Hardware Review: PlayStation Move

  • Publish Date: September 16, 2010
  • Comments: ↓ 38 user comments

Sept. 17 (6:30p): Added five additional reviews.

What it is

Image
PlayStation Move Reviews
(through Sept. 16)
Great bar 5
Good bar 12
Mixed bar 4
Bad 0
Awful 0

Sony's answer to Nintendo's Wii, the PlayStation Move is a new motion-sensitive controller, scheduled to arrive in stores Friday in North America (and available since Wednesday in Europe). The Move requires the use of the PlayStation Eye camera, which is one of several methods used to track the location and orientation of the controller as you play. That tracking is enabled by the Move's most distinctive feature: a glowing, squishy rubber orb that sits atop the controller.

The controller also provides both tactile and visual feedback -- the former through vibrations, and the latter by changing the color of the orb in response to actions in a game. And, unlike the Wii controllers, there are no AA batteries required; recharging is done via USB cable (or an optional charging station) as with other PS controllers.

Much like the Wii offers a secondary "nunchuk" controller, Sony is also offering an add-on "navigation" controller. Smaller than the main Move motion controller (and, unlike the nunchuk, completely wireless), the nav controller includes a small joystick, a D-pad, and additional buttons. The navigation controller is not required, since you obviously have a DualShock controller sitting around that can be used instead (though the compact nav controller is a lot easier to use while holding in one hand).

Pricing options

Options for purchasing the Move at launch include:

  • One Move controller alone: $49.99
  • Starter bundle of one Move controller + PlayStation Eye + Sports Champions: $99.99
  • Bundle of one Move controller + PS3 console + PlayStation Eye + Sports Champions: $399.99

If you plan on playing any local multiplayer games, you'll quickly realize that you need a second Move controller, so count on spending an extra $50 in addition to the above prices. And, if you do want the navigation controller add-on, it will run you another $30.

Launch titles

Move-enabled games available at launch include:

Before the end of the year, additional titles such as The Fight: Lights Out will hit the market, while previously-released games like Heavy Rain and Tiger Woods PGA Tour 11 will be patched to allow Move control. Hardcore gamers may not be satisfied until 2011, however, when SOCOM 4 and Killzone 3 are set to arrive.

What critics are saying

Read through just a few reviews of the PlayStation Move and you'll notice a clear consensus forming: the Move is far superior to the Wii controller (even with Motion Plus) in terms of accuracy, but a lack of any solid launch titles means that there is no compelling reason to purchase the new controller immediately. Critics also are unanimous in finding the initial setup process a snap.

There's more of a debate over whether button placement is ideal, or if the controller's design will remain comfortable over prolonged periods of gameplay, but most critics are generally appreciative of the Move's ergonomics. Some reviewers also had minor issues with inconsistencies from game to game in the distance you are required to be from the Eye camera. And a common (but again, minor) gripe was the far-too-frequent need to recalibrate the controller while playing most games.

Below is a sampling of the critical response to Sony's new controller. We have grouped the reviews based on the general level of enthusiasm for the product, from most to least positive. If a publication assigned a score to the review, it is listed below (converted to a 100-point scale if necessary for purposes of comparison); otherwise, we did not attempt to assign scores to reviews that did not have them. Click on any publication name to read the full review.

