Metascore
68 out of 100

Generally favorable reviews - based on 24 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 18 out of 24
  2. Negative: 1 out of 24
  1. Boldly structured, intensely focused and briskly paced, Alice and Martin has a tremendous emotional density that places the utmost demands upon its actors--and asks a lot of audiences, too.
  2. It's a lovely, terrifying sight.
  3. Reviewed by: Jay Carr
    88
    Richly compelling.
  4. Your attention is rewarded by a film of surprising depth and a few deep surprises.
  5. Something that falls just shy of greatness.
  6. This drama is richly photographed and enhanced by Binoche's steadily appealing performance.
  7. With its intriguing relationships and sacrificial acts, Alice is a good alternative to happily-ever-after fluff.
  8. Heartfelt and passionate and brave in what it attempts to explore.
  9. Binoche is the ideal creature for that kind of cosmetic expansion, and, here, her thorough modernity takes on an almost cruddy, Italian sadness.
  10. 70
    It isn't an entirely successful or satisfying film, but it's far from dismissible.
  11. 70
    Thrives on vivid incidentals and telling details.
  12. If you like your substance short on style, or just want a change of pace from "X-Men," this is the film for you.
  13. Reviewed by: Jonathan Holland
    70
    All the main characters make a telling contribution to the claustrophobic web of feelings the drama comprises.
  14. The sheer neurotic intensity of Techine's characters--characteristically stretching both backward and forward in time, as in a Faulkner novel--holds one throughout, as does Techine's masterful direction and many of the other performances.
  15. 67
    Has storytelling rambles and lapses that no amount of electrifying jump-cuts and original image-making can compensate for.
  16. Techine has a delicate touch and these lovely moments flow with a life that Martin's heavy, stumbling psychodrama can't match.
  17. 63
    A mess, but a fascinating one.
  18. Reviewed by: Ken Fox
    60
    That Techine manages to coax a somewhat happy ending from this staid, somber film is heartening proof that what doesn't kill us might indeed make us stronger.
  19. It's as if, in exploring the scars that shape these personalities, Téchiné has forgotten to color in the flesh.
  20. 58
    Eventually becomes tedious.
  21. 50
    It's one of those movies whose appeal depends on the viewer's tolerance for watching French people suffer, smoke and sigh prettily.
  22. Best watched while doing a crossword or reading the paper.