Metascore
39

Generally unfavorable reviews - based on 23 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 5 out of 23
  2. Negative: 7 out of 23
  1. Reviewed by: Hollis Chacona
    78
    Only masterful performances keep this frankly sentimental film from foundering in a sea of syrup.
  2. The movie is lively, funny, and endearing until melodramatics and sentimentality take over in the last few scenes.
  3. 75
    Either you stand back and resist it, or you plunge in. There was something about its innocence and spunk that got to me, and I caved in.
  4. Because the movie is otherwise so well made and so full of sweet emotion and "good" values, I was happy to ignore the shortcomings.
  5. 70
    This friendly, briefly exciting story (1998), inspired by John Irving's A Prayer for Owen Meany, achieves a nice balance between caricature and nuanced characterization and even manages not to be cloying.
  6. Reviewed by: M.V. Moorhead
    60
    The film is a feeble shadow of a book that won over even those of us who are no special fans of Irving -- it's probably his funniest, least self-conscious work.
  7. Reviewed by: Ken Fox
    60
    Irving's dead-serious sense of spiritual purpose is here replaced with weepy sentiment and saccharine comedy. But knee-deep in syrup, the film manages to stand on its own -- mainly due to a terrific performance from young Smith and a host of winning supporting players.
  8. 60
    That Simon Birch is not as maudlin as it might have been is largely due to the intensely thoughtful, prickly performance of 11-year-old Ian Michael Smith, who plays Simon.
  9. Reviewed by: Ron Wells
    50
    If you were expecting a small art film, you know you're in trouble when the first thing you see is Jim Carrey.
  10. The film does not jerk tears as much as it knocks you down and runs away with them.
  11. 50
    It's an excursion into a melodramatic morass that occasionally becomes difficult to sit through because it's so cloying.
  12. 50
    Admirers of Irving's sprawling tome are sure to find Birch a botch.
  13. The film, "suggested by" John Irving's novel "A Prayer for Owen Meany," is so unabashedly manipulative -- and implausible -- that even while crying, many viewers may also feel abused.
  14. It allows for little of the dark and funny in Irving's picaresque morality fable. No room! Not with the buckets of bathos thrown our way, substituting for mass-market spiritual uplift!
  15. Reviewed by: Ken Marks
    40
    This tale of faith, fate, death, and redemption is non-threatening and also non-inspiring.
  16. A magical child movie in which the child is magical, yes, but the movie is not.
  17. Reviewed by: Jack Mathews
    30
    Johnson, on his maiden voyage as director, treats every scene as if it were a bonbon, almost too precious to consume, and Marc Shaiman's score is a running series of mood cues.
  18. Reviewed by: Dennis Harvey
    30
    Johnson (who scripted "Grumpy Old Men") flattens out any promise so completely that the feature resembles nothing so much as a subpar "Hallmark Hall of Fame" entry.
  19. This is a film whose sunny and insipid storytelling style is at odds with its material.
  20. Reviewed by: Simon Braund
    20
    In the title role, newcomer Smith shows vestiges of an intuitive and moving performance, but he's swamped by a veritable tsunami of sentimentality and hamstrung by cute dialogue.
  21. 20
    A movie bloated with character cliches and a bullying score that bludgeons us into whatever emotion composer Marc Shaiman thinks we should be experiencing.
  22. 20
    There's hardly a character, plot twist, or musical theme in the whole enterprise that isn't primed to go straight for the tear ducts, as if Johnson assumes that his audience is incapable of mounting a defense.
  23. No doubt there are those who will deem Simon Birch ''heartwarming.'' It is exactly the kind of movie that has given that hackneyed superlative a bad name.
User Score
7.3

Generally favorable reviews- based on 14 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 4 out of 5
  2. Negative: 0 out of 5
  1. Jan 5, 2014
    9
    This is a perfect blend of humor and a touching story that illustrates that every person has a unique purpose regardless of their physical attributes.
  2. Apr 26, 2013
    5
    I really liked this movie, and it would have been great, but I honestly don't think the director worked hard enough. I loved the actors, andI really liked this movie, and it would have been great, but I honestly don't think the director worked hard enough. I loved the actors, and this really had potential, which is the main reason why I'm not giving this movie a bad score, and I just feel that this movie is just a disappointment.

    I understand that this movie can connect to many people out there, but that doesn't mean that it is an excellent movie.

    There are a lot better movies out there for everyone to watch, and I mean in all genres.
    Full Review »
  3. NancyB.
    Mar 24, 2008
    10
    I absolutely loved the movie, I watched it, next day showed it to my sister and mother, watched it with them, then a few days later, I I absolutely loved the movie, I watched it, next day showed it to my sister and mother, watched it with them, then a few days later, I watched it with my husband, and I will probably watch it again, I recorded it so that I can watch while everyone is at work and school. This is the only movie that I have ever been able to watch over two times without getting bored with it. If 20 had been the very best score, I would have chosen it. Simon did an absolutely superb job or Ian Michael I should say, on his part. Nancy Barnes Full Review »