CNET Networks Entertainment GameSpot | GameFAQs | SportsGamer | Metacritic | MP3.com | TV.com
Home | About Metacritic | About Metascores | What's New | Wireless Versions | Discussion Forums | Advertising Inquiries | Contact Us | RSS
Metacritic.com: We Deal With Criticism
     Help
> Switch to Advanced Search  
Film Video/DVD Music Games TV

Film

Upcoming Release Calendar
Weekend Box Office
Film Awards & Top 10s By Year
All-Time High Scores
All-Time Low Scores
How Metascores Are Calculated
Discuss Film In Our Forums

 

Wide Releases

sort by name sort by score

Stars indicate the most critically-acclaimed movies.

 

Limited Releases

sort by name sort by score

85 Alexandra
40 America the Beautiful
66 American Teen
74 Anita O'Day: The Life of a Jazz Singer
65 August Evening
xx Bachna Ae Haseeno
62 Baghead
58 Beautiful Losers
xx Beer for My Horses
47 Before the Rains
80 Bigger, Stronger, Faster*
56 Bottle Shock
75 Boy A
55 Bra Boys
61 Brick Lane
64 Brideshead Revisited
47 Burn After Reading
61 Bustin' Down the Door
49 Children of Huang Shi, The
54 CSNY: Déjà Vu
xx Cthulhu
86 Edge of Heaven, The
66 Elegy
52 Elsa & Fred
80 Encounters at the End of the World
26 Everybody Wants to Be Italian
64 Fall, The
86 Flight of the Red Balloon, The
82 Frozen River
71 Girl Cut in Two, A
62 Girls Rock!
xx Goal II: Living the Dream
73 Gonzo: The Life and Work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson
54 Hamlet 2
25 Hell Ride
44 Henry Poole is Here
76 I Served the King of England
72 I.O.U.S. A
63 In Search of a Midnight Kiss
46 Jack Brooks: Monster Slayer
67 Jellyfish
62 Kabluey
63 Kit Kittredge: An American Girl
78 Last Mistress, The
50 Last Stop for Paul
70 Love Songs
61 Man Named Pearl, A
89 Man on Wire
62 Mister Foe
85 Momma's Man
74 Mongol
46 My Mexican Shivah
80 Order of Myths, The
66 Patti Smith: Dream of Life
54 Ping Pong Playa
77 Pool, The
72 Priceless
61 Red
71 Roman de gare
78 Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired
51 Savage Grace
55 Save Me
73 Secret, A
57 Sixty Six
58 Sukiyaki Western Django
xx Surfer, Dude
83 Tell No One
56 Then She Found Me
71 To the Limit
72 Transsiberian
81 Trouble the Water
83 U2 3D
86 Up the Yangtze
79 Visitor, The
61 Wackness, The
54 What We Do Is Secret
66 When Did You Last See Your Father?
67 XXY
54 Year of the Fish
xx Young People F**king
75 Young@Heart

Stars indicate the most critically-acclaimed movies.

 



Printer-Friendly Version Email This Page Discuss In Our Forums

Criminal
Warner Bros.

Criminal reviews
Critic Score
Metascore: 61 Metascore out of 100
User Score  
5.4 out of 10
based on 35 reviews
Read critic reviews
How did we calculate this?
based on 9 votes
Read user comments
Rate this movie

MPAA RATING: R for language

Starring John C. Reilly, Diego Luna, Maggie Gyllenhaal, Jonathan Tucker, Peter Mullan, Zitto Kazann, Maeve Quinlan, and Brent Sexton

Set in Los Angeles over the course of 24 hours, Criminal follows a day in the life of two smalltime bunco artists who stumble upon a foolproof, and extremely lucrative, scam. (Warner Bros.)


GENRE(S): Drama  |  Suspense/Thriller  
WRITTEN BY: Gregory Jacobs
Steven Soderbergh
Fabián Bielinsky (film Nueve Reinas)
 
DIRECTED BY: Gregory Jacobs  
RELEASE DATE: DVD: April 12, 2005 
Theatrical: September 10, 2004 
RUNNING TIME: 87 minutes, Color 
ORIGIN: USA 

What The Critics Said

All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...

