Mixed or average reviews - based on 17 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 9 out of 17
  2. Negative: 5 out of 17

Where To Watch

Stream On
Stream On

Critic Reviews

  1. A majority oriented movie that assumes sophisticated familiarity with a sexual minority.
  2. Berlanti brings a smart, witty, mainstream style to his well-crafted picture, which surely enhances its crossover appeal.
  3. It's the first mainstream gay movie that feels totally comfortable in its shoes.
  4. A slice-of-life where being gay is a fact of daily existence, not an excuse for existential dilemmas or grand tragedies.
  5. 75
    So likable, we go with it on its chosen level.
  6. 75
    The strength of the performances, along with the good will generated by these flawed but likable characters, carry the movie through.
  7. Funny and friendly and all-inclusive and unremarkable.
  8. Turns out to be a choppily written, unevenly acted exercise, no less shlocky and predictable than any of Hollywood's average second-string heterosexual comedies.
  9. An undemanding and reassuring amiability that made it a crowd-pleaser at Sundance.
  10. 60
    Emerges as an engaging if occasionally hokey inspirational melodrama about the importance of community in the face of life's disappointments.
  11. 50
    Shallow though it may be, is a breakthrough.
  12. Reviewed by: Ernest Hardy
    A constant video rental for a community that aches to see itself as banal and generic.
  13. Reviewed by: Jay Carr
    It plays like a pilot for what I imagine will be network TV's first all-gay sitcom.
  14. 36
    Pushes the standard tropes of gay romance movies a few more steps toward full-blown cliché-dom.
  15. 30
    He (Berlanti) shoots for bland entertainment and scores.
  16. 25
    This little serio-comedy contains absolutely nothing that warrants big-screen release. It's lit like TV, acted like TV and staged like TV.
  17. 20
    Bloated loquaciousness, damp self-absorption, and defensive reflexiveness on display here.
User Score

Generally favorable reviews- based on 14 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 6 out of 6
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 6
  3. Negative: 0 out of 6
  1. Keith
    Jul 30, 2007
    This is one of those movies that sneaks into your heart in spite of any protesting you might offer. I found some of it clumsily done, This is one of those movies that sneaks into your heart in spite of any protesting you might offer. I found some of it clumsily done, especially the big death that happens near the end. I found this completely unnecessary, as if the screenwriter was trying to check off some list of things that must happen in a romantic comedy. The movie succeeds, though, largely because the characters (and actors, too) are so likable and the scenes among them have the chemistry of real friendships. I must admit, I put this movie on often, when I feel like settling into something comforting and with characters who I now regard as my own friends. Nothing earthshattering here, but it is pleasant, funny, big-hearted, and at times, true to life. Full Review »