Ranked: Best and Worst Horror Videogames

  • Comments: ↓ 123 user comments
  • Publish Date: October 25, 2010

Worst horror games for any platform

Next, let's look at the games that put the horrible in horror (or something like that) -- the lowest-scoring horror games in our database. As it turns out, videogames based on horror films are no different than most games based on other types of movies: they tend to be low quality releases, and though several such horror movie adaptations are on the list below, many more narrowly missed inclusion. The list also includes some poorly-executed originals and some sub-par sequels to better games.

Remember, when a game has been released on multiple platforms, we have averaged the scores together and denoted such scores with an asterisk.

The Worst-Reviewed Horror Videogames

(tie) 1. Vampire Rain 34* (Ignition/AQ, 2008)

Released for:
xbox Xbox 360 38
playstation PlayStation 3 30
Image

"Watching a B-movie can be cheesy good fun. Playing and paying money for one ... that's a nightmare."

-- Official Xbox Magazine

The PS3 version boasts the somewhat longer title "Vampire Rain: Altered Species," but it's the same lousy stealth action game on both platforms.

(tie) 1. Land of the Dead: Road to Fiddler's Green 34* (Groove Games, 2005)

Released for:
pc PC 36
xbox Xbox 32
Image

"Land of the Dead fails to deliver even the most garden-variety of zombie-killing thrills, due to its inept combat, awful visuals, and cripplingly stupid artificial intelligence."

-- GameSpot

While George A. Romero's movies are deservedly acclaimed by horror fans, the same can't be said about many of the games based on those movies. Designed as a prequel to the film Land of the Dead, Fiddler's Green did offer both single-player and multiplayer modes, though most critics felt that the proper number of players should be zero.

3. Shellshock 2: Blood Trails 35* (Eidos Interactive, 2009)

Released for:
pc PC 40
playstation PlayStation 3 35
xbox Xbox 360 30
Image

"Shellshock 2: Blood Trails is the answer to the question that no one was asking. What if there were zombies in the Vietnam War?"

-- Cheat Code Central

While the first Shellshock was a conventional (though mediocre) third-person shooter set during the Vietnam War, this sequel decided to make things more "interesting" by adding zombies. And by "interesting," we mean "idiotic."

4. Escape from Bug Island 37 (Eidos Interactive, 2007)

Released for:
wii Wii 37
Image

"Escape from Bug Island is a dismal reminder of the low points of survival horror's past."

-- GameSpot

You'll want to make a quick escape from this Wii-exclusive survival horror title, which critics found repetitive and boring despite (or perhaps because of) the presence of giant insects.

5. Dead Space Ignition 38* (Electronic Arts, 2010)

Released for:
xbox Xbox 360 39
playstation PlayStation 3 36
Image

"Ignition's narrative is as static as it is boring and Hollywood-horror generic."

-- Cheat Code Central

While the original Dead Space just missed the cut for our list of best-reviewed horror games, this downloadable "interquel" (which takes place before the events of next year's Dead Space 2) is a hybrid of puzzle game and interactive comic that comes up short on both counts with its tedious hacking mini-games, lousy story, and poor graphics.

6. Painkiller: Resurrection 38 (DreamCatcher Interactive, 2009)

Released for:
pc PC 38
Image

"A host of problems ensure this is one of the worst games of 2009. "

-- IGN

The 2004 first-person "horror shooter" Painkiller should never have been resurrected for this stand-alone expansion, which critics found amateurish and buggy.

(tie) 7. Resident Evil: Survivor 39 (Capcom, 2000)

Released for:
playstation PlayStation 39
Image

"The scariest thing about this game is how awful it is."

-- GamePro

Like any series, Resident Evil has had its share of ups and downs, though its nadir came with this 2000 title, a tedious first-person zombie shooter with little to recommend it.

(tie) 7. Onechanbara: Bikini Samurai Squad 39 (D3, 2009)

Released for:
xbox Xbox 360 39
Image

"Cleavers and cleavage, sadly, aren't enough."

-- G4 TV

While it seems like any game subtitled "Bikini Samurai Squad" would be a critical and commercial smash, this horrific hack-n-slash title offers little other than mindless button-mashing and skimpy outfits.

(tie) 7. Ju-on: The Grudge 39 (Xseed, 2009)

Released for:
wii Wii 39
Image

"It'll scare you a couple times, but they're just cheap scares that even the lowest budget B movie would be embarrassed to have to resort to."

-- Kombo

The Japanese horror film scared audiences enough to spawn both an American remake (and its sequel) and this videogame adaptation, exclusive to the Wii. Designed as an episodic "haunted house simulator," the game offered players little to do and even less time to do it in.

10. Evil Dead: Hail to the King 47* (THQ, 2000)

Released for:
playstation PlayStation 51
dreamcast Dreamcast 49
pc PC 40
Image

"A waste of an excellent license and a great opportunity."

-- Daily Radar

One of four games based on Sam Raimi's Evil Dead movie series, Hail to the King is set eight years after the events in Army of Darkness. But the game suffered mightily in comparison to Resident Evil, with critics finding Evil Dead's gameplay and controls inadequate, though the title did a decent job at capturing the atmosphere of the films.

What do you think?

What are your favorite and least favorite horror games? What is the scariest moment you've ever encountered in a game? Let us know in the discussion section below.

We're sorry, but comments are closed for this article.

