Metascore
45 out of 100

Mixed or average reviews - based on 27 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 7 out of 27
  2. Negative: 4 out of 27
  1. Reviewed by: Jay Carr
    88
    Quite apart from wringing the last molecule of vividness from his freewheeling roster of loose cannons, he brings to his direction of Martin a finesse shared by only a few of the directors who have worked with the comedian-actor.
  2. 75
    A screwball film noir with a lot of medium laughs and a few great big ones,
  3. 75
    A funny and constantly surprising exercise in comic tension.
  4. 75
    Martin's most adventurous film in many years, may be next best thing to a quick shot of nitrous oxide.
  5. Martin is marvelous; through sheer charisma, he takes over certain scenes as if no one else is there.
  6. One moment it's farcical comedy, the next it's gruesome melodrama. The movie never finds the right tone.
  7. Novocaine is neither funny enough to be a comedy, nor dark enough to be a true film noir. Like the drug of the title, it just kind of leaves you numb and anxious to taste the good stuff once again.
  8. Reviewed by: Ellen Marshall
    60
    There are a few priceless moments, like Dr. Sangster trying to work on a patient, while removing a hot pink pair of panties from a nearby chair, and the discovery of a stuffed bunny complete with a full set of dentures on his fiance's bed.
  9. 60
    Atkins has trouble keeping the tension high and the jokes rolling. Halfway through he begins tripping over the noir genre's dark rules, and in the end he veers off into a haze of romantic redemption that Billy Wilder and Nicholas Ray would have scoffed at.
  10. 50
    The absurd meets the violent meets the droll, and we just watch from the outside, never having been drawn in by anything resembling believable feelings or behavior.
  11. Reviewed by: Claudia Puig
    50
    With Bonham Carter's been-there, done-that performance and a plot that spins out of control, we end up with a movie that you can't quite sink your teeth into.
  12. 50
    The film is weighed down by the decision of director David Atkins to throw too much into the mix. The result is a serious problem of consistency.
  13. If Novocaine fulfilled the promise of its premise and cast, it could be great. As it is, the film is sabotaged by writer-director David Atkins' failure to set a consistent tone and follow through.
  14. 50
    Martin seems uncomfortable and oddly waxen (the orange Al Gore makeup doesn't help), injecting Frank with neither restless anger nor wry humor.
  15. Nothing is particularly believable here, but there are still a few moments of silly, sinister fun.
  16. It's too bad the movie's intriguing effect wears off (so to speak) about two-thirds through.
  17. There are many things wrong with Novocaine, but the film's most gnawing pain is its clodhopper farfetchedness.
  18. Drowns promising ideas in a sea of missed details and unconvincing motivations.
  19. Reviewed by: Ken Fox
    40
    The mystery is terribly plotted and the satirical elements are limited and not very funny.
  20. 40
    Given his lackluster performance, even Martin, who is no stranger to sardonic humor, seems unsure about the film's tone.
  21. Reviewed by: Todd McCarthy
    40
    A Steve Martin vehicle that's not prankish or weird enough by half.
  22. Starts out stylishly, and promisingly, but then coarsens into a silly parody of film noir.
  23. There's a mechanical desire to work in as many outlandish twists as possible, and shallow grotesquerie quickly takes over.
  24. The result is a performance that is neither funny nor empathetic, and the romance that develops between the dentist and the junkie patient is not strong enough to support the mystery.
  25. 30
    Slack direction fails to touch a nerve. Martin was scarier and funnier extracting Bill Murray's molars without Novocaine in "Little Shop of Horrors." Now that was one crazy dentist.
  26. Spins an unconvincing, miscast noir tale.
  27. A coarse, witless and stunningly violent black comedy.
User Score

Generally favorable reviews- based on 7 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 4 out of 4
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 4
  3. Negative: 0 out of 4
  1. FrankO.
    9
    Second time watching this movie...a wild premise and great cinematograhy with black/white scenes. Good use of the cast, great plot twists. A guilty pleasure not seen by many people. Full Review »