CNET Networks Entertainment GameSpot | GameFAQs | SportsGamer | Metacritic | MP3.com | TV.com
Home | About Metacritic | About Metascores | What's New | Wireless Versions | Discussion Forums | Advertising Inquiries | Contact Us | RSS
Metacritic.com: We Deal With Criticism
     Help
> Switch to Advanced Search  
Film Video/DVD Music Games TV

Games

Playstation Reviews
PS3 | PS2 | PS One | PSP

Xbox Reviews
Xbox 360 | Xbox

Nintendo Reviews
Wii | DS | GBA | Cube | N64


PC | N-Gage | Dreamcast

How Metascores Are Calculated
Discuss Games In Our Forums

 

Upcoming & Recent Releases

sort by name sort by score

xx Abbey, The
xx Aces of the Galaxy
80 Age of Conan: Hyborian Adventures
55 Alone in the Dark
49 Art of Murder: FBI Confidential
xx Backyard Baseball '09
xx Beauty Factory
44 Beijing 2008
54 Belief & Betrayal
93 Bionic Commando Rearmed
xx Brothers in Arms: Hell's Highway
xx Building & Co: You Are The Architect!
xx Chaos Theory
xx Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian, The
xx Code of Honor 2: Conspiracy Island
xx Code of Honor: The French Foreign Legion
xx Combat Mission Shock Force - Marines
xx Concerto Gate
75 Crazy Machines 2
51 Crimes of War
xx Crysis Warhead
xx Dark Horizon
xx Dead Mountaineer's Hotel
xx Deadliest Catch: Alaskan Storm
78 Devil May Cry 4
xx Dracula 3: The Path of the Dragon
72 Dracula: Origin
xx Dragons Rage
xx Dreamlords: The Reawakening
xx Emergency 4: Global Fighters for Life
xx Empire: Total War
xx Europa Universalis III: In Nomine
76 Everyday Shooter
78 FlatOut: Ultimate Carnage
xx Galactic Dream: Rage of War
xx Geo-Political Simulator
xx Goin' Downtown
88 GRID
xx Guild Wars 2
xx Gumboy Tournament
xx Happy Tree Friends False Alarm
xx Hell's Kitchen
xx Hope Springs Eternal
xx Igor The Game
65 Immortals of Terra: A Perry Rhodan Adventure, The
32 Incredible Hulk, The
68 Insecticide: Episode 1
xx International Cricket Captain 2008
71 Kung Fu Panda
xx LEGO Batman
79 LEGO Indiana Jones: The Original Adventures
xx Limbo of the Lost
xx Line Rider 2: Unbound
77 Lost Cases Of Sherlock Holmes, The
74 Lost Planet: Extreme Condition Colonies Edition
90 Mass Effect
xx Mercenaries 2: World in Flames
xx MindHabits
xx Mount & Blade
xx Nancy Drew: The Phantom of Venice
xx NHL 09
xx Nostradamus: The Last Prophecy
82 Out of the Park Baseball 9
xx Overspeed: High Performance Street Racing
xx Paws & Claws: Pet Vet Australian Adventures
78 Penny Arcade Adventures Epsiode One: On the Rain-Slick Precipice of Darkness
xx Penumbra: Requiem
xx Planet Busters
74 Political Machine 2008, The
xx Princess Bride Game, The
40 Pro Cycling Manager: Season 2008
xx Pure
xx Racing Team Manager
xx Requiem: Bloodymare
xx Romance of The Three Kingdoms XI
70 Roogoo
xx S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Clear Sky
51 Samurai Warriors 2
67 SBK-08 Superbike World Championship
xx Shattered Suns
xx Silent Hill: Homecoming
62 SimCity Societies Destinations
74 Sims 2 Apartment Life, The
xx Sims 2 IKEA Home Stuff, The
xx Sinking Island
xx Sniper: Art of Victory
xx Space Chimps
59 Space Siege
xx Spore
83 Spore Creature Creator
xx Strategic Command 2: Patton Drives East
75 Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People Episode 1: Homestar Ruiner
45 Stronghold Crusader Extreme
xx Summer Athletics
xx Supernova 2: Spacewar
67 Supreme Ruler 2020
xx Sword of the Stars: A Murder of Crows
xx Tank Universal
38 Terrorist Takedown 2: U.S. Navy SEALs
xx Terrorist Takedown: Conflict in Mogadishu
xx Top Trumps: Doctor Who
xx Total Extreme Wrestling 2008
83 TrackMania United Forever
xx Ubersoldier 2: The End of Hitler
67 UEFA Euro 2008
xx WALL-E
xx War Leaders: Clash of Nations
xx Warhammer Online: Age of Reckoning
67 Warhammer: Mark of Chaos - Battle March
xx Windchaser

Stars indicate the most critically-acclaimed games.