Loved It
Score Publication
90 CVG
It's hard to say whether the Move has much technical prowess over the Wii Motion Plus or whether it's just that the high-end graphics that draw your attention to the finer details. Either way the PlayStation Move feels more responsive, more-sophisticated and generally more in-depth.
90 GamePro
For now, the early read on the Move is that it’s a fantastic piece of equipment that adds an interesting wrinkle to the PS3 experience. Sure, you probably don't need to rush out and get it on initial release, but if Sony plays its cards right, it will eventually become an essential part of the PS3 library.
90 IncGamers
This isn't just a Nintendo rip-off. ... With the use of the camera and the added buttons you feel like it’s the next evolutionary step in motion-controller technology.
n/a Ars Technica
The PlayStation Move is here, ladies and gentleman, and it's pretty damn great. ... It used to be that you'd tolerate the Wii's graphics in order to use its motion controls. Now you don't have to.
n/a PlayStation LifeStyle
The controller acts and reacts with unprecedented accuracy and can be applied to nearly endless applications within games. ... When you finally do pick up a PlayStation Move you’ll realize a few things: this isn’t just another motion controller, it’s precision is unmatched, it’s going to open up a host of new game experiences, and it’s going to revolutionize the PlayStation 3 experience moving forward.
Liked It
Score Publication
85 IGN
At the end of the day, the PlayStation Move has the potential to be the best motion control system on the current crop of consoles; but unfortunately, the games offered at the moment just don't do the technology justice.
80 PCMag
Overall, the PlayStation Move does exactly what it set out to accomplish: bring very accurate motion controls to the PS3. My one issue with the PlayStation Move—and it's less a gripe, and more a fear—is now that Sony supports motion gameplay, many budget-priced, poorly developed motion control shovelware titles that once lived exclusively on the Wii (like Pool Party, for example) will be ported over the system.
80 PlayStation Universe
Move is comfortable, the onboard controls are solid, and its precision is unmatched ... but many of you will likely want to wait until there are a few games on the market you really want to try.
80 TechRadar
The controller is comfortable, but not for really long sessions of hard-swinging games. ... Our single biggest concern is the space required to really go at the games. It won't be an issue for games like MAG and SOCOM, but it could be the difference between whether this or a Wii is more appropriate for your space.
70 Engadget
The success is going to be largely dependent upon the games that support it. What we've seen so far is very promising, but whether or not the $100+ cost of entry will dissuade one too many customers remains to be seen.
60 CNET
To be clear, the PlayStation Move has shown that it's capable of some of the best motion controls we've seen in a game. That said, we're just not sure the launch library of titles provides a compelling reason to spend $100 on the new technology.
n/a Destructoid
My first impressions? Underwhelming. The controller's performance was somewhat iffy, likely skewed a bit by poor lighting and 50-plus Bluetooth controllers all vying for air time. And the software? I already had a Wii, thanks. Yes, I was that guy. But after spending some time with the controller and a batch of software in the comfort of my own living room for the past week or so, my tune has changed. Simply put, I'm impressed by what Sony has to offer; it may have a winner on its hand with PlayStation Move.
n/a Gaming Age
The PlayStation Move is neither as original as the Wii, nor as unique as the Xbox 360 Kinect, but what the Move does, it does well. Surprisingly well. ... It's now up to the software developers to really show off the Move's capabilities, and only that will truly determine if the Move is a hit or a miss.
n/a Guardian
Playing with Move makes it very hard to go back to the relative inaccuracy of the Wii.
n/a Joystiq
I can't help but declare PlayStation Move a resounding success as a piece of consumer technology and general way of interacting with games. ... But considering everything on offer, it's hard not to classify Move as anything more than a "cool toy" at launch. The best of Move is worth experiencing, but is it worthy of a day-one purchase – not to mention the full set of two controllers and a NavCon? No.
n/a Kotaku
The PlayStation Move is a intuitive, natural feeling way to play games and it brings with it not only a sense of increased immersion to already graphically immersive games, but a new way to play with your reality and a refreshing form of colorful feedback.
n/a Telegraph
The wand-style remotes are very easy to use, and offer a level of accuracy and precision that you won't find on the Wii, or on Microsoft's rival system, Kinect.
Mixed Feelings
Score Publication
n/a Christian Science Monitor
While Sony has nailed the feeling of motion-controls, the illusion falls apart if the camera ever loses sight of a controller. This won't be a problem for most people, since games don't ask you to do any behind-the-back tricks. But gamers with small living rooms may want to look elsewhere.
n/a Geek.com
It’s more laggy than Wii and has an annoying reflection issue ... [but] the actual hardware is of a better quality than the Wii Remote and Nunchuck setup. PS Move also has an advantage in its ability to track movement in a 3D space giving it the potential to extend motion gaming beyond what the Wii can offer.
n/a Gizmodo
In the games that I tried, it's just about as accurate as the Wii MotionPlus—which is to say, accurate about 75% of the time, and frustratingly loose the other 25% of the time.
n/a Metro.co.uk
It's not new or at this stage in its life even very exciting. But it doesn't suffer from the potentially crippling limitations of Kinect or Microsoft's refusal to use it with core games.
Didn't Like It
Score Publication
(none)

What do you think?