80
LA Weekly Scott Foundas
The cast is brilliant, not least of all Reilly -- vaguely despicable, smooth as an oil slick and altogether mesmerizing in the most impressive screen performance he's yet given.
Read Full Review
80
Los Angeles Times Carina Chocano
Captures Los Angeles in a straightforward, naturalistic way, neighborhood-hopping like a native.
Read Full Review
75
ReelViews James Berardinelli
A respectable caper movie in the tradition of "The Sting" and David Mamet's "Heist."
Read Full Review
75
New York Daily News Jami Bernard
The movie is fast and fun. Best of all are the actors, who likewise seem to know they've lucked into a rare good gig.
Read Full Review
75
Baltimore Sun Chris Kaltenbach
The performances of Luna and, especially, Reilly, make the film more enthralling than it perhaps deserves to be.
Read Full Review
75
Boston Globe Wesley Morris
Just as exciting and socially vivid as Bielinsky's. Yet, somehow it's more stressful. The American characters practically sweat desperation.
Read Full Review
75
Philadelphia Inquirer Carrie Rickey
Apart from Luna's exquisitely subtle performance, Criminal's strongest suit is the so-artless-it's-artful cinematography by Chris Menges, which gives the impression of being shot by a fly on the wall. Similarly, Alex Wurman's jazz-infused score contributes to the improvisational atmosphere.
Read Full Review
75
New York Post Lou Lumenick
Jacobs keeps the action moving rapidly and gets solid performances from an ensemble cast, especially the rumpled Reilly.
Read Full Review
70
New York Magazine Peter Rainer
Taut and straightforward and a little grungy, which is how these movies ought to be.
Read Full Review
70
Washington Post Ann Hornaday
The main reason to see Criminal isn't for the mental workout it might offer but simply to watch these two appealing performers act and act and act.
Read Full Review
70
Washington Post Desson Thomson
Reilly and Luna make a chemically appealing screen team. Reilly, one of the best working actors in the indie side of things, is wonderfully world-weary, manipulative and roguishly charming.
Read Full Review
70
The New York Times Stephen Holden
Even with its tepid lead performance, Criminal is a clever and diverting caper film. At least, it is as long as you don't think too hard about it.
Read Full Review
67
Austin Chronicle Marjorie Baumgarten
Movies about cons, if well done, are hard to resist – and such is the case with Criminal.
Read Full Review
67
Entertainment Weekly Lisa Schwarzbaum
The performances are winning -- Gyllenhaal is particularly sharp as an aggrieved sibling, and there's mutual zing in her scenes with Reilly.
Read Full Review
67
Portland Oregonian Karen Karbo
The resulting film, while derivative, is worth the price of admission.
Read Full Review
63
Premiere Aaron Hillis
Subtly gaining momentum as it dexterously glides through pages of good-time, snappy dialogue, Criminal offers no time to catch your breath, let alone enough to think through its reality-stretching story flaws and subtext-lacking motives.
Read Full Review
63
USA Today Mike Clark
The casting falters on every level compared with Queens.
Read Full Review
63
The Globe and Mail (Toronto) Liam Lacey
Jacobs is a competent director but he doesn't bring anything extra to this shell game of a narrative.
Read Full Review
63
Chicago Sun-Times Roger Ebert
Since you have probably not seen "Nine Queens," Criminal will be new to you, and I predict you'll like the remake about as much as I liked the original -- three stars' worth. If, however, you've seen "Nine Queens," you may agree that some journeys, however entertaining, need only be taken once.
Read Full Review
60
Chicago Reader Jonathan Rosenbaum
The filmmakers have lovingly retained and expanded on that film's only flaws, some implausible plot details. But even without the same cultural significance, it's still a good story, and the interesting cast.
Read Full Review
60
The Hollywood Reporter Frank Scheck
Although Criminal retains its source material's cleverness and intricate plotting, something seems to have been lost in the translation.
Read Full Review
60
Variety Ken Eisner
More a tribute than a remake, Steven Soderbergh-approved take on Argentine hit "Nine Queens" isn't quite as sharp or surprising as the original, one of the best scam pics of the past decade.
Read Full Review
60
Village Voice Mark Holcomb
He (Jacobs) and cinematographer Chris Menges compose the film largely in close-ups, and the effect is appropriately unnerving. Regardless, unfavorable comparisons to "Nine Queens" are inevitable.
Read Full Review
60
Empire Adam Smith
Apart from an irritating plot glitch this is a solidly entertaining ride, more than competently directed and played.
Read Full Review
60
TV Guide Maitland McDonagh
The remake is infinitely more entertaining if you haven't seen "Nine Queens" -- the details are different, but the surprises are the same and something of the first film's underlying darkness has been lost in translation.
Read Full Review
58
Seattle Post-Intelligencer Paula Nechak
The film is inherently calculated and cold, so smugly satisfied with itself and its surprise final trick that it seems to be running its own con to convince us the script's house of cards is actually substantial, original and slick.
Read Full Review
50
Dallas Observer Bill Gallo
This plodding mediocrity displays none of the flair or the compelling trickery that enlivened its 2002 prototype.
Read Full Review
50
Christian Science Monitor David Sterritt
Effective at times, and Gyllenhaal shows a new side of her talent, but the main impression is of first-rate performers doing second-rate work.
Read Full Review
50
Rolling Stone Peter Travers
Here's the problem: The movie was made just four years ago by Argentinian director Fabian Bielinsky. It is called "Nine Queens," and it is vastly superior to this blah U.S. remake from director Gregory Jacobs.
Read Full Review
50
Chicago Tribune Sid Smith
Criminal is an exercise where viewers are likely to ponder not "How did the characters do it?" but "Who cares?"
Read Full Review
50
The Onion (A.V. Club) Scott Tobias
Without any glimmers of depth or subtext.
Read Full Review
50
San Francisco Chronicle Carla Meyer
The problems lie not with the actors but with a glib approach that exposes the flaws of the original story.
Read Full Review
50
Charlotte Observer Lawrence Toppman
In the end, coincidence undoes Criminal.
Read Full Review
50
Miami Herald Rene Rodriguez
Criminal is happy to reprise Fabian Bielinsky's original note for note, and it's a listless, dutiful affair -- a cover version played out of obligation, not inspiration.
Read Full Review
50
Film Threat Christopher Zinsli
Can be fun. Just don’t think about it too hard.
Read Full Review