Printer-Friendly Version Email This Page Discuss In Our Forums
Rome: Total War pc Game Reviews
Rome: Total War
Critic Score
Metascore: 92 Metascore out of 100
User Score  
8.8 out of 10
based on 58 reviews
Read critic reviews
How did we calculate this?
based on 102 votes
Read user comments
Rate this game

Rome: Total War is the next generation in epic strategy gaming from the critically acclaimed and award winning Total War brand. The aim of the game is to conquer, rule and manipulate the Roman Empire with the ultimate goal of being declared as the "Imperator" of Rome. Set in a time when the mighty Roman Empire emerged to conquer the known world against powerful enemies; when gladiators fought to a bloody death in the Coliseum; when Spartacus defied the might of the empire; when Hannibal led his invincible army and his war elephants across the Alps to strike fear into the very heart of Rome itself; and when Julius Caesar finally smashed the Barbarian Gauls. This was a time of brutal confrontation between civilisation and barbarism, and of civil war as the ancient world's only superpower turned on itself. A completely new Total War engine uses innovative technology and groundbreaking design to bring the world of ancient Rome to life to deliver the biggest and most cinematic battles ever seen in a videogame. So the battles in Rome: Total War maintain the epic scale that fans of Total War are used to, but now use high-detailed 3D polygonal troops and allows huge cities to be displayed on the battlefields. The result is truly spectacular. [Activision]

PUBLISHER: Activision
DEVELOPER: Creative Assembly
GENRE(S): Real-Time Strategy
PLAYERS: 8
ESRB RATING: T (Teen)
RELEASE DATE: September 22, 2004

What The Critics Said

All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...

