- Studio: Arenas Entertainment
- Release Date: Feb 22, 2013
- Starring: Benito Martinez, Castulo Guerra, Dolores Heredia, Joaquín Cosio, Joseph A. Garcia, Luis Bordonada, Luke Ganalon, Manuel Garcia-Rulfo, Miriam Colon, Reko Moreno
- Summary:
- Director: Carl Franklin
- Genre(s): Drama, War
- More Details and Credits »
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 10 out of 17
-
Mixed: 7 out of 17
-
Negative: 0 out of 17
-
100Carl Franklin's film is true to the tone and spirit of the book. It is patient and in no hurry. It allows a balanced eye for the people in its hero's family who tug him one way and another.
-
75Writer-director Carl Franklin offers up a tone of heightened reverence that weighs down the material, but there are small, lovely moments when the magic realism approaches the magical.
-
70This material would never have attracted a major studio, so Christy Walton — heir to the Wal-Mart fortune — financed the picture herself, not because of any desire to become a movie mogul but simply because of her passion for the novel. She allowed the filmmakers to work without major stars or obvious commercial hooks added to the story. Although the film doesn’t always sustain dramatic impact, its fidelity to the spirit of the novel is impressive.
-
63Obviously a labor love, and its very existence in a godforsaken marketplace is a minor miracle.
-
60Volumes are said about class, assimilation, and the ways the assimilated sometimes shame and scar those who haven't shorn themselves of ethnic or racial signifiers. There is pungency in this shorthand, in these sketches that are richly evocative without saying too much or giving too little. You can't help but wish the movie had more of it.
-
50The film isn’t overlong. But it tries to fit so many themes into its brief running time — that it merely touches on most conflicts instead of exploring them in depth or with any delicacy.
-
Feb 22, 201340The lyrical book is filled with touches of magical realism. On the other hand, the movie is sorely lacking in both magic and realism. It’s all very empty and blah.
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 2 out of 4
-
Mixed: 0 out of 4
-
Negative: 2 out of 4
-
Feb 23, 20138
-
-
Feb 26, 20137
-
-
Mar 4, 20133
-
-
Sep 27, 20133
-