Games

Best of 2008 | 07 | 06 | 05
Advanced Search

Stars indicate the most critically-acclaimed games.

Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-earth II, The

EMAIL PRINT xbox360

8.2 User Score:

Generally favorable reviews

Based on 50 critic reviews
How did we calculate this?

Based on 44 votes
Read user comments
Rate this game >

Game Info

Publisher: Electronic Arts

Developer: Electronic Arts LA

Genre(s): Real-Time Strategy

Players: 4

ESRB Rating: T (Teen)

Release Date: July 5, 2006

Summary

Based on the PC version of the same name, The Lord of the Rings, The Battle for Middle-earth II for the Xbox 360 will bring players into the heart of Middle-earth to live the battles seen in the blockbuster New Line Cinema films and classic J.R.R. Tolkien literary fiction. The game boasts a new and intuitive console-specific control scheme that will allow novice players to enjoy the game’s signature strategy gameplay while giving expert players the flexibility needed to engage in a deeply complex strategy experience. Players will directly control hundreds of units in an attempt to defeat enemy armies, conquer new lands, and seal the fate of Middle-earth. [Electronic Arts]

Cheat Codes & Hints: GameSpot Hints & Cheats

Also On The Web: Official Website

What The Critics Said

All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...

Yahoo! Games

To produce a console RTS game that equals its PC counterpart is no mean feat, and here Electronic Arts has even surpassed it slightly in some areas.

Read Full Review >

eToychest

Simple enough to pick up and play after only a cursory glance at the control scheme, but it also provides the sort of depth that genre fans crave. Far from being a kiddie version of a PC game, Battle simply streamlines the controls down to their quick, intuitive essence.

Read Full Review >

AceGamez

Sure, the camera can be a pain and the map isn't in any way natural to use, but you get used to these quirks and they don't get in the way of the very engaging gameplay, while very authentic renditions of every aspect of the LOTR world, both visually and aurally, are spread across the various campaigns and multiplayer game modes.

Read Full Review >

Cheat Code Central

Much like Bioware's "Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, Middle-earth II" has been created from the ground up with the Tolkien fan in mind. Those who appreciate this incredible body of fiction will love being able to wage epic battles with the touch of a few buttons.

Read Full Review >

PGNx Media

There is a lot of gameplay to be enjoyed in the game thanks to the highly entertaining multiplayer mode, the presentation is superb (albeit somewhat less so if you’re playing on a SDTV), and the game makes good use of its source material.

Read Full Review >

Gamer 2.0

A great game for anyone who enjoys The Lord of the Rings, fantasy, strategy games, or Xbox Live. It’s a surprisingly well ported game that really shouldn’t play anywhere near as good as it does.

Read Full Review >

GameZone

The controls and easy command selection allow anyone to enter the fray, while the ferocious battles will keep skilled players at bay.

Read Full Review >

ZTGameDomain

EA has taken great care in delivering a solid storyline that aficionados of the series will certainly enjoy while at the same time creating the world’s greatest console RTS control scheme.

Read Full Review >

Deeko

The controller is a very suitable replacement for the mouse, the situations within the game are appealing and interesting, plus you can play online with up to four people.

Read Full Review >

Worth Playing

One of those rare licensed games that actually transcends its license to provide a great gaming experience for anyone willing to give it a shot.

Read Full Review >

Official Xbox Magazine

We have seen the future of real-time strategy on Xbox 360, and its name is Battle for Middle-Earth II. [Sept 2006, p.76]

Play Magazine

The control scheme, though a bit Byzantine, works well. [Aug 2006, p.58]

Armchair Empire

It’s not without minor flaws, but overall, it’s a really satisfying experience that broadens the horizons of console gaming.

Read Full Review >

Play.tm

As engrossing as it is pretty, while also offering up a rare control system that allows the game's core real-time strategy component to remain the right side of intuitively 'real-time' without ever lapsing into finger-breaking trials of game-pad frustration.

Read Full Review >

Kombo

The title is packed full of features and boasts fun gameplay, with good graphics, and sound.