100
GameSpot AU
A sumptuously detailed and totally engrossing RTS title that can even hook those who normally aren't fans of RTS titles.
Read Full Review
100
Thunderbolt
It has so much depth and aptitude that you'll find yourself drawn in for hours, which will quickly turn into days, months and, dare I say, years. There's been so much effort put into every single aspect of the game that it's hard not to admire the hard work of the developers behind it.
Read Full Review
100
G4 TV
Few things are more satisfying than watching the bodies fly as your cavalry charge breaks through a defensive line or watching your elephants flatten your foes as they run away in terror. Rome: Total War adds much needed personality to the battle. No other game in the strategy genre does it better.
Read Full Review
100
Gamer.tv
The most epic, cinematic real-time 3D battles ever seen.
Read Full Review
100
AceGamez
A new breed of superlative is needed to even begin describing how truly revolutionary and fantastic Rome: Total War really is. "Medieval" was a strategic masterpiece but the superiority of Rome makes Medieval look positively, well medieval in comparison.
Read Full Review
100
Sydney Morning Herald
Every couple of years a game is released that is so well crafted, so perfectly made, that it sets a benchmark for gaming quality. Rome: Total War is one of those games. We couldn't find a fault.
Read Full Review
100
Computer Games Magazine
Enough staying power to keep you busy for years. [Dec 2004, p.72]
98
Gamezilla!
Without a doubt one of the best strategy games I’ve played. Activision has successfully combined full RTS and turn based genres in one game while maintaining the balance between them, putting any serious strategy fan to the test.
Read Full Review
96
Gaming Illustrated
This is a MUST HAVE GAME, with stunning graphics, depth, detail and playability. This game provides a new level of challenge and enjoyment that other games will now be judged against.
Read Full Review
96
RealGamer
I suppose the most telling thing about this game is the way that it draws you in, making you ponder every turn-based move, knowing it will affect the outcome of each battle with each enemy army that takes offence to you.
Read Full Review
95
Gamers Europe
Like Romeo and Juliet, I was deprived of my love for so long, but the third Total War has made the franchise accessible to all but the most casual of gamers.
Read Full Review
95
Games Radar UK (Pre-2006)
It's huge, thrilling, epic stuff. Give yourself unto Caesar. [PC Gamer UK]
Read Full Review
95
3DAvenue
Combining a powerful turn based engine for the management, and an insanely enjoyable RTS engine for the battles, Activision and The Creative Assembly have produced what could easily be the best strategy game of 2004.
Read Full Review
95
Computer Games Online RO
The most advanced, complete and realistic strategy game out there. No matter if you are looking for a great single player campaign which can fill weeks or even months with continuous challenges and new experiences, or you just want realistic cinematic multiplayer skirmishes of epic scale, this game delivers.
Read Full Review
95
Gamers' Temple
A strategy game for the ages.
Read Full Review
95
DailyGame
Still, despite the occasional glitch in battle, Rome: Total War is a superb game that easily consumes your day, evening, night and next morning. In other words, play this game with caution if you succumb easily to the desire to conquer the world.
Read Full Review
94
IGN
Personally, I've never given a score this high before but Rome Total War is without a doubt one of the best games I've ever played. The combination of subject matter, game mechanics, and outstanding visuals add up to one of the best experiences you'll have on the PC.
Read Full Review
94
Xequted
The atmosphere in R:TW is breathtaking...This game is by far the best Total War game released yet and, in our opinion possibly the best strategy game of all time.
Read Full Review
94
Jolt Online Gaming UK
Rome: Total War is nothing less than awesome, and is engrossing enough to provide weeks of play at the very least.
Read Full Review
93
GameZone
The graphics for Rome were nothing short of great in my opinion from animations to the smooth camera work and lack of lag even when large numbers of troops filled the screen. The sound in the game is also spectacular.
Read Full Review
93
Worth Playing
As a total game experience, it is enchanting, and sometimes even astounding, if you have a machine that can handle it well.
Read Full Review
93
Computer and Video Games
Jaw-dropping battle engine, Staggeringly deep yet intuitive strategy map, Fiendishly lifelike AI.
Read Full Review
93
PGNx Media
An ideal strategy game as it combines two rather different gameplay approaches into one very cohesive package.
Read Full Review
93
FiringSquad
It has a seamless blend of strategy and tactics, giving the player the power to choose whether he wants to enjoy one or the other, the 11 civilizations to play – and it does this all in a very refined fashion.
Read Full Review
93
PC Format
Crosses the rubicon of greatness with a Latin flourish; it's the equal of a hundred lesser games. [Nov 2004]
Read Full Review
93
Warcry
The presentation is marvelous, the gameplay is terrific, and much of the strategy is tremendous. Strategy gamers, I implore you, buy this game!
Read Full Review
92
PC Gamer
To say I loved every minute of Rome: Total War is a tremendous understatement. For my money, it's the ultimate strategy game. Not only does it effortlessly combine turn-based strategy with raucous real-time warmongering, but it delivers them in a package that is accessibe and easy to play. [Nov 2004, p.76]
92
VGPub
If you loved "RISK," you’ll feel right at home with this title.
Read Full Review
92
Gaming Nexus
A constantly impressive element is the rousing speech your general hollers before a battle.
Read Full Review
92
Game Chronicles
Rome's campaign mode can be a bit daunting for all but the most hardcore RTS veterans.
Read Full Review
91
Gamer's Hell
No other game so expertly combines a cerebral challenge with visceral thrills.
Read Full Review
91
Game Revolution
A fantastic conquest. The power of the game engine has finally caught up with the developer’s vision of what a war game should really be like, and what a cool vision that is. It’s almost like getting two games for the price of one...and you can even just play your favorite.
Read Full Review
91
Gaming Age
Many games are excellent world-builders, and many are deep real time strategy war games. Rome: Total War sets out to be both and pulls it off wonderfully.
Read Full Review
91
netjak
The best part is that players can zoom in to watch the battle in glorious detail, and players will want to zoom in just to sit back and watch the action.
Read Full Review
91
GameSpot
It's as much a revolutionary step as it is an evolutionary one, thanks to a beautiful new 3D graphics engine that makes the series' tactical battles--featuring thousands of soldiers--better than ever. The results are nothing short of spectacular, helping make Rome: Total War the very definition of an epic strategy game.
Read Full Review
90
Computer Gaming World
A stroke of brilliance. With its unparalleled scope and enough strategic gameplay for two top-flight games, let alone one, Rome is a game that triumphs over its minor bugs and A.I. glitches and once again redefines what a historical strategy game can - and should - be. [Holiday 2004, p.100]
90
EuroGamer
In any real-time strategy game you'll fight desperate battles against hopeless odds, but here, thanks to the strategy side, you know the precise cost of loss will be. It's a magical, beautiful synergy and there's nothing quite like it in the entire gaming lexicon.
Read Full Review
90
1UP
Almost a perfect strategy game. It has strategic scope and splendor nearly matching that of "Civilization" and a tactical game unlike anything else on the market.
Read Full Review
90
GamerFeed
This game is not only visually overwhelming, but intellectually, too. This is not for the casual gamer, or for people who only have a few hours a day to play. Instead, it is for those armchair generals who enjoy both the slower turn-based elements of games like Civilization and faster paced real-time strategy games.
Read Full Review
90
Total Video Games
An epic game in terms of both visual execution and longevity...Campaigns can last for several hundred turns, so prepare for the long haul.
Read Full Review
90
Yahoo! Games
Finally, the campaign elements and the 3D combat have merged into a game that's practically perfect in almost every way.
Read Full Review
90
My Gamer
Primarily for hardcore strategy fans but, thanks to the great tutorial, it's still accessible enough for the casual gamer interested in delving further into the world of armchair generals. The game play is steeped in depth and can sometimes be overwhelming, but that’s a good feature—trust me.
Read Full Review
90
games(TM)
The tactical battles are better than ever thanks to an improved engine and significantly smarter enemy AI. You can now take up to 400 units into battle, leading to some impressive large-scale scraps.
Read Full Review
90
Gamenikki
Where the series goes from here (Please, a cross over with the "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" series?), it will have a mighty legacy to live up to.
Read Full Review
90
Adrenaline Vault
It seamlessly combines real-time and turn-based gameplay, gives the player ultimate control of their experience, and provides a level of depth that verges on bottomless.
Read Full Review
90
Edge Magazine
Rome: Total War is more compelling, more beautiful and more expansive than anything that has gone before. [Dec 2004, p.104]
90
Game Over Online
No matter if you’re a fan of strategy, combat, really angry guys with spears or some mixture of all of the above, Rome: Total War will definitely please.
Read Full Review
90
PC Gameworld
It sucks you in and holds on for hours. Anyone with the slightest interest in RTS games would find it well worth their money.
Read Full Review
90
GMR Magazine
The multiplayer could use a few more game options, like allowing players to actually play the campaign rather than only skirmishes. Still, for anyone who wants strategic depth with their RTS game, there's no better title out there. [Dec 2004, p.131]
90
GameSpy
A stunning title... Sure, it might be a little complex for the casual gamer, and it might be a little rough in places, but Rome is as deep and as satisfying as they come.
Read Full Review
90
Armchair Empire
While I wouldn’t way Rome: Total War is a good title for novice strategy players, there’s plenty of depth and fun in this masterful effort from Creative Assembly without being overwhelming.
Read Full Review
90
Games Radar
For people who loved "Gladiator," fans of top-shelf strategy games and history aficionados of any stripe - all roads lead to Rome.
Read Full Review
89
ActionTrip
As far as tactics and empire management are concerned, this is not a (much) more elaborate strategy game, and the AI does have its faults, but this is certainly an infinitely more cinematic and spectacular looking strategy game than before.
Read Full Review
89
Ferrago
Niggly controls, cheating AI, cluttered management screens, a rash of aggravating bugs and an unshakeable sense of over familiarity all combine to keep Rome: Total War from being an outright classic.
Read Full Review
87
GameBiz
The in-battle game engine is entirely unmatched for realism and its unique vast - and yet personal - nature, while the turn based world map is both complex and involving.
Read Full Review
80
Gamers Depot
My last whine is lengthy AI turns.
Read Full Review
80
Loaded Inc
In the strict application, and importance, of strategy in regard to your success, Rome: Total War is to most other strategy games what chess is to tic-tac-toe. Far from flawless, Rome is, unquestionably, an enjoyable and immersive game.
Read Full Review
78
Game Informer
As it stands, Rome: Total War is merely a good empire simulation with a minor real-time strategy diversion built in. [Nov 2004, p.165]