What Our Users Said

Vote Now!The average user rating for this movie is 5.4 (out of 10) based on 9 User Votes
Note: User votes are NOT included in the Metascore calculation.

daniel wtf gave it a0:
Yet another Hollywood remake ruining an authentic foreign masterpiece. Now they are after 'My Sassy Girl', a Korean masterpiece that redefined the industry standard of romantic comedies.

Gabi B. gave it a1:
Horrible compared to the original. Stop running from subtitles and go watch a much better actor, Ricardo Darin, star in a much better movie.

Chuck gave it an8:
A huge percentage of viewers will have never seen "Nine Queens", so why rate it in comparison? It's a very fun movie on its own, and those who complain about holes in the plot have no imagination.

Keiko G. gave it a10:
I loved this film. It was great. John C. Reily Oscar caliber performance.

Si Caro gave it a10:
This is a great film. I loved it.

Alex V. gave it a 3:
Every single aspect is inferior to the original. Pretty bad directed and miscasted. Go for the real thing, find the Queens...

Jay W. gave it a 6:
Highly contrived plot detracts from Reilly's outstanding performance. Just when it seems that Reilly is morphing into something that resembles a human being he pulls a totally unnecessary and dangerous trick, right in public no less. Sometimes less is more.

Read more user comments...

Discuss this movie in our forums

Return to top of page
Home | FILM | DVD/VIDEO | MUSIC | GAMES | TV | Forums | About Metacritic metacritic.com

Popular on CBS sites: Fantasy Football | Miley Cyrus | MLB | iPhone 3G | GPS | Recipes | Shwayze | NFL

About CNET Networks | Jobs | Advertise

© 2008 CNET Networks, Inc., a CBS Company. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use