Milk

Chicago Sun-Times Roger Ebert

Sean Penn never tries to show Harvey Milk as a hero, and never needs to. He shows him as an ordinary man, kind, funny, flawed, shrewd, idealistic, yearning for a better world.

San Francisco Chronicle Mick LaSalle

With Milk, a great San Francisco story becomes a great American story.

Rolling Stone Peter Travers

It's a total triumph, brimming with humor, heart, sexual heat, political provocation and a crying need to stir things up, just like Harvey did. If there's a better movie around this year, with more bristling purpose, I sure as hell haven't seen it.

TV Guide Perry Seibert

Harvey Milk embodied the concept that "all politics is personal," and by presenting the famed Mayor of Castro Street's personal and public lives with such clarity and empathy, Van Sant has made something very rare in Hollywood -- a genuinely powerful political film that works equally well as a story of personal triumph.

The New York Times A.O. Scott

Harvey Milk was an intriguing, inspiring figure. Milk is a marvel.

Boston Globe Wesley Morris

By nearly every measure, Milk is a beautifully made, far less conventional movie biography than most.

New York Post Lou Lumenick

Smiling more than in all of his movies since "Fast Times at Ridgemont High" combined, Penn goes way deep and soulful in a highly ingratiating performance that's the one to beat for the Best Actor Oscar.

Washington Post Ann Hornaday

What makes Milk extraordinary isn't just that it's a nuanced, stirring portrait of one of the 20th century's most pivotal figures, but that it's also a nuanced, stirring portrait of the thousands of people he energized.

Slate Dana Stevens

Gus Van Sant and screenwriter Dustin Lance Black pull off something very close to magic. They make a film that's both historically precise and as graceful, unpredictable, and moving as a good fiction film--that is to say, a work of art.

Time Richard Corliss

Three decades ago, Milk and his ilk were able to enlist President Jimmy Carter and future President Ronald Reagan in the gay fight against Prop. 6. But this fall, Barack Obama was all but mute on Prop. 8. Some community organizers, like the President-elect, are more cautious than others. It's a shame Harvey Milk wasn't around to recruit him.

Entertainment Weekly Owen Gleiberman

A fascinating film -- more docudrama than biopic.

Seattle Post-Intelligencer William Arnold

Though it's unflinching in its depiction of homosexual affection, the marvel of the movie is the dexterity with which it transcends the specificity of its characters and gay theme to be a universal human statement and profound political epic.

NPR Bob Mondello

What sets this film entertainingly apart from most civil-rights sagas, though, are a slew of relaxed, offhandedly persuasive performances, along with the flamboyance of hippie-era San Francisco.

The Hollywood Reporter Kirk Honeycutt

The film is superbly crafted, covering huge amounts of time, people and the zeitgeist without a moment of lapsed energy or inattention to detail.

The New Yorker David Denby

Milk is a rowdy anthem of triumph, brought to an abrupt halt by Milk's personal tragedies and the unfathomable moral chaos of Dan White.

USA Today Claudia Puig

Penn's Oscar-caliber transformation is breathtaking, and the saga of one man's fight for human rights is engrossing.

Chicago Tribune Michael Phillips

The story of Harvey Milk is a tragedy, but not since Jeff Spicoli in "Fast Times at Ridgemont High" has Sean Penn played such a serenely happy individual.

Baltimore Sun Michael Sragow

It's not a great movie, but it is an enlivening and unusual one: an effervescent political film that also packs a knockout punch.

ReelViews James Berardinelli

Milk feels like an important picture, but not in a way that makes it tedious to watch. There's no pretentious sheen to the proceedings.

Charlotte Observer Lawrence Toppman

Whatever you think of gay people (or politicians), you may find the movie compelling viewing.

Empire Colin Kennedy

Milk thoroughly deserves all of the press ink that will doubtless be spilt over it. Wear your 'Vote Penn' Oscar pin with pride.

Newsweek David Ansen

How you feel about Milk may depend on whether you've seen Rob Epstein's great, Oscar-winning 1984 documentary "The Times of Harvey Milk." Van Sant's movie lacks that film's shattering emotional impact. (Rage is not a color in the director's palette.) For those coming to Milk's story for the first time, however, this will be a rousing experience.

Wall Street Journal Joe Morgenstern

More than acting, though, Penn's performance is a marvelous act of empathy in a movie that, for all its surprisingly conventional style, measures up to its stirring subject.

Salon.com Andrew O'Hehir

Milk is good enough, thanks mostly to Penn's uncanny evocation, to bring Harvey Milk alive as a vital and highly relevant figure, rather than a distant political abstraction or gay saint. (He very definitely was neither.)

Variety Todd McCarthy

Brolin's work is superlatively expressive of the inchoate impulses roiling inside his sorry character. But good as most of the cast is, the show belongs squarely to Penn.

Village Voice J. Hoberman

Milk is so immediate that it's impossible to separate the movie's moment from this one.

Austin Chronicle Kimberley Jones

The deeply heartfelt Milk is more of a surface skim: a fairly standard biopic – if a very fine one, indeed – but never the transcendent work one would have hoped from the filmmaker or his subject.

Premiere Stuart Levine

Beyond Milk, few of the other characters are given much to do.

Christian Science Monitor Peter Rainer

Milk is an agitprop fantasy about the selflessness of sainthood. If anybody but Penn was playing the saint, we'd probably feel as if we were being sold a bill of goods. Instead, he just about pulls it off. Such is the treachery of talent.

Miami Herald Rene Rodriguez

As good as it is depicting his career, Milk doesn't fare quite as well as a portrait of the man himself.

Philadelphia Inquirer Carrie Rickey

For its mesmerizing first two-thirds, Van Sant keeps the film tightly focused on his subject, superbly played by Penn and intimately shot, home-movie style, by Harris Savides. But when the director pulls back to detail Harvey Milk's fight against gay backlash, Milk gets derailed. And - dare I say it? - didactic.

Portland Oregonian Shawn Levy

It's a testament to Van Sant's way with actors that the performances are better than the lines and that the film tugs undeniably at the heart as the awful finale falls. But a lack of poetry and freshness in the writing nags.

The Globe and Mail (Toronto) Rick Groen

A worthy docudrama that is solid if not sublime. But, sometimes, a merely good film can brush up against greatness, and this one does so twice – in Sean Penn's magnetic performance and in the cautionary tale's contemporary resonance.

Los Angeles Times Kenneth Turan

There's nothing terribly wrong with Milk, it's just that its celebration of a culture and a neighborhood, its valentine to the early days of gay rights activism, is mostly more conventional than compelling.

New York Magazine David Edelstein

Milk is one of the most heartfelt portraits of a politician ever made--the man himself remains just out of reach.

Chicago Reader J.R. Jones

Milk is steeped in the street-level details of acquiring and applying power, and a few early episodes show how clearly Milk understood the economic component.

Film Threat Scott Mendelson

A fine character study and a solid look at a specific political movement and a certain time and place.

The Onion (A.V. Club) Scott Tobias

It's a little disappointing to see Van Sant dial back into mainstream respectability. Had he evoked Harvey Milk's life with the poetry that he did Kurt Cobain's, Milk might have been something special.

New York Daily News Joe Neumaier

The final result somehow undersells a man whose life and death were watershed moments in the gay rights movement.