GAMES: GameSpot | GameFAQs MUSIC: Last.fm | MP3.com MOVIES: Metacritic | Movietome TV: TV.com
Home | About Metacritic | About Metascores | What's New | Wireless Versions | Discussion Forums | Advertising Inquiries | Contact Us | RSS
Metacritic.com: We Deal With Criticism
     Help
> Switch to Advanced Search  
Film Video/DVD Music Games TV

Music

Upcoming Release Calendar
All-Time High (And Low) Scores
Best Of 2008
Best Of 2007
Best Of 2006
Best Of 2005
Best Of 2004
Best Of 2003
Best Of 2002
Best Of 2001
Best Of 2000
How Metascores Are Calculated
Discuss Music In Our Forums

 

Upcoming & Recent Releases

sort by name sort by score

69 AC/DC
73 Ryan Adams
67 Trace Adkins
59 Akon
66 The All-American Rejects
81 The Alps
92 Amadou & Mariam
66 Anastacia
73 Anathallo
66 Annuals
75 Antony And The Johnsons
58 David Archuleta
77 Aterciopelados
72 Attic Lights
81 Belle & Sebastian
61 Beyonce
83 Black Milk
69 Bloc Party
71 Bonnie "Prince" Billy
67 Brandy
66 The Bronx
67 Ane Brun
92 Buena Vista Social Club
72 Isobel Campbell & Mark Lanegan
64 Castanets
64 Cat Power
67 Catfish Haven
65 Tracy Chapman
60 Kenny Chesney
65 Tony Christie
81 The Clash
67 Coldplay
69 Keyshia Cole
52 Common
67 David Cook
70 Nikka Costa
61 Cradle Of Filth
68 Crooked Fingers
76 Crystal Stilts
72 Rivers Cuomo
69 The Cure
77 Danielson
74 The Dears
80 Deerhoof
81 Deerhunter
70 Brett Dennen
79 Department Of Eagles
68 Devin The Dude
73 Dido
75 Dillinger Four
81 DJ/rupture
61 Dragonette
85 Dub Colossus
86 Bob Dylan
77 Eagles Of Death Metal
79 El Guincho
57 Electric Six
75 Brian Eno + David Byrne
74 Fall Out Boy
86 Fennesz
75 The Fireman
83 The Foreign Exchange
61 Jamie Foxx
69 Free Blood
85 Fucked Up
77 Gang Gang Dance
62 Ghostface Killah
63 Girls Aloud
78 Glasvegas
76 Glasvegas
67 Gojira
78 Holly Golightly
83 Grails
72 Grampall Jookabox
66 Guns N' Roses
73 Anthony Hamilton
76 Hauschka
69 Headhunter
61 Kieran Hebden and Steve Reid
66 Her Space Holiday
49 Hinder
71 Jolie Holland
79 Hush Arbors
81 Frida Hyvonen
68 I'm From Barcelona
63 The (International) Noise Conspiracy
75 Jake One
53 Japanese Motors
81 Johann Johannsson
70 Grace Jones
63 Tom Jones
73 Justice
70 Kaiser Chiefs
64 Keane
76 Toby Keith
69 The Killers
77 The Knux
71 Mark Kozelek
73 Femi Kuti
73 Lady GaGa
76 Lambchop
73 Ray LaMontagne
74 Land Of Talk
68 John Legend
71 Little Joy
60 The Little Ones
64 Longwave
83 Los Campesinos!
78 Love Is All
68 Ludacris
78 Luomo
61 Jesse Malin
66 Margot & The Nuclear So And So's
69 Maroon 5
61 The Matthew Herbert Big Band
76 Max Tundra
61 Megapuss
74 Micah Blue Smaldone
57 Ingrid Michaelson
75 The Mighty Underdogs
77 Juana Molina
82 Mount Eerie
46 Mudvayne
75 Musiq Soulchild
49 Nickelback
66 Oasis
68 O'Death
71 Of Montreal
54 The Organ
70 Brad Paisley
82 Pale Young Gentlemen
78 Parts & Labor
92 Pavement
69 Pink
75 Benoît Pioulard
61 Plies
73 The Postmarks
74 The Pretenders
81 Q-Tip
42 Queen + Paul Rodgers
71 The Rapture
57 Razorlight
70 Lou Reed
71 Reefer
69 Jonas Reinhardt
76 Religious Knives
65 Rise Against
76 The Rosebuds
82 Arthur Russell
72 Nitin Sawhney
85 Scarface
69 School of Seven Bells
73 The Sea And Cake
59 Seal
64 Secret Machines
74 Blake Shelton
78 The Sight Below
72 Simon Bookish
89 The Smiths
70 Todd Snider
67 Snow Patrol
45 Soulja Boy
64 Britney Spears
62 Spinto Band
66 Squarepusher
82 Marnie Stern
63 The Streets
67 Sway
81 Taylor Swift
54 Those Dancing Days
85 Thursday/Envy
76 Tobacco
70 T-Pain
66 Travis
76 Vic Chesnutt, Elf Power, And The Amorphous Strums
82 Butch Walker
58 Scott Weiland
75 Kanye West
73 White Denim
79 Wild Beasts
77 Wilderness
71 Hank Williams III
72 Lucinda Williams
67 Michelle Williams
73 Lee Ann Womack
76 Women
72 Rachael Yamagata
61 Yo Majesty
86 Neil Young

Stars indicate the most critically-acclaimed albums.

 



Printer-Friendly Version Email This Page Discuss In Our Forums

Return To The Sea
by Islands

Islands reviews
Critic Score
Metascore: 80 Metascore out of 100
User Score  
8.3 out of 10
based on 18 reviews
Read critic reviews
How did we calculate this?
based on 39 votes
Read user comments
Rate this album

The debut disc for the new band from former Unicorns members Nick Diamonds and J'aime Tambeur includes appearances from members of Royal City, Wolf Parade and Arcade Fire.

