Four Feathers, The

New York Post Lou Lumenick

Splendidly spectacular, intelligent and very well-acted.

New Times (L.A.) Gregory Weinkauf

Has a lot to offer as grand entertainment, from surprising battle sequences (plenty of terror, virtually no gore, brief and tasteful digital enhancement) to fine performances.

The Onion (A.V. Club) Nathan Rabin

Ledger is a charismatic, conflicted hero who internalizes his character's shame and anguish to powerful effect. Wes Bentley is similarly strong as Ledger's best friend turned romantic rival, and Kapur makes the most of Africa's breathtaking desert, crafting a gorgeous spectacle that's at once stately and hyper-real.

Christian Science Monitor David Sterritt

The Four Feathers ends on the same dubious note as "Black Hawk Down" and other recent war movies, suggesting that loyalty in the trenches -- not the reason for fighting in the first place -- is all that matters. Many will disagree.

Chicago Tribune Michael Wilmington

At its best, this new film does mix grandeur with skepticism, excitement with reflection. In the end, like Harry, it redeems itself.

Seattle Post-Intelligencer William Arnold

When a filmmaker heavy-handedly imposes his contemporary values on a classic of popular art, it's devilishly hard not to destroy or invalidate the very thing that made it a classic.

New York Daily News Jack Mathews

Ultimately, The Four Feathers is strong where its predecessors were weak (in the authenticity of combat) and weak where they were strong (in the larger-than-life quality of the characters). It's not a good exchange.

Miami Herald Rene Rodriguez

What The Four Feathers lacks is genuine sweep or feeling or even a character worth caring about.

Charlotte Observer Lawrence Toppman

Kapur’s contradictory feelings about his material result in a movie that works against itself. As righteous and consistent as his anger may be -- it’s displayed from the opening title cards to the final shot -- it doesn’t blend successfully with the story.

ReelViews James Berardinelli

A tighter version of the same story might have captured and held my interest, but this one had the proceedings wandering like the riderless camels in the desert.

Washington Post Michael O'Sullivan

It's a pretty compelling yarn, not to mention full of pretty pictures, and yet it could be so much more than that.

Chicago Reader J.R. Jones

The film's opening and closing moments are weirdly reminiscent of "Black Hawk Down," another tale of Western soldiers in over their heads on the dark continent -- clearly no one these days understands manifest destiny.

Entertainment Weekly Owen Gleiberman

It may be an accidental historical parallel that, at times, we seem to be watching a 19th-century version of ''The John Walker Lindh Story,'' but the fluke is only enhanced by the weird anonymity of Ledger's performance.

USA Today Mike Clark

Kapur's stodgy style halts the momentum of young actors who have impressed in other movies.

San Francisco Chronicle Mick LaSalle

Its virtues can't outweigh the disappointment of a movie that might have been a rousing old-fashioned epic, or better yet a provocative reworking of an old epic, and instead became a muddle.

TV Guide Steve Simels

The film's center will not hold. Either crucial scenes were cut (perhaps for length) or Kapur has a problematic sense of narrative structure; sometimes it's unclear who's doing what to whom.

Boston Globe Ty Burr

Still as moth-eaten as a Bengal tiger rug on the floor of a London men's club.

Los Angeles Times Kenneth Turan

All these intriguing good intentions, however, have largely gone for naught because of a variety of missteps, starting with an increasing implausible plot as well as the fact that Ledger's Harry looks about as likely to pass for an Arab as the Mahdi is to pass for Queen Victoria.

The Globe and Mail (Toronto) Rick Groen

What a featherweight epic this is, the kind of uniformed period piece where the watchword is pretty. Pretty costumes, pretty soldiers, pretty battles; pretty silly.

Rolling Stone Peter Travers

It should have been an old-fashioned rouser, and sometimes it is. The great cinematographer Robert Richardson (JFK) lights the battle scenes like action paintings. But Kapur weighs down the tale with bogus profundities.

Austin Chronicle Marc Savlov

Offers too small a dose of the blood-and-sand adventure you expect from this sort of big-budget Hollywood remake. As it is, it borders on The English Patient's on again-off again heroics, minus Anthony Minghella's patient skill in eliciting romantic suspense.

Village Voice J. Hoberman

Feels both tiresomely old-fashioned and disturbingly topical.

Washington Post Stephen Hunter

The movie's deeper problem and its primary disappointment: its unwillingness to deal directly with the issue of colonialism.

Portland Oregonian Kim Morgan

Works as pure escapist entertainment, but it's on the cusp of being smarter -- making it all the more frustrating.

Chicago Sun-Times Roger Ebert

It looks good, it moves quickly and it is often a jolly good time. As mindless swashbuckling in a well-designed production, it can't be faulted. The less you know about the British Empire and human nature, the more you will like it, but then that can be said of so many movies.

Philadelphia Inquirer Carrie Rickey

The good news is that it sees what a jihad looks like from both sides. The bad news is that it's not a very good movie, with three fine performances and two great sequences.

The New Yorker Anthony Lane

Illogical and glum. [30 Sept 2002, p. 145]

Baltimore Sun Michael Sragow

Because this Four Feathers is an utter botch, it might make savvy viewers feel that the subject matter is hopeless.

Variety Todd McCarthy

There is no one to become attached to in The Four Feathers, no interest or sympathies appealed to or engaged.

LA Weekly Chuck Wilson

A mindless muddle.

The New York Times A.O. Scott

Such few assets aren't enough to alleviate the film's shallowness.

Salon.com Charles Taylor

Hoary epic of British Empire valor and cowardice, remade for seventh time, remains rot, old boy.