Read Full Review >

Games Master UK

A genuinely successful console RTS and a sumptuous slice of strategy. [Sept 2006, p.74]

Pelit (Finland)

I thought it was impossible to play an RTS with a gamepad, but I stand corrected. BFME2 is an expertly crafted console conversion of a good strategy game, but you definitely need a high-definition television to play it. [Aug 2006, p.39]

Gaming Age

It a shame it took developers this long to come up with a console RTS control scheme, but alas it is here and it is glorious.

Read Full Review >

GameSpot

Apart from the control scheme, the game is virtually indistinguishable from the PC experience. As such, this is a pretty good introduction to real-time strategy for console gamers, and a good way to discover the joys of building up huge armies and using them to crush your opponents.

Read Full Review >

IGN

The game is deep with 16 single-player missions, and a hefty set of maps in five Xbox Live multiplayer modes should give it online legs. Like I've been saying all along, this is the sleeper hit of the summer on Xbox 360.

Read Full Review >

Jolt Online Gaming UK

The control scheme feels comfortable, albeit not quite as precise as a good old keyboard and mouse, and is paired up to an equally well-executed interface.

Read Full Review >

GameTrailers

EA should be commended for creating a console control scheme that works well in real-time strategy games. But that doesn’t mean that this is the best way to play Battle for Middle Earth, or an Xbox 360 game for that matter.

Read Full Review >

Talk Xbox

This title is easily the best RTS game seen on consoles. The control scheme allows anyone to jump into the game fairly quickly, although you cannot get as detailed with your strategies and forces.

Read Full Review >

Sydney Morning Herald

This slow-paced strategy game is just as successful on console as it is on PC - in fact it's hobbit forming.

Read Full Review >

DarkStation

RTS based on the LOTR franchise seems like a perfect fit, and the fact that it plays so good on a console makes this one a clear winner.

Read Full Review >

360 Gamer Magazine UK

The definitive LOTR game. [Issue #12]

Planet Xbox 360

It is very nice to know that RTS games are very much so playable on the 360, and this can only mean that the trend will be upward.

Read Full Review >

MS Xbox World

The controls aren’t quite 100% satisfactory, but an incredibly brave attempt has been made and should be applauded.

Read Full Review >

Game Informer

Taking into account the uphill battle this title had to fight, it comes out much the same as the PC edition (minus the Risk-like War of the Ring mode)--which is not a bad thing to say. [Aug 2006, p.86]

Official Xbox Magazine UK

Our main gripe with BMEII? The battles aren't big enough. Though the unit sizes have been increased from the previous PC version, they're still pitifully small. [Aug 2006, p.8]

Read Full Review >

GameSpy

I'm very pleased with how TBfM-eII on the 360 turned out, and while it does have some issues, it's a shining example of how persistence and well-constructed game design can bring a classic genre of games to the unlikely console platform in true style.

Read Full Review >

GamerFeed

With the new control system there is a bit of a learning curve, especially if you're not familiar with other RTS titles. However, if you give the game a few missions and a chance to learn the controls properly, BFME2 should appeal to most RPG and Strategy fans out there, and even a few of the action-oriented gamers.

Read Full Review >

Games Radar (in-house)

The single-player may be over in a day or two, but you'll spend many more happy weeks and months starting skirmishes or challenging friends online.

Read Full Review >

VideoGamer

Yes, the RTS genre has been seen on consoles in the past, but never to this level, and with this much polish.

Read Full Review >

TeamXbox

Let’s face it: there’s only so much you can do with a simple Xbox 360 controller. I think EALA has really taken advantage of the peripheral in question, and has also tweaked the gameplay enough so that micromanagement is less of a need.

Read Full Review >

DailyGame

Being able to (mostly) control an RTS on a console is great, but it still has a few control and graphics snafus to work through.

Read Full Review >

Electronic Gaming Monthly

Each campaign mission plays out in wonderfully designed stages created specifically to capture your imagination. [Aug 2006, p.86]

GameShark

A quality console RTS game. There are still times that I’d prefer playing this type of game on a PC, but overall I found the controls easy to work with and although I was frustrated at my lack of ability I didn’t think it was the fault of the controls at all.

Read Full Review >

X360 Magazine UK

As long as you're a fan of the RTS format, it's hard to fault Battle for Middle-Earth II on anything other than the controls. We think most will adapt soon enough, though. [Issue 9, p.84]

Digital Entertainment News

Ultimately, it's ony worthwhile for those that don't have a decent gaming PC.