PlayStation owners: Are you excited about the new Move controller? Let us know in the comments section below.

We're sorry, but comments are closed for this article.

Comments (38)

  • me  

    move is terrible. always out of calibration. Move a little on the couch and its out of calibration. hip fire instead of aiming down the barrel = out of calibration.

  • Ferrous  

    I was a little skeptical about this current round of motion controls. One of my concerns was that the PS3 controls were a copy of the Wii controls. Something I realized is that they are similar much in the same way that our standard current generation game controllers aren't that much different than previous generation game controllers. Technically, the fundamentals of the Xbox 360 controller isn't all that much different than the one used for the Super Nintendo. They both use a directional pad for multi-directional movement, they both have buttons to execute actions. What Xbox (or any current gen system) did though was take the concept of the controller and significantly added to it, with multiple analog joysticks, additional shoulder buttons, and even regular pressure sensative buttons. I can see even further improvements, but I doubt that the concept of a gamepad will ever go away, it is a solid fundamental concept that works.
    This is how I now look at the Playstation Move after trying it out. Nintendo discovered a good fundamental design that I don't think will ever go away. And Sony evolved that fundamental to something that is extremely accurate in a 3D space.
    Just the fact that the tacking is so accurate that the games superimpose tools and items right onto your controller (for example if you are supposed to be holding a sword, a game might superimpose a sword onto your controller in the game so it looks like the Move controller IS a sword on the TV), and that even as you move it around, that it looks like you are really holding that item on the TV is amazing.

  • Keisu  

    The Move shocked me with its accuracy. While the Wii and Kinect mostly are toys the Move can really be used for serious gaming. Sports Champions is awesome, just from the realism of the gameplay, so the lacking environments and characters doesn't even bug me. The only game i want from the kinect is Dance Central.

    Move has also given me daily workout. The boxing game "The Fight: Lights Out" i hope will give me more of a varied workout, since I favor my right arm in sports games. I finished the bronze champions cup of table tennis with my left arm now though. It's amazing!

  • Jon  

    Move is really an outstanding addition to the PlayStation library. The ability to use both the Move or DualShock 3 in many games means several ways to enjoy high-quality experienced. Highly recommended!

  • troublesome  

    "Even my little 12 year old brother think the wii is crap he rather spend his time playing 360 and ps3 like almost everyone else."

    That's because kids at that age are wanting to stay in the 'in-crowd', and with all the emphasis on 'next-generation technology' and 'OMGSHINY graphics' it's no surprise people will find the games on the PS3 and X360 more appealing than the games on the Wii. Unfortunately, most developers are the same way and will continue to ignore the Wii, thus bringing it down even further in the eyes of 'dedicated' gamers. (Psychology FTW!)

    The hardware itself, I've found, is just about as responsive as the Wii Motion Plus, so that was disappointing. We'll see how things develop... but I for one would laugh my head off if all third-party developers started boycotting all three systems to protest the movement to 'interactive gaming', since they deem it to be 'too difficult to program'.

  • Marco  

    I just bought this, and its really cool, i think its better than the wii, but that's only my opinion. I would like more games that are compatible with it tough.

  • Excalibur  

    I had a wii, and liked a few of its games. nothing special though. I largely disliked the control schemes. I sold my Wii to get a PS3 because I didn't like the motion control. I want a system with a controller that I can sit back, and relax with. I don't want some game that I have to jump all around or stand up. That's not what gaming is about. Its suppose to be fun, not an aerobic work out. When I first unpackaged the Playstation Move I was immediately disappointed for the the large price tag and lack of things to show for it. Then, after playing with it for a while, I was only further disappointed on how un-imaginative sony was being. The only thing they could do was knock-off a product that was already made. If you didn't have a wii, try it. If you have a wii, tried it, liked it, or didn't like it, skip the Playstation Move. Its a waste of time and money. Thanks for nothing sony. I though we were friends.