What Our Users Said

Vote Now! The average user rating for this game is 8.8 (out of 10) based on 102 User Votes
Note: User votes are NOT included in the Metascore calculation.

Jonathan M. gave it an8:
Rome: Total Realism FTW! Yeah, this game is very good. The graphics are decent and are downgraded just enough for the larger battles to be playable. As this was my first TW game, I was blown away by finally being permitted to wage wars and fight battles on a massive scale. I do wish it would be easier to manage your forces without having to pause every 30 seconds, but that didn't matter that much to me, because this game has potential. Specifically, I reference the great work various modders put into one of the greatest mods I have ever seen: Rome: Total Realism. It's a lot like it sounds: dedicated to historical accuracy and, as a side effect, more diversity of gameplay. What I disliked most about the original game is that you can only play one of three identical Roman empires that never existed in the way that the game presents them. Historical accuracy aside, I became very bored, very quickly with the basic campaign. There just wasn't enough variety. I wanted to play Carthage. I wanted to play the Gauls. Total Realism cracked this game wide open for me. No, I never tried the expansion, because I never needed to. When you take each empire and kingdom in this game and you pay each one personal, custom attention and you set them in motion with this game's engine and its concepts and its scope, you get an amazing experience and a strategy game that rubs shoulders with Civ 4. (What's funny is that the two go well together. One gives you depth in conquest and the other gives you depth in nation management, especially civically.) Yeah, this and Medieval 2 TW both need just a little modding/upgrading to realize their true glory, and, when they do, they're awesome. RTW alone is an 8/10. RTW with Total Realism is a 10/10.

