Compared to 2003 this game wasn't nearly as good. I admit the set pieces and new off-ball controls are great. However game speed is definatley a factor; you aren't even able change the game speed and its much slower than 2003.
But however much positive energy we lavish on FIFA all the areas that EA beats Konami on - bar online - are simply gloss. In a straight tussle between the games, we just don't enjoy playing FIFA as much as we do PES3, and, for most of you, that's what matters.