Metascore
49 out of 100

Generally unfavorable - based on 10 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 0 out of 10
  2. Negative: 3 out of 10
  1. While it may not have the depth and grandeur some would look for, it has enough character to stand out from the other licensed titles.
  2. Perhaps the best aspect of the game is that you will care a lot about collecting treasure.
  3. At times, the game seems to focus more on mundane wandering around than on interesting pirate activity, but the action picks up as the story progresses. [Sept 2003, p.137]
  4. The production values are all in place and a game couldn’t ask for better sounds or graphics, but in this case they are wasted on a simple exploration game with occasional and simplistic combat.
  5. 55
    Had the game put a little more attention on the weapon combat it would have been a lot more fun, but as it is the battle between pirate vs. pirate in Pirates of the Caribbean is a basic and tedious button-masher.
  6. This lack of depth, coupled with the weak combat and repetitive levels, equals a pirate game that won't even manage to steal away an hour of your precious time. [Sept 2003, p.126]
  7. It be a poor portrayal of the pirate's life, says I.
  8. Exactly like every other cookie-cutter movie/cartoon-licensed platformer.
  9. The game is inadequate and tedious--22 levels of mindless button mashing that will come as a major letdown to anyone who grabs it hoping to relive any portion of the film.
  10. Every fight and puzzle "packed" into this game's 20-plus levels would be found in the first level of most other games. [Fall 2003, p.51]
User Score

Mixed or average reviews- based on 5 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 2 out of 5
  2. Negative: 2 out of 5
  1. OwenK.
    6
    I got this free with a Nintendo DS, and so I decided to play it. I think it is really good. The graphics are really neat. Marks of for how crud Captain Jack looks. Full Review »
  2. EddyM.
    10
    Awesome. Great pirate game.
  3. HarryB.
    2
    This game is horrendous. A password-based save system? I thought we were searching for treasure, not lost progress. Poor gameplay. An unbelievably poor representation of Jack Sparrow, as a bald-headed, naive, uncertain apprentice. Zero connection to the actual movie. Poor all the way around. Full Review »