The Oscar Nominations: Metacritic Users vs. The Experts

  • Publish Date: February 2, 2010
  • Comments: ↓ 2 user comments

Well, that was easy

So much for suspense. This year's Academy Award nominations went, well, almost exactly as predicted -- by the experts, and by our users.

We had invited Metacritic users to predict the nominees in four categories (best picture, director, and the two lead acting categories), and we compiled the results to form a consensus (below), which would then be pitted against a variety of expert picks. But with conventional wisdom about the eventual nominees so firmly entrenched, there were few differences among the experts -- or our users.

That said, congratulations are still in order, as Metacritic users correctly guessed 24 out of the 25 nominees in the four major categories, a figure matched by a few experts but topped by none. Pitted against our users were a variety of film industry experts and websites who regularly write about the Oscars and other awards:

Overall Results
Category Metacritic Users CS
(Douglas)
ATWI
(Feinberg)
EW
(Karger)
LAT/GD
(O'Neil)
AD
(Stone)
IC
(Tapley)
INDIEWIRE
Best Picture 9 9 9 8 9 8 9 9
Director 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
Lead Actress 5 4 5 5 5 5 5 5
Lead Actor 5 5 5 5 4 5 5 5
# CORRECT: 24 23 24 23 23 23 24 24
% CORRECT: 96% 92% 96% 92% 92% 92% 96% 96%

Below, each expert's individual predictions are compared to the actual results in the four categories.

Best Picture (y = correct pick; n = incorrect pick)
Nominee Metacritic Users CS
(Douglas)
ATWI
(Feinberg)
EW
(Karger)
LAT/GD
(O'Neil)
AD
(Stone)
IC
(Tapley)
INDIEWIRE
Avatar y y y y y y y y
The Blind Side     y          
District 9 y y y y y y y y
An Education y y y y y y y y
The Hurt Locker y y y y y y y y
Inglourious Basterds y y y y y y y y
Invictus n n n n n n n n
Precious y y y y y y y y
A Serious Man y y     y   y y
Star Trek       n   n    
Up y y y y y y y y
Up in the Air y y y y y y y y
# CORRECT: 9 9 9 8 9 8 9 9
Director
Nominee Metacritic Users CS
(Douglas)
ATWI
(Feinberg)
EW
(Karger)
LAT/GD
(O'Neil)
AD
(Stone)
IC
(Tapley)
INDIEWIRE
Kathryn Bigelow y y y y y y y y
James Cameron y y y y y y y y
Lee Daniels y y y y y y y y
Jason Reitman y y y y y y y y
Quentin Tarantino y y y y y y y y
# CORRECT: 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
Lead Actress
Nominee Metacritic Users CS
(Douglas)
ATWI
(Feinberg)
EW
(Karger)
LAT/GD
(O'Neil)
AD
(Stone)
IC
(Tapley)
INDIEWIRE
Emily Blunt   n            
Sandra Bullock y y y y y y y y
Helen Mirren y   y y y y y y
Carey Mulligan y y y y y y y y
Gabourey Sidibe y y y y y y y y
Meryl Streep y y y y y y y y
# CORRECT: 5 4 5 5 5 5 5 5
Lead Actor
Nominee Metacritic Users CS
(Douglas)
ATWI
(Feinberg)
EW
(Karger)
LAT/GD
(O'Neil)
AD
(Stone)
IC
(Tapley)
INDIEWIRE
Jeff Bridges y y y y   y y y
George Clooney y y y y y y y y
Daniel Day-Lewis         n      
Colin Firth y y y y y y y y
Morgan Freeman y y y y y y y y
Jeremy Renner y y y y y y y y
# CORRECT: 5 5 5 5 4 5 5 5

Coming soon

Okay, Metacritic users: that was too easy, so let's try something more challenging. Within the next few days (after we set up our new, easier-to-use voting system), we'll supersize our prediction system and ask you to forecast the actual winners in all 24 Oscar categories, to see if you can out-guess an even larger panel of experts.

We're sorry, but comments are closed for this article.

Comments (2)

  • Confused  

    So...this doesn't make any sense. How can everyone choose every option and have every option be the correct pick?

  • Pearl  

    Yea to Metacritic users!!!

New in Metacritic Features

  1. This Week's New Movie Trailers
    Film Friday (1/20): This Week's New Movie Trailers Image
    Published: January 20, 2017
  2. What Movie Should I See This Weekend? Image
    Published: January 19, 2017
  3. Metacritic Users Pick the Best of 2016 Image
    Published: January 5, 2017
  4. The Best Movies of 2016 Image
    Published: January 4, 2017
  5. The 15 Worst Movies of 2016 Image
    Published: January 3, 2017
  6. 10 Films to See in January Image
    Published: December 30, 2016
  7. What to Watch Now on Amazon Instant Video Image
    Published: December 22, 2016
  8. This Week's New Movie Trailers
    Film Friday (12/16): This Week's New Movie Trailers Image
    Published: December 16, 2016

What Our Users Are Talking About

  1. /feature/most-anticipated-albums-of-2017 Image
    2017 Music Preview: 100+ Notable Upcoming Albums
    January 10, 2017 - 9 comments
    1. applemapsfan : What about These New Puritans? Nothing from them this year? Couldn't find it. Read »
    2. waltermace : Goldfrapp have been teasing a new release since the beginning of the year. And Róisín Murphy was back in the studio... Read »
    3. Kaprawiec : Well Im waiting for something fresh from Watkin Tudor Jones / Anri du Toit. Everything else seems just meh. Now I go... Read »
    4. nathansoderberg : New Fleet Foxes, National, LCD Soundsystem, Sigur Ros, Beck and Arctic Monkeys?! Yes, please. Read »
    5. ajax7 : Ok, first, Sheezus was a great album. Secondly, Katy Perry's upcoming album will be her fourth, not fifth. Read »
    6. Pdfortune : The once great U2 has put out weak albums for quite a while, and I kept buying the non free ones. I'm not accepting... Read »
  2. /feature/users-pick-the-best-of-2016 Image
    Metacritic Users Pick the Best of 2016
    January 5, 2017 - 8 comments
    1. benwatches : PLEASE restore our ability to see user scores on sorted lists of movies (the old format allowed this, and still does... Read »
  3. /feature/2016-film-awards-and-nominations-scorecard Image
    Best of 2016: Film Awards & Nominations Scorecard
    November 29, 2016 - 21 comments
    1. TheLillypop : You guys forgot custom designers guild awards nominees and Hawaii Film Critics Society awards nominees and winners!... Read »
    2. ashrock : Denver http://www.steamboattoday.com/news/2017/jan/16/moonlight-leads-denver-film-critics-society-awards/ Read »
  4. /feature/tv-premiere-dates Image
    2017 Winter/Spring TV Premiere Calendar
    December 15, 2016 - 138 comments
    1. cmcino : The Arrangement (New series) - March 5 @ 10p on E! Read »