- Starring: Adam Driver, Greta Gerwig, Michael Zegen, Mickey Sumner, Patrick Heusinger
- Summary: This small budget, black-and white-collaboration between writer/director Noah Baumbach and writer/star Greta Gerwig centers on Frances (Gerwig), an apprentice dancer fumbling through post-college life in New York City.
Above all, Frances Ha is a wry and moving portrait of friendship, highlighting the way that two people who know everything about each other can nevertheless grow apart as their needs change.
Frances Ha also marks the rare instance in which an actress has the perfect role at the perfect time. Ms. Gerwig's work here is fragile, delicate, subject to bruising; something that could wither under too much attention. Perhaps Ms. Gerwig is the greatest actress alive. And maybe Frances Ha is just the ghost orchid of independent cinema.
Aiming for lightness but landing with a thud, Frances Ha is a well-meaning blunder. Director Noah Baumbach’s ode to Brooklyn twentysomething life is a flibbertigibbet fable that, like a self-absorbed flirt you meet at a party, grates on the nerves despite being easy on the eyes.
Dec 20, 2013It was my personal favourite of the year. I just can't show how much I
loved this movie but will try my best in this review to explain. ItIt was my personal favourite of the year. I just can't show how much I
loved this movie but will try my best in this review to explain. It was
just like the movie 'The Pursuit of Happiness' where it describes a
person's struggle over professional as well the relationship with a
best friend. I don't know why this movie was in black and white but
very seductive, like women from Charles Chaplin movies. The expressions
are 'the killer' if you are a man who fall easily for struggling women.
'Ruby Sparks' is my one of the year's favourite which was written by
the lead female of the movie and the same goes to 'Celeste and Jesse
Forever'. I know it is out of topic but I was saying the lead actress
from this movie who played Frances wrote this. All these were women
oriented subjects which rendered the movies from a distinct angle.
Frances is a cute and sarcastic woman in her late 20s lives with a best
friend Sophie in New York city. She is not talented but as a
professional dancer she earns enough to lead a happy life. Once she and
her boyfriend breakup, Sophie too throws an another bomb as she decides
to move out to live with her boyfriend. One after another her battle to
survive in the city for rich remains hopeless. But pursue for her dream
never ends as she wanted to be a fine choreographer. For all these she
must hold back her downs of her life and aim only up to self discover
the meaning of the life. Did she successful or not is what the movie
steadily chronicles her efforts.
The character Frances will be remembered for a long time, especially by
me. I just did not only had a fondness on that character but it
completely transformed me as one. In fact I felt the movie deeply into
me that I regretted for unable to give my support to Frances. I came to
know I am in love with Frances in the scene where she runs on the
streets of Chinatown. I think it is the best scene of the movie, very
adorable. You must watch the movie till the last frame before the end
credits roll up to know the meaning of this strange title. It was a
silly reason to have names like this for a movie but completely cool
and refreshing. It is not a thought provoking or an art movie but
believe me it is definitely a must see movie of the year.… Expand
Jul 13, 2014This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Not only love, but sex, or rather, as Helen puts it, the "whole package", is what the art gallery curator wants from her coupling with Jessica, who insists on downplaying sex as being just one component" in a "loving and tender" relationship. "What we have is a friendship," she protests, "best friends", even, which for her incrementally straight partner, a journalist, is enough. How did Francois Truffaut tackle the same terrain of sexual politics, as portrayed in Kissing Jessica Stein? The narrator, in Jules and Jim, recalls how "people called them Don Quixote and Sancho Panza," and that "rumors circulated behind their backs about their unusual friendship." Although Jules puts the kibosh on Jim's pursuance of Catherine, whom we presume to be his lover par excellence, we later learn, after both men return from war, that their marriage is marked by celibacy. Sabine looks nothing like her father, Jim notes. Catherine's satiation, Jules admits, comes from other lovers. When he hands over Catherine without any hesitation or qualms, it's because the cuckolded husband apprizes his best friend's platonic love as being on par with his wife's feminine powers. Bi-curious Jessica, ultimately, doesn't covet women, and yet, bawls her eyes out over Helen's departure as if she did. Whereas Jessica, and Jessica alone would subscribe to the notion that "Jules' and Jim's friendship had no equivalent in love," Frances and Sophie take delight "in the smallest things" and accept "their differences with tenderness," a shared sensibility that transcends love of all persuasions. Manhattan settings both, essentially, Frances Ha picks up where Kissing Jessica Stein leaves off, but here, there is no analogue for Helen, since both Frances and Sophie are randy heterosexuals. "The coffee people are right. We are like a lesbian couple that doesn't have sex anymore," Frances says, sharing both cigarette, and inside joke, in regard to the careening apogee of their avowed sexual orientation. Modern love, indeed. Only David Bowie can explain them. When Frances' laptop light goes out, like a lover, Sophie stops the aspiring dancer from adjourning to her own room, and like a lover who nags about a partner's annoying little habits, she softly chastises Frances over her bad decorum, regarding socks in bed. Socks are the only piece of clothing she removes, which may surprise the viewer, since all of New York can see the uninhibited pair carrying on like Don Quixote and Sancho Panza. Alas, so who is Jules? And who is Jim? The film, it would seem, casts the titular character as Jules. Akin to the scene where Jim gives Catherine to his closest confidant, Frances, in a bequeathing of sorts, suggests that Sophie hook up with Lev, a roommate(one of her "two husbands", a Jules and Jim reference), which would reunite the Vassar graduates, turning the Manhattan apartment into something resembling her counterpart's crowded Austrian chalet. But Sophie, like Jim, already has a partner, and