Generally favorable reviews - based on 40 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 31 out of 40
  2. Negative: 1 out of 40

Where To Watch

Stream On
Stream On

Critic Reviews

  1. [Keaton's] lost none of the spunk, sass, and ditzbomb charm of her "Annie Hall" days. She, quite simply, is marvelous. Too bad her similarly iconic co-star is such a toad. Jack never stops being Jack, to great distraction.
  2. Jack Nicholson and Diane Keaton are so good in Something's Gotta Give, it's a shame writer-director Nancy Meyers couldn't rein herself in a little more.
  3. 63
    Doesn't America's 50-and-fabulous set deserve better than a movie this superficial and pandering?
  4. It's wise, funny, honest right up to its last sadly dishonest scene, doesn't mock us more than we deserve and offers attractive women in various stages of undress.
  5. 70
    In the end I didn't believe in their relationship, but I was pleased to see Keaton tearing it up for two hours.
  6. 88
    [Keaton and Nicholson] bring so much experience, knowledge and humor to their characters that the film works in ways the screenplay might not have even hoped for.
  7. Doesn't always sizzle, but its stars do.
  8. Movies like this are meant to amuse and entertain, though, not instruct. Meyers's latest is worth seeing for its offbeat story, its tantalizing settings, and most of all, its spot-on acting, especially by Keaton and Nicholson.
  9. Every moment spent in the company of Keaton... is such a joy that the whole is more delightful than the sum of the formulaic ingredients. Keaton makes Nicholson bounce the way Shirley MacLaine once did in ''Terms of Endearment.''
  10. A sweet and fresh comedy that was a joy to watch.
  11. Stumbles in miscalculating how far it needs to go to make this particular romance convincing when, as another romantic comedy character put it, it had us from hello.
  12. 63
    It's a glossy, somewhat condescending comedy, with all the substance of a cone of soft vanilla ice cream.
  13. It's hard to imagine anyone other than Keaton pulling this off.
  14. 63
    Keaton's overamped girlishness, and the adolescent shenanigans she engages in, make a mockery of this overlong romantic comedy's stance as a celebration of mature love.
  15. Reviewed by: David Ansen
    The movie, which ricochets between farce and poignancy, casts just enough romantic pixie dust to leave you smiling. It's certainly not the last word on the subject, but it's an amiable start.
  16. With the likes of Nicholson, Keaton, Reeves and Peet -- and a fleeting, funny few minutes with McDormand -- Something's Gotta Give is never less than entertaining. And once in a while it's sweetly, and extremely, funny.
  17. 67
    As cinema, it's polenta, but it's made palatable by the piquant sauce with which these two great stars season it.
  18. Reviewed by: Sara Brady
    Frances McDormand, as Erica’s younger sister, flourishes in her few minutes of screen time. She’s flinty, ferocious, and purely hysterical.
  19. 63
    Despite the weak dialogue, there are still some laughs to be had. At the end of this long journey, we're rooting for Harry and Erica to be together. For the movie to get us to that point, regardless of its motives and methods, it can't be all bad.
  20. 75
    In an era of dumb farce, Something's Gotta Give is something special.
  21. The moments between the characters are absolutely full. It's a pleasure to watch such consummate professionals.
  22. Its script is sharp, its dialogue is acerbic, its stars could hardly be better and, in its more sparkling moments, it exudes some of the flavor and charm of the later Hepburn-Tracy comedies.
  23. Reviewed by: David Edelstein
    I love Nicholson here because he lets Keaton take the movie--and his relative reticence is very attractive.
  24. 70
    Mostly, it's just a pleasure to watch Keaton and Nicholson learning new steps in an old dance, stumbling to grab at happiness before it's too late.
  25. The film also does something quite remarkable for an American film: It makes middle-age love look sexy and hugely satisfying.
  26. Nobody else working in movies today can make her (Keaton) own misery such a source of delight or make the spectacle of utter embarrassment look like a higher form of dignity.
  27. But let's not mislead about acting gold: Without Nicholson and Keaton, the movie would be fair. With them, it's one of the few good romantic comedies this year. What we gotta give is thanks.
  28. Reviewed by: Scott Foundas
    Jokes about impotence, menopause and other middle-aged maladies reside where a screenplay ought to live.
  29. Wall Street Journal
    Reviewed by: Joe Morgenstern
    Diane Keaton has the crucial role, and she makes the most of it.
  30. Generally quite amusing, with a brilliant cast.
  31. It is a well written, nicely acted and smoothly directed battle of the sexes.
User Score

Generally favorable reviews- based on 65 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 25 out of 33
  2. Negative: 4 out of 33
  1. Aug 24, 2014
    There's something about Diane Keaton and Jack Nicholson together in this film. It's as if they are truly feeding off of each other's energies.There's something about Diane Keaton and Jack Nicholson together in this film. It's as if they are truly feeding off of each other's energies. Jack & Diane are the perfect mix for Nancy Meyers' finest work to date. It's really, really special. Full Review »
  2. Dec 9, 2012
    If Nicholson and Keaton weren't in this, no one would care one whit about the movie. The acting is good (though not their best), theIf Nicholson and Keaton weren't in this, no one would care one whit about the movie. The acting is good (though not their best), the cinematography is excellent, but the story is cliche, boring, and the dialogue is stilted and predictable. Full Review »
  3. Sam
    Apr 6, 2006
    Fantastic, hilarious, and moving, it's quite simply a great movie.