Daniel T. gave it a10:
Wow,wow,wow! This game is definately worth the money. There is nothing more fun that pitching a massive Roman army agains a hoard of Gauls. Watch th blood (and men) fly. The graphics did almost kill my computer but it was well worth waiting for the lag to pass befor the climax of your battle. I recommend a pretty good computer or you may have to switch off your flaming arrows.

Kingeth J. gave it a10:
Amazing! Nearly flawless! The depth of this game is amazing, tedious negotiations, rebellious citizens, and many many people to conquer. The battles are reallistic (if not, then turn up the difficulty) and very controllable with a simple to use interface. The makers did an excellent job of fusing the campain map and the battle fields to the point that in the first week I had this, I believe I logged over FORTY hours on one campain. You truly face highs and lows of your millitary strengh and strategising. When I first started playing this game I wished to make peace with the surrounding nations and build my armies up, but several backstabbings later I felt no mercy for those who broke their allegances to me as my troops trampled them underneath their feet. This is honestly the first game I actually lost myself in. With constant audible explanations of anceint terms, strategies, and history, it is definately worth 20, 30, 40, even 50 dollars. Plus the historical battles make it even more worth while!

Neskire gave it a9:
Don't believe all those negative comments! There is no "hype". This is genuinely one of the best games with a mix of strategy and action ever to be created. I have played computer games since 1981 and must say that this is one of the most immersive games. The music is excellent. Download a demo and try it for yourself. Yes, not every game will appeal to everyone. But do not prejudge it based on a handful of negative reviews.

Jonas H. gave it a10:
Many hours worth of gaming. Great combo of RTS and Turn-Based Strategy. And Jeff-D, it's logical, that if you play as the same nation over and over again and you don't fight your battles on the map: The game gets boring, cause it's what makes the Total War series so awesome!

Dom F. gave it a10:
Sweet game. The strategical and graphical depth is just amazing. I don't think ill ever get over the sight of enemies falling off the wall or burning alive.

Jeff D gave it a6:
I'm starting to get pretty sick of the gaming press' absurd hyper-enthusiasm for any even remotely-interesting game. This is the third game I've spent my hard-earned cash on in the last six months which had a Metascore of 85+ and which, nonetheless, was lackluster-to-bad. Coupled with the fact that games can't be returned (a practice which badly needs to end), it's just unforgivable. Hello, journalistic integrity? Where are you? With regard to this specific game, yeah, it's an OK strategy game. Certainly not the godsend that the gaming press and some of the folks around here seem to think. Gameplay is initially rather convoluted and confusing (no doubt due to a less than stellar user interface), then fun for a few hours, then repetitive and tedious. The graphics are OK -- nothing special. I think that folks may be getting off on the "epicness" of the graphics, on the sheer fact that you'll have thousands of soldiers fighting in a battle. But all those soldiers look alike and move exactly alike. And the terrain they're fighting on, as well as the campaign map, and the cutscenes as well, are all pretty lacklustre. Despite this game's general classification as a RTS, the gameplay emphasis is on the campaign (turn-based) play. I say this because all RTS battles can be skipped...and frequently they will be, since the AI will spend a lot of time attacking your armies even when they're badly outmanned. Naval battles can't be fought in RTS mode at all. And as a turn-based campaign game, R:TW is really lacking in depth. About 8 hours into my campaign game (now at about 12 hours, I seem to be about 1/3 of the way through it), I enabled the "Automanage AI" option and never looked back. So, I'm not fighting my battles on the battlefield, I'm not managing my cities. It seems like all that's left is what would be the most tedious part of another turn-based game like Civ IV -- ferrying my troups around the campaign map. Yuck. It's not all bad. I did have some fun with this game in the few intervening hours between figuring out the rather poorly-documented and unusual-but-not-in-a-good-way UI and getting bored with the repetitive gameplay. But was it worth my $30? Hell no.

Read more user comments...

Discuss this game in our forums

Return to top of page
Home | FILM | DVD/VIDEO | MUSIC | GAMES | TV | Forums | About Metacritic metacritic.com

Popular on CBS sites: Fantasy Football | Miley Cyrus | MLB | iPhone 3G | GPS | Recipes | Shwayze | NFL

About CNET Networks | Jobs | Advertise

© 2008 CNET Networks, Inc., a CBS Company. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use