- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
Bright Ideas is more pleasant than kick-ass or inspired. But for an album this deep into his career, at a time when he could start growing aesthetically antsy, McCaughan sticks to a blueprint that works best.
-
As good as Bright Ideas is, though, I still can't recommend it over say, the last Superchunk record.
-
Under The RadarWhile McCaughan retains a lot of his vitality, he can't completely shake off the specter of comfortable maturity. [#11, p.116]
-
Bright Ideas sounds pretty much like a decent, later-period Superchunk record.
-
Paste MagazineEvery track here is strong.... Portastatic's best yet. [Oct/Nov 2005, p.122]
-
Alternative PressBoth exhilaratingly rocking and gorgeously pensive. [Nov 2005, p.210]
-
The songs are reliably mid-tempo and catchy, although they certainly lack the heedless rush that made the first Superchunk albums such models of indie rock.
-
Portastatic is exactly as advertised: catchy, sometimes dumb, occasionally rockin', but always at least competent pop.
-
MagnetOn par with anything in the back catalog. [#69, p.106]
-
At ten tracks, Bright Ideas doesn’t have a lot of fat, but it ultimately feels like it could have been more successful on the EP format McCaughan is so fond of.
-
While the batch he's cooked up on his the latest LP... stays true to the songwriting formula that has gained him over a decade of accolades, "Bright Ideas" does, in fact, find McCaughan at his most sonically expansive to date.
-
More than the sound, the words of Bright Ideas are especially important; they are not particularly eloquent, but they are representative something larger: each clumsy, unsure expression desperately needs to be said.
-
Spine-tinglingly great.
-
Bright Ideas has an air of excitement and energy about it, and contains some of McCaughan's strongest songwriting to date.
-
The best record of his career, a collision of the idiosyncratic charms of Portastatic with the exuberant rock power of Superchunk.
Awards & Rankings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 5 out of 6
-
Mixed: 1 out of 6
-
Negative: 0 out of 6
-
leshecticOct 10, 2005
-
BrianMSep 7, 2005
-
raulzSep 7, 2005