LABEL: Equator / Rough Trade
RELEASE DATE: 04 April 2006
DISCS: 1 disc
GENRE(S): Indie, Rock

What The Critics Said

All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...

90
All Music Guide
A rich, exciting, and emotionally deep sounding album that carries on the freewheeling spirit and sound of the Unicorns as well as that of the Elephant 6 bands of the late '90s.
Read Full Review
90
Billboard
The duo's current sonic incarnation favors melody over mayhem, and all the better for it.
Read Full Review
84
Filter
It's sprawling, ambitious pop music. It's just not perfect--not yet. [#20, p.92]
84
Pitchfork
Return to the Sea is a case of Diamonds and Tambeur yanking up their anchor and setting sail for new waters, enjoying the freedoms of exploration and discovery.
Read Full Review
83
The Onion (A.V. Club)
A tighter, more controlled version of The Unicorns' wackiness.
Read Full Review
83
Almost Cool
This album is a great deal of fun.
Read Full Review
83
Entertainment Weekly
The Frank Zappa/Neutral Milk Hotel/Muppet Show vibe doesn't always jibe, but that's half the fun. [7 Apr 2006, p.63]
80
cokemachineglow
Those who felt like maybe they were starting to get Who Will Cut Our Hair When We’re Gone? only to be left out by Unicorns’ sudden dissolution should be reassured that Return to the Sea is a more rooted and confident effort.
Read Full Review
80
Prefix Magazine
Return to the Sea is filled with breezy, infectious melodies and quirky whip-smart lyrics; qualities that were sometimes lost underneath the Unicorns' shtick.
Read Full Review
80
Dusted Magazine
Return to the Sea reins in its eccentricities successfully enough to illustrate that the most understated risks can be the most rewarding.
Read Full Review
80
PopMatters
What is surprising is the consistent quality of the songwriting.
Read Full Review
80
Under The Radar
Islands have made a grand entrance into the indie-rock world. [Summer 2006, p.90]
75
Stylus Magazine
Thanks to some subtly disquieting diction it’s almost as disturbingly memorable as a cuddly cartoon blood orgy.
Read Full Review
70
Alternative Press
Amid the highlife guitars and percussion that give Sea a delightful Afro-pop sheen... it's impossible to ignore the creeping conventionalism of the disc's best tracks. [Jun 2006, p.178]
70
New Musical Express
A one-way ticket to the outer limits of the solar system. [8 Apr 2006, p.39]
60
Q Magazine
At times Return To The Sea can be too clever for its own good. But there's also an ambition here that's hard to knock. [May 2006, p.126]
60
NOW Magazine
While the bouncy good-time foolery is charming enough in small doses, Islands' relentlessly giddy glee gets annoying awfully fast.
Read Full Review
50
Tiny Mix Tapes
There are some redeeming qualities, but for every success there are one or two failures.
Read Full Review

What Our Users Said

Vote Now! The average user rating for this album is 8.3 (out of 10) based on 39 User Votes
Note: User votes are NOT included in the Metascore calculation.

[Anonymous] gave it a10:
One of the best this year. A constantly fun and interesting listen. "Swans (Life After Death)" is one of the best songs this year.

Flinch Bot gave it a10:
Album of the year so far.

Kevin M gave it a9:
A pop masterpiece. This isn't the Unicorns back from the dead, Nick Diamond in a new project with a whole different mood, and sound than the Unicorns. This is a rich piece of work, it has probably the best pop song of the year (Rough Gem), a fantastic epic opener and some other great highlights such as "Don't Call me Whitney, Bobby", "Where There's A Whale There's A Whalebone", and "Bucky Little Wing". Definitely listen to this for some great organic pop and some great instrumentation. This album IS an adventure as someone else pointed out.

anonymous gave it a10:
YAY! The Unicorns are back!

miguel c gave it a10:
ill give it a ten if not for its feel good vibe but its its uniqueness. i havnt heard anything this adventurous in a while.

Heidi S gave it a9:
I really love this album. I'll have to agree with others that one or two songs are lacking (yes, track 10), but the rest are SO GOOD it totally makes up for it. I NEVER thought rough gem sounds like we didn't start the fire and now that you've said that I've gone back and listened to it and I still don't. Rough Gem is one of my favorite songs on this album and I think it's silly that people are comparing it to billy "i crash cars into houses" joel. the tempo is different, the instrumentation is different. the reason you can probably sing we didn't start the fire over the song is probably because the melody seems to maybe use roughly the same number of total notes (but i don't even believe this). but that's all. it just does not fit. that is one of the silliest comparisons i've ever heard. Anyhow, I think 2006 has so far been a pretty sad year in indie music, but this is one of the few good albums. I love it.

Jason L gave it an8:
The melody to track 4 is so close to Billy Joel's "We Didn't Start the Fire" it's distracting...you can literally sing along to "We Didn't Start the Fire" and it matches almost perfectly. Track 10 sucks. All subtle build-up with absolutely no payoff. But all in all, this is a really good album. I find some of the tracks to be terrific, many are good, a few are disappointing.

Read more user comments...

Discuss this album in our forums

Return to top of page
Home | FILM | DVD/VIDEO | MUSIC | GAMES | TV | Forums | About Metacritic metacritic.com

Popular on CBS sites: MLB | Spore | iPhone 3G | Paris Hilton | Antivirus Software | GPS | Recipes | Shwayze | NFL

About CBS Interactive | Jobs | Advertise

© 2008 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use