this is where Frances Ha diverges from the Jules and Jim template, since Frances' bespectacled friend remains loyal to Patch, whereas the German can't choose between Catherine and his fiancee. Frances, ever the martyr, rebuffs Lev's advances, because, perhaps, thinking ahead, she sees him as the key to luring Sophie back into her life, even though the Sacramento native thinks he's "magic". Back home for Christmas with family and friends, this transplanted New Yorker, now signified by tract housing instead of skyscrapers, and churchgoers instead of artists, seems less like a persona than a person, and more like a woman than a man. In NYC, she adopts the masculine role by paying for Lev's dinner, and also, Benji draws attention to her "weird man walk", suggesting that Frances is in drag, albeit less visibly than Catherine, who with chapeau and painted mustache, passes herself of as a man, one sunny day in France among the boys. Arguably, the scene where Frances teeters along the river Seine, the same river where Catherine jumps into, is not the first direct steal from Jules and Jim. While Frances' mother pounds on the bathroom door, the daughter lies down in the tub, more or less, underwater, which abstractedly recalls Catherine's drowning, when she drives, with Jim riding shotgun, off the dock. Like the similarly-themed Superbad, porn-lovin' Seth declares, "I don't know what I'm going to be into ten years from now," the same ambiguity imbues itself in this familial exchange: "Frances, how much longer?" asks mom. "I'll be out in a second," responds her adult child, or, maybe give it ten years. From an objective distance, Jules and Jim lock eyes, and for emphasis, the mis-en-scene freezes. What do the eyes say? In Frances Ha, the filmmaker instead employs close-ups and a shot/countershot during the climactic staring, following Frances' first show as a choreographer. We can see. What are we seeing?… Expand
May 26, 2013In a month of sequels (Star Trek 2, Hangover 3, Iron Man 3 you get the picture), it was nice to see something original on the screen withoutIn a month of sequels (Star Trek 2, Hangover 3, Iron Man 3 you get the picture), it was nice to see something original on the screen without a number in its title.
While it does not open or end strong, this movie's middle is filled with many great moments. It's beautifully photographed, often funny, and a good combo of Noah B. and Greta G.… Expand
Feb 12, 2014Certainly not a masterpiece, not even in its particularly niche subsubgenre, but I thought it was better than more than half the crap theyCertainly not a masterpiece, not even in its particularly niche subsubgenre, but I thought it was better than more than half the crap they released in the last two years. The black and white doesn't really fulfill the purpose and there's reason to believe it was chosen for budget rather than artistic value; anyway it's not annoying and Greta Gerwig's bulky, awkward character feels real notwithstanding the small plot holes (the mystery of how she can pay anything at all is left unveiled). Actually, I didn't find any of the characters to be very likeable, but I assume that's another take on recreating reality.
P.S.: Is that really a thing, walking out of cinemas? I don't understand, how can you rate something if you've seen half of it?… Expand
Sep 2, 2014To use black-and-white photography in film today is a gutsy move. Fortunately for Noah Baumbach it paid off--the lack of color allows focus onTo use black-and-white photography in film today is a gutsy move. Fortunately for Noah Baumbach it paid off--the lack of color allows focus on the character study at hand.… Expand
Nov 23, 2013Everything was great except for the blubbering blundering francis (greta gerwig) who even though she had few funny moments in all she justEverything was great except for the blubbering blundering francis (greta gerwig) who even though she had few funny moments in all she just kept on talking non stop a very bad influence for upcoming young adults.… Expand
Aug 26, 2014Frances is an "apprentice" dancer - which is hard to believe since she is very ungainly. Apart from "dancing" she never worked a real job inFrances is an "apprentice" dancer - which is hard to believe since she is very ungainly. Apart from "dancing" she never worked a real job in her life. Frances shares an apartment with BFF Sophie, in a sort of a "celibate" lesbian relationship (at least, from Frances' side).
Both girls have boyfriends, but Frances has no problem with dispassionately dumping hers, when he proposes she moves in with him. Unfortunately for Frances, Sophie actually moves in with her man, Patch. Frances, feeling hurt and betrayed (more strong lesbian vibes) cannot pay rent and moves in with another couple of slackers. Then she gets "temporarily" sacked from the dance company she works for and "sort of" runs out of money.
This does not stop her from flying to Paris for a weekend and from refusing a job as a "mere" accountant, which would not fulfil her artistic delusions. She meets with Sophie and Patch and comes to terms with them getting married. In the end, Frances accepts the "normal" job and moves into her own apartment, while maintaining her status as "undateable".
Shot in black & white, by director Baunbach, the movie tries and fails miserably to look like a mix of French nouvelle vague (specifically Jules & Jim) and early Woody Allen (specifically Manhattan).
Gerwig plays Frances as a lethargic young woman, lacking elegance and discipline, which presumably are needed for such a competitive and physical profession. Sophie is played by one of Sting's children and one of Streep's daughters plays another dancer, completing the cast of VIPs. Neither shines, but I guess being mediocre actresses will not hurt their careers.
Baumbach and Gerwig were (still are? Really don't care) a couple during the filming. Actress/director relationships usually produce mediocre movies, and this is just another one to add to the list.… Expand
Published: May 2, 2013Get the details (and watch trailers) for all of the key films heading to cineplexes between now and the end of August, including the latest Star Trek, Superman, and Hangover films, new features from Sofia Coppola, Joss Whedon, Noah Baumbach, Nicolas Winding Refn, and Edgar Wright, and much more.
Published: September 17, 2012Find out what critics are saying about over two dozen key movies that debuted at fall's three major film festivals, including "Silver Linings Playbook," "Argo," "To the Wonder," "Cloud Atlas," "Frances Ha," and more.