Metascore
53 out of 100

Mixed or average reviews - based on 25 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 12 out of 25
  2. Negative: 3 out of 25
  1. Reviewed by: Tracie Cooper
    88
    A perfect fairytale, adhering to The Princess Bride's standards of fighting, fencing, torture, and true love, without the ham-fisted moral element of so many of its fairy-tale predecessors.
  2. 75
    It is a joy to look at frame by frame, and it would be worth getting the Blu-ray to do that. I am not quite so thrilled by the story, which at times threatens to make "Gormenghast" seem straightforward.
  3. 75
    More like Disney's "Sleeping Beauty," somber, slow and elegant instead of frantic and dazzling.
  4. May not be a classic, but it still has a lot of class.
  5. 75
    A skillfully managed fairy tale about a mouse, a rat, and fairy tales in general.
  6. Reviewed by: Sheri Linden
    70
    A rare creature, not only for the handmade look and subtlety of its computer-generated imagery but also for its irony-free embrace of once-upon-a-time storytelling.
  7. A pleasantly immersive, beautifully animated, occasionally sleepy tale.
  8. 67
    Despereaux at least has too much ambition rather than too little, but its curiously intellectual pleasures suggest a quaint puzzle rather than a passionately loved fairy tale.
  9. I admired the craft more than I loved the results. But The Tales of Despereaux is still better-than-average animation.
  10. The tiny, intrepid rodent is so cute it's impossible not to ooh and aww, just looking at him. Which is a good thing, because you'll need something to get you through the long stretches of fairytale pastiche that make up this overwrought yarn.
  11. Reviewed by: Claudia Puig
    63
    While the story does not quite come to magical life, the themes of courage, hope and decency are sweetly inspiring.
  12. 63
    While the voice acting is fine and the story is nicely paced, the visuals are disappointing.
  13. The flatly generic results certainly appear at odds with the picture's stirring visual style, which pays homage to the great Flemish artists.
  14. Reviewed by: Staff (Not credited)
    60
    While it meanders on its way to the requisite happy ending, the lush, stylised animation and courtly flourishes would win over anyone.
  15. Reviewed by: Adam Markovitz
    58
    Too bad the story's such a mess.
  16. Reviewed by: Bob Mondello
    50
    A little slow for the very youngest kids -- though the messages it imparts are certainly ones you'll want them to hear.
  17. The movie is a freakish creature, with lush, painterly animation inspired by Dutch and Flemish masters, attached to a convoluted, gloomy narrative punctuated with scenes of sadism that rival "The Dark Knight."
  18. Unfortunately, the life has been sucked out of DiCamillo's story about a brave, unusual little mouse.
  19. Reviewed by: Justin Chang
    50
    This graphically well-rendered kidpic is less crass and mouthy than many recent feature-length toons, but also more sluggish and ungainly as it tries to approximate DiCamillo's singularly delicate tone.
  20. Reviewed by: John Anderson
    50
    As usual with these animated epics, much depends on the vocal performances, and it's a mixed bag.
  21. Many of the charms of Kate DiCamillo's best-selling children's book are lost in this British animation by Dreamworks alumni Sam Fell (Flushed Away) and Rob Stevenhagen.
  22. Reviewed by: Stina Chyn
    40
    As easy as it is to pass down mantras of fear and hate from parent to child or society to community (and individual), so is the imprinting of courage and compassion through conversation, emulation, books, plays, films, and the like. The Tale of Despereaux, aims to share such a message.
  23. The lesson learned from The Tale of Despereaux is that an overabundance of vocal talent does not a good cartoon make.
  24. Reviewed by: Ella Taylor
    30
    Clumsily wedged in like a TV commercial between deafening stunts, the emotional storytelling sinks without trace, leaving you with only one flawed character to cling to.
  25. Kids will get antsy, wondering why their favorite characters disappear for long stretches of the film, while adults will wonder just when this scattershot approach to storytelling will congeal into something resembling coherence.
User Score

Mixed or average reviews- based on 32 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 12 out of 21
  2. Negative: 7 out of 21
  1. This film was a mess. The plot was like three very crappy early-morning children's TV shows stripped of all personality and quirk and rolled into an hour and a half of extremely dull, artsy-fartsy, fragmented storylines. They obviously pushed the 'morbid' theme as far as they could while still advertising as G-rated.
    I thought the voice acting was pretty bad despite all the big names that worked on this movie. Every time Sigourney Weaver jumped in to preach at us through the narration, I couldn't help groaning a little ... it was that bad.
    I haven't read the book, but I have a feeling that most of the parts I really loathed were invented for the film.
    Full Review »
  2. They changed several things about the book that simply didn't work for the film. One thing, where Despereaux is a just a boy and has Dustin Hoffman's older than dirt voice, the cook' s friend made from kitchen ingredients and the bad rat just kept jumping around the side he was on. Full Review »
  3. Two years ago during Christmas of 2008, I got this book of the same name written by author Kate Dicamillo. I read it, enjoyed it, and was desperate to see this CGI movie-adaptation of a great book. I did saw it at the Clifton Park Mall at Albany, New York during my visit with my cousins at Christmas. Throughout the whole movie, it didn't meet my expectations, but for a kids movie, its just pretty decent.

    The storyline was weak and scrambled, it had some very dark moments and the villain's death in the movie was very mediocre, but the animation was excellent, The characters were worth-seeing, The acting was great, and The music score by William Ross was lovely.

    Although, did I forget to mention that it had every single actor I've known for the past few years? Man, was that awesome! H*ll, Even Matthew Broderick (The Lion King, Bee Movie), Emma Watson (The Harry Potter Series), and Dustin Hoffman (Kung Fu Panda) were so freaking good.

    Bottomline: "The Tale of Despereaux" isn't the best CGI cartoon and its not intended for adults, but for the kids, its definitely worth a watch on DVD rental only.

    Rating: 3 1/2 out of 5 stars
    Full Review »