Read Full Review >

games(TM)

Probably the best console RTS that we’ve ever played in terms of flexibility and control, but it will still prove frustratingly slow and awkward to seasoned PC and Mac users. [Aug 2006, p.116]

WHAM! Gaming

It's hard to imagine how this epic strategy game's control scheme could be any better on a console, but it's still not quite a match for the precision of the PC version.

Read Full Review >

Boomtown

Something of a disappointment. One cannot fault EA for trying to bring an intelligent strategy game to the console yet at the same time the removal of the dynamic campaign shows that the publisher wasn't quite convinced the game would fly on the console.

Read Full Review >

PALGN

One of the best console RTS titles in a long time, if you've avoided RTS titles in the past on consoles then this game will change your perception on whether they can work or not.

Read Full Review >

GamePro

As far as multiplayer goes, while a couple heroes dispatching entire enemy armies on their own might seem true to the spirit of the films, it hardly makes for a balanced and satisfying online encounter.

Read Full Review >

Total Video Games

Remaining credible to the works of Tolkien, EA LA have adapted The Lord of the Rings into the mechanics of an RTS with some success, though there are one or two niggles that stop this from being a classic.

Read Full Review >

1UP

This superport does an admirable job of taking a complex PC game from an intimidatingly complex PC genre and making it an accessible console title. If any part of your heart enjoys playing on Live, you'll be too busy crushing the hobbits to even notice that you can't quite select the unit you were aiming for.

Read Full Review >

Entertainment Weekly

While Battle does a serviceable job of distilling the requisite commands into an intuitive sequence of button taps on the controller, it doesn't come close to the convenience of the tried-and-true keyboard and mouse combination. Playing on the 360 feels like flying an airplane using only the ''cabin lights off'' switch.

Read Full Review >

3DAvenue

BFME 2 presents a visual spectacle that's quite engaging, as long as you're playing it through a high definition display. Drop it down to a standard definition TV, and you'll find yourself looking at tiny units and blurred text.

Read Full Review >

Game Revolution

I’ll give EA credit for trying what few companies have the cajones (or cockiness) to do –stick an RTS on a television. Unfortunately, the result of their effort is somewhat inconsistent and misses the smooth, intuitive play of the original.

Read Full Review >

What Our Users Said

The average user rating for this game is 8.2 (out of 10) based on 44 User Votes

Note: User votes are NOT included in the Metascore calculation.

Lazar A. gave it a10:
This is a cool game. I love it. I can not stop playing it. Thanks for making it.

Red XIII gave it a9:
I am glad to see that RTS games are coming back to the console, the last one I played was Command and Conquer for the PS1. This game is visually amazing, the controls are easy to master, yet there is so many things you can do. Playing as either good or evil is nice, as well as being able to train air units. It can be tedious to set up squads, but you don't even have to use them. Excellent game if you like RTS's.

Tim T. gave it a9:
I loved this game - the selection controls were very good, and the graphics were top-notch. With a 5.1 surround system the sounds come from all around and really help you identify what's just off-screen. Only reason I didn't give it a 10 is because of the pauses in gameplay (texture loads?) that cause the framerate to stutter. Seems to only happen at the beginning of levels but they could do better. Maybe they should use one of the other CPU cores to do the loading in the background?

Reel W. gave it a4:
Good graphics, but I really just couldn't get into the control scheme. As pointed out, RTS games are better on PC than console and this one proves the point. Points for graphics, and voice overs, but if you really want to sink your teeth into an RTS game, I'd do it on the computer instead using the trusty mouse instead of a controller.

Joe G. gave it a10:
Awesome. I can't believe how easy it is to control and the multiplayer is a blast. Totally pick this up if you are into RTS and love your 360!

Carcas G. gave it an8:
Take it from me the game is good and it deserves a nine but anyone who would dare rate any lord of the rings game below a 6 or 60 is craz. Long live Tolkien and Peter J.

James gave it a10:
This game REALLY does it for me - the best thing since command and conquer & Red alert 2 :) LOVE IT

Games

Sony

Microsoft

Nintendo

Other Platforms

Upcoming &Recent Releases

Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-earth II, The

Game Info

Summary

What The Critics Said

What Our Users Said

Upcoming &
Recent Releases