleasures decked out in the very brightest new armour, this is about as good as it gets. --Eurogamer

Your take

What do you think of God of War III? How does it compare to the first and second games? If you haven't done so already, feel free to cast your official vote for God of War III, and read the user reviews already posted on Metacritic's page for that game. Or continue the discussion in the comments section below.

We're sorry, but comments are closed for this article.

Comments (22)

  • TMIE  

    It's really funny and sad to see people comparing the bare-bones fighting system of GOW series to complex masterpieces like DMC and Bayonetta. Considering that the GOW series' fighting system is a rip-off of games like Ninja Gaiden & DMC + QTEs. I'm not saying this is a bad game but it's also a game nobody has the guts to be subjective about because PS3 fangirls will get their panties in a bunch.

  • Fautsch  

    Ripping Helios head off with your bare hands and masshing up (spoiler) Zeus's into oblivion until the blood on your screen leaves u blinded is worth what every other game in this genre wishes it could be. Yes I like Violence!! hehe Simply BRUTAL!!

  • pantazis  

    it is one of the best i have ever played.it has superb graphics and the gameplay is the same with the other two.the story it is not so dynamic as the other two but it is still good

  • nicky b  

    all i can say is that i'm truly depressed and saddened after playing gow3!!!.... and why, well this is the last i'll see of kratos and boy will i miss him. this game is a visual feast and i really cant understand how darksiders, bayonetta , devil may cry etc.... can even be mentioned in the same review as gow3. gow3 reigns supreme over very other game in its genre. so a very big thank u to its developers for te ours of plesure this game has giving me!!

  • ReBytes  

    I saw a lot of comments raving about the graphics and the GOW III masterpiece. In my mind GOW III has glimpses of excellence in every department but as a whole its found wanting. Graphics wise the Kratos vs Minotaur kill shows the best graphics ever but the inconsistency in graphics throughout the game is a major let down. White pixels cropping up where 2 walls meet and the addiction of object piercing makes for many disappointments. Character models are inconsistent as can be with most looking like plastic dolls.
    Gameplay wise the most frustrating is the fact that you cannot dodge while you are performing an attack which left me crushed far too often in the game. Only 10 hours of gameplay and then you visit almost every setting in the game twice. The mini-games and puzzles are excellent especially the Echochrome labyrinth.
    The only hype this game was able to deliver is the Empire State building size monster named Cronos but the actual gameplay around it was fun but not that much.
    Darksiders was overall a much better gaming entertainment experience but I would recommend every GOW fanboy to play GOW III. The story is not the best but it is not bad so even non GOW fanboys will be able to enjoy it.
    This game has far too many flaws to warrant a 9/10 or 10/10 score which most magazines write up for it.
    I have written a full review scoring is 69% yes unfortunately I think that is about what it is worth subjectively. You can read my full review at
    http://ps3-downloads.co.uk/ps3-forums/?vasthtmlaction=viewtopic&t=34.0
    and then tell me why you hate me so much. I am just trying to keep it real and subjective

  • tool0420  

    Oh yeah both uncharted's are great too.

  • tool0420  

    GOW3, to me stands next to the other 2 only with better graphics and gameplay. Since I've had a PS3 my top games would be GOW3, both COD modern warfare's and any EA sports game. I now can't wait until MOH comes out.

  • DRUNKCANADIAN  

    @Ricky Damn you're a good troll, got here so fast...

    God of War III is a masterpiece of the action genre, and is a cut above the others...it isn't a button mashing game like DMC or Bayonetta (although Bayonetta was more of spam the same move over and over with some element of tactic, but the story was bad so disregard)...
    As stated, GOWIII is an awesome game, the only reason people could have for disliking it is they are Xbots and can't play the game...or they clearly didn't do any research on the game b4 buying it...it is as the reviewers agree like those b4 it....so quit your QQing....
    ...maybe you should go play FFXIII where you can press x/A and toggle stances while running in a straight line and watching stupid anime cut-scenes....I'm done here...

  • Trae  

    GOW III has easisly krept into my top ten and the series runs a close second to my beloved Resident Evil games. Bravo to the teams that brought us this series. Bravo.........If you have not beat GOW III yet, make sure to watch through the credits.

  • Peter  

    Edge Magazine should be removed from the list of websites.

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/best-iphone-and-ipad-games-of-2014 Image
    The Best iPhone and iPad Games of 2014
    December 17, 2014 - 3 comments
    1. kolin1302 : Who would have thought 2 years ago that an iPad game would become the second most viewed e-sports game worldwide ?... Read »
    2. matteda : yes..this is a good list :) Read »
  2. /feature/vote-for-the-best-of-2014 Image
    Metacritic User Poll: Vote for the Best of 2014!
    December 15, 2014 - 11 comments
    1. vicyamusicgreat : For God's sake, Owen Pallett's In Conflict was too good and Soldiers Rock was most certainly misunderstood: made the... Read »
    2. Duke_Challenger : Best Movie: Interstellar Best TV Show: The Americans Best Album: Dialects by Snowmine Best Song: Bring Me Your... Read »
    3. VincentHaleon : 1989 was awesome. Unbroken fared better than I anticipated. The Vampire Diaries Season is arguably the best season... Read »
  3. /feature/film-critic-top-10-lists-best-movies-of-2014 Image
    Best of 2014: Film Critic Top Ten Lists
    December 6, 2014 - 10 comments
    1. ChrisL75 : @Shiira Lisa S. listed her Top Ten here (haven't seen any sign from OG thus far):... Read »
    2. LCbaseball22 : The individual RogerEbert.com film critic lists have been posted now and Interstellar takes two #1 spots!... Read »
  4. /feature/critics-pick-top-10-albums-of-2014 Image
    Best of 2014: Music Critic Top Ten Lists
    December 2, 2014 - 29 comments
    1. Shiira : If you like Kate Bush, I highly recommend Lydia Ainsworth's "Right From Real". Read »
  5. /feature/best-tv-shows-of-2013-2014-season Image
    Best TV Shows of the 2013-14 Season
    July 22, 2014 - 4 comments
    1. valendrena : Hannibal is another show that despite critical acclaim has yet to get a good fan base, Despite those that are... Read »
  6. /feature/tv-premiere-dates Image
    TV Premiere Calendar for 2014-15
    August 7, 2014 - 17 comments
    1. kac283 : Hart of Dixie returns January 9th Read »