I saw this for free and walked out. What a piece of garbage. Worst movie ever.

The plot sounded promising at first, but it disappoints because at the end, it actually relies only on a ridiculous internet myth. The plot is therefore not substantiated. Lindsay's acting is passable. The only thing that saves this movie from a perfect zero score is perhaps her pole-dancing.

Many things can sink even the most earnest movie including an inane plot, over-the-top acting, a dreadful script or pretentious direction. This one's got it all.

Semi-passable acting and decent visual effects don't save the horrible plot that falls apart less than 15 minutes into the movie.

The real stars of this movie are, first, a color that appears in almost every scene that will have you seeing spots upon leaving, and secondly, a plot so unbelievable it makes you appreciate some of the movies during the Ben Aflec/Jennifer Lopez era. (well, that is a stretch). Therefore, the real mystery is why a director would take on this project, why any studio would fund it, and why the actors accepted the roles. This is nothing more than an over-the-top attempt to create a plot that astounds the audience, with a little "Texas Chainsaw Massacre" tossed in for grand effect. I think I would rather see Evan Almighty again, heck, I know I would.… Expand

This movie touched American hearts at their core. Whether it be the acting, reminiscent of a female Gary Grant, or the story, closely related to those Star Wars flicks and Bring It On: In It to Win It, there is something in this movie for the whole family. Buy some popcorn, gather with granny, and set phazers to FABULOUS, this film with succeed all expectations and take viewers on a whirlwind adventure through time, space, and Lindsay's appendages. A can't miss.… Expand

Couldn't sleep last night, saw the writeup on the cable guide and thought why not. Here's why: Lindsay Lohan is terrible. I didn't buy her in blue or red. I found her Dakota utterly predictable and pathetic. She's a fox, but couldn't arouse a 14 year old with that pole dance. The plot is terrible. Ludicrous even. Holes everywhere and makes zero sense. Shame really, the premise has a lot of promise. Preppy teen gets abducted by serial killer and wakes up in the hospital believing she is a character in one of her own stories. So much potential here, but this movie fails to deliver on every level. It wasn't scary, it wasn't sexy, it wasn't suspenseful, and it wasn't entertaining. Lindsay Lohan has become a bad actor in bad movies. What a waste.… Expand

Just checked this out on Starz. It's as bad as they say. The direction is horrible. All of the bright blues and reds are a desparate attempt at mystery and artistry, but it looks so astonishingly cheap that it starts to feel like a sixteen-year-old's MySpace page (OMG, it's all in black and white...except blue! How did you do that???). It completely destroys any tension. The scenes were strung together with the finesse of a high school student on iMovie. One scene drags along a police station, showing "MISSING" flyers and all of the cops in the station, only to pan to the sheriff who makes some smartass comment about bingo night as the scene is fading to black. This was the turning point for me---this was not just any average bad movie, this was a clunker for the ages. I won't get in to the twin stigmata crap, the absurd finale, the awful acting, and the terrible script that brought it all to fruition. For all of those who defend this awful, awful film, perhaps you just need to see what a good film like this looks like: go rent Seven. Everything about it is exponentially better. Seriously.… Expand

I know what killed Lindsay Lohan's career (and it wasn't getting all zooted out on blow).

An early contender for the Razzies.

You need to pay attention to the smallest detail to be able to understand the movie. It is very confusing and sometimes very awkward. The story is understandable however is weak, what reward are the steamy Lindsay Lohan's scenes. From bad, the movie becomes good. I have a few chances, but whatever. Lindsay would not have a twin sister, she keeps the whole story in mind, so that she can not feel pain. I read this somewhere and I adopted this hypothesis as well.… Expand

Did this movie deserve to be in theatres? No. Was this the best movie? No. Was it entertaining? Yes!!! This movie is actually okay if you pay attention to it. The acting was pretty good. And it doesn't deserve all these zeros.

Lindsay Lohan stays in this kind of role and shall not immediately transport back to ckicky flick's. This is a movie that captivates you, and has you hooked till the very end. Do not skip this, this is a very good movie.

Unfairly trashed as Z grade torture porn, Chris Sivertson's canny thriller is actually one of the nuttiest artsploitation flicks ever churned out by the Hollywood machine. Tabloid trainwreck Lyndsay Lohan flamed out in a spectacular fashion last year and among the collateral damage was the reputation of this star vehicle, which made a virtual sweep of the Razzie Awards for 2007. Apparently taking his cues from influences as diverse as Lynch (the black humor and surrealism), DePalma (the emotional pitch and film brat references), Cronenberg (the body horror) and Kieslowski (doppelgangers), Sivertson plunges the surprisingly game Lohan into a deliriously baroque, color-coded world of adoloescent anxiety and virgin/whore hysterics. With appearances by Art Bell, a hairless cat, stigmatic twins, a rechargeable prosthetic limb and Lohan's deliciously scuzzy poledancing, it's all here--including the film's unforgettable catchphrase cum motto "Everybody gets cut." Darkly funny, off-kilter, scary, sometimes poignant, always disreputable and sleazy, I Know Who Killed Me deserves a second look, HFS style. Don't miss it!… Expand

A very unique homage to those cheesy horror stories about a pretty girl being abducted by a serial killer. What this movie adds is an awesome twist, a creative color effect, and some (surprisingly) great acting.

It probably doesn't deserve an 8, but it doesn't deserve all those zeros, either. You guys need to get over yourselves. As for the movie, these are the elements it combines: a trippy, late-night-TV type semi-supernatural mystery; grotesque torture of a pretty girl; and 3 minutes of Lindsay Lohan pole-dancing in her underwear. That's extended to 5 minutes on the DVD. Decide for yourself if it's worth it based on that info. Personally, the torture stuff leaves me cold, but I can forgive a lot in return for 3 to 5 minutes of Lohan in her underwear.… Expand

This movie is such a big mess but i liked it a little.

I loved this movie!! i plan on going to buy it..the people that are giving zeros are pathetic. they wouldn't know a good movie if it hit them in the face. the plot was excellent and i think Lindsey did a great job at the role..I love it!

I like that it was not predictable. Her character was believable and kept me guessing. I will be buying this movie. I did not like the ending and will have to watch it again to understand.

I think this movie is a true testament to just how talented Linday Lohan is. I though it was great and it definitely doesn't deserve all those zeros. A gripping, spellbinding movie from start to finish, this is not a movie to be missed..... Neither is the pole dancing scene woth Lohan in her underwear, that's worth it alone.