Comments (123)

  • Jordan  

    Should probably get someone that knows something about videogames to write this...I would 6 of the top 10 games Metascores are inaccurate because of them being very old, not to mention some games (Plants vs. Zombies and Demon's Souls) arent exactly horror yet they are listed as top 5. In my opinion, Dead Space and Condemned 2 have been the scariest games Ive ever played, with Resident Evil 4 in close competition.

  • Doug  

    This article is poorly researched. Amnesia the current PC game is easily one of the best horror games ever made. The rest of the Penumbra series certainly beats out almost all the castlevania games. Even indigo prophecy is more horrific than 90% of the crap you put on this list...miserable miserable article.

  • Johnfreeman45  

    Is the title "Shocks for your system" an accident?
    System Shock is easily the best of all time and its not even in the list. Why would the title allude to it without it even being mentioned?

  • Matty  

    I would say favorites RE2 or the RE1 remake for the game cube, as the only thing horrifying in RE1 for PS1 was the voice acting. Least favorite probably Alone in the Dark Inferno.

  • Pattysin  

    Is this a joke? Half of these games aren't even horror. Bioshock can hardly be counted as horror. Castlevania has never been a horror genre. Left 4 Dead has zombies but isn't presented as a horror at all (this last one may be debatable). Please get someone who actually plays games to make a list instead of searching for random metacritic scores for games that contain the word "horror" in the review.

  • Eganil  

    Once again, I follow a link to an "article" on Metacritic hoping it will bring me informative details about something I wouldn't already know everything about and once again I am sorely disappointed. Just like every other top 10 you guys put out there, one has to wonder what are your selective criterias beyond the Metascore and if the "reviewer " even knows what he/she's talking about or has done a bit of research prior to writing the article. What about Call Of Cthulu: Dark Corners of the Earth? What about Cold Fear? Where is Silent Hill 2? And what are the Castlevania titles doing here! They're good games but have nothing to do with Horror!
    when will Metacritic stop writing articles that haven't been researched or documented? Or , if you insist on doing so, when will you hire REAL writers?

  • Kirby  

    Agree with you entirely Jordan. RE4 was my first memorable survival-horror game. Both Condemned games scared the bejesus out of me (especially the school mission in the first game... gave me nightmares). But Dead Space easily tops my personal list of horror; best atmosphere ever in a horror game.

  • Z3r0  

    Bioshock as number 1, is that scary? cmon! what about SH3 or even SH1? or even the old alone in the dark series (not alone in the dark inferno, that just crap), and resident evil isnt so much for scares or chills...

    Cmon guys, play at least the games and not read the counter part of the box!

  • Connor  

    Yeah, Amnesia just came out. That demo is scarier than any game on that list. I would also call RE4 just more of a third person action game and while Plants Vs. Zombies is awesome, that game is not a horror game by any stretch of the imagination. I can rally behind Demon Souls though. While I have never played it, the atmosphere and the difficulty can scare the poop out of people.

  • Guido  

    Agreed everybody. I read this in opes of finding a game I might not have known about, and instead found myself questioning what I knew. I woudl say that Silent Hill should be on here for sure, I dont care which one you pick. The Penumbra series also deserves a note. I would also like to place the Fatal Frame series on here, and although technically misguided at times, Clock Tower messed me up for a few days.

New in Metacritic Features

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/best-video-games-of-2014 Image
    The Best Videogames of 2014
    December 22, 2014 - 3 comments
    1. JRath : In all honesty, it was a rather disappointing year in gaming. Many of the most anticipated titles (i.e. Destiny,... Read »
    2. tucotuti : PS.: A shame that only three NEW games (Dark Souls 2, Bayonetta 2 and Smash 4) received more than 90. Read »
    3. tucotuti : It was a very weak year for gaming, especially for XOne and PS4, so in my opinion the WiiU deserved to win GOTY.... Read »
  2. /feature/vote-for-the-best-of-2014 Image
    Metacritic User Poll: Vote for the Best of 2014!
    December 15, 2014 - 14 comments
    1. Atermi : Best movie: never saw any 2014 movie Best album: never listened to any 2014 album Best song: never heard any 2014... Read »
    2. easybreezy248 : best movie: by far boyhood and nightcrawler best album: St. Vincent best tv show: Hannibal best video game: PT... Read »
  3. /feature/2014-golden-globe-nominations Image
    2014 Golden Globe Nominations
    December 11, 2014 - 8 comments
    1. easybreezy248 : Hannibal is x10 better than all the shows nominated. Read »
  4. /feature/film-critic-top-10-lists-best-movies-of-2014 Image
    Best of 2014: Film Critic Top Ten Lists
    December 6, 2014 - 13 comments
    1. DreamScreen : Seriously? Pulling the "How Green Was My Valley" card? Most cinephiles (and certainly non-cinephiles) recognize that... Read »
    2. Mike_M : Good grief.... Boyhood is a good movie ONLY in premise: "Let's shoot a kid for 12 years!" How anyone enjoyed... Read »
    3. herbalalami : we were pleased to visit this website, greetings from our visit jelly gamat gold-g Read »
  5. /feature/movie-awards-and-nominations-2014 Image
    Best of 2014: Film Awards & Nominations Scorecard
    December 1, 2014 - 5 comments
    1. DasCinema : Some of this list is not up-to-date. For instance, Keira Knightley has two wins and eleven nominations, which brings... Read »