  • Rob  

    Simple truth...try the Move and you'll immediately see the difference. The main thing I'm noticing with all of the comments here is that the Wii fans haven't tried the move. I love my Wii, but that's because of Mario and the rest of the first party gang. While the launch titles are certainly do not do the hardware justice, anyone who's played table tennis for 10 minutes in PS3 Sport Champions will the the "potential" of Move. You all can spout off all you want but let's see you all put your "money where your mouths are"

  • JP  

    Most people don't seem to understand the truth. Maybe the Wiimote is a little inaccurate. Maybe MotionPlus didn't bring across that much of an improvement. But people didn't buy Wii for motion controls alone. It's best selling titles barely use motion controls at all. It's the quality of Nintendo's titles, combined with the low barrier of entry that put the Wii on top. Adding motion controls to the MOAR POWA mentality of the HD generation isn't going to get people to drop their Wiis no more than Xbox's avatars or both HD Twins' addition of trophies/achievements did. It doesn't matter if the Move is well made or not. The games tell the tale, and aside from FPS games (which people seem to enjoy just fine with regular controllers), more accurate motion isn't going to make motion control gaming any better than Nintendo has already made it starting 4 years ago.

    I own a PS3 and a Wii, and I already have a PS Eye, but I will not be buying the Move. I already have a Wii and I love it, so I don't see the point.

  • Anon  

    Anyone who thinks this will be successful in anyway and that it isn't a knockoff of the Wii is sorely blinded by obscure love to Sony.

    It looks the same + a stupid light ball.

    Fail.

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/predict-the-2016-emmy-awards Image
    Predict the 2016 Emmy Award Winners
    July 19, 2016 - 5 comments
    1. zembowerboy : Still bitter that Denis O'Hare didn't get a nom for his fantastic work in AHS: Hotel. Super stoked that this is... Read »
    2. Hufter : The Americans, all over. Far out Read »
    3. aydge89 : American Crime deserves to win best limited series along with Felicity Huffman or Lili Taylor for best actress. The... Read »
    4. emilyay : I also want Mr. Robot to win. It was one of the best first season of any show I've ever seen. It had flaws, but it... Read »
    5. DanBurrito : I want Mr. Robot to win best drama. Most engaging and addictive tv show in recent memory. Read »
  2. /feature/68th-primetime-emmy-award-nominations Image
    2016 Emmy Nominations
    July 14, 2016 - 5 comments
    1. DetonNation : Yes. What about Penny Dreadful. Besides Eva Green, every actor in the series put in a ground-breaking performance... Read »
  3. /feature/summer-movie-metascore-predictions-2016 Image
    Your Metascore Predictions for 30 Summer Movies
    May 4, 2016 - 23 comments
    1. Blanche : Seems that the user scores are - usually - far more accurate to the predicted score as per normal. Read »
  4. /feature/now-streaming-on-amazon-instant-video Image
    What to Watch Now on Amazon Instant Video
    July 20, 2016 - 6 comments
    1. MaryJames007 : thank you for the info. I waited for this amazon feature for a long time. http://www.how-to-program-in-java.com/ Read »
  5. /feature/tv-premiere-dates Image
    2016 Summer/Fall TV Premiere Calendar
    May 10, 2016 - 112 comments
    1. SuburbanGal : FOOD NETWORK'S CAMP CUTTHROAT - Premieres Wednesday August 24, 2016 @ 10 PM Read »
  6. /feature/dexter-series-finale-reviews Image
    Episode Review: Dexter Series Finale
    September 22, 2013 - 8 comments
    1. jldavis : It's been days since I finished watching the eight seasons of Dexter. To say that the finale left me unsettled is an... Read »