- Record Label: Sony
- Release Date: Oct 23, 2007
User Score
Generally favorable reviews- based on 125 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 86 out of 125
-
Mixed: 6 out of 125
-
Negative: 33 out of 125
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
TH.Oct 28, 2007After 3 listens, you come to realise this is some of Coheeds' best work. Lots of different influences and generally harder and darker the the previous albums.
-
-
JackMOct 30, 2007As per all other Coheed albums, amazing. Great storyline of songs.
-
-
JBApr 2, 2008A proper 7,5. Currently the definition of a modern rock opera! Not as good as In keeping secrets..., but way better than the first installment of Good Apollo. While in no respect my favourite band, (not even within the prog or indie genres) this is quality.
-
-
JoshC.Sep 8, 2008The culmination of a grandiose sci-fi story entwined with break-taking atmosphere and ripping guitar riffs.
-
-
ShaneB.Nov 27, 2007I dunno why people are s h i t t ing on this album. Honestly Ican't thinnk of one song thats not good. And I can think of plenty that area absolutely excellent- No World for Tomorrow, Mother Superior, Gravemakers and Gunslingers, The End Complete, On the Brink. Keep listening, maybe you'll realise the truth.
-
-
EricOct 23, 2007This is their best album yet. Way better than the last album they put out and even tops SSTB and IKSOSE:3. It took me awhile to really get into the somewhat different feel of the album...but now it's simply amazing. I'd definatly recomend it to anyone.
-
-
NinoOct 25, 2007A super-solid album that exceeded my expectations. There's some very unexpected instrumentation here, with great references to previous songs for the astute listener No filler-ish sounding tracks. A great listen end to end!
-
-
CodyKickOct 26, 2007This album to me is a throwback to their old albums in several ways. I hear alot of IKS in many of the songs (the end of The Hound is pure IKS), and the layout of the album is similar to second stage, in that the album doesn't so much flow as that each song is different and very good on their own. Feathers is amazing, and MOther Superior is possibly their best song.
-
-
BrettH.Oct 27, 2007
-
-
TyroneHOct 29, 2007This album really is good, yet, not for people who may not favour his vocals, but after 3 listens, the album really does captivate you and leaves you no other choice but to love it.
-
-
MaxN.Oct 30, 2007
-
-
JasonC.Oct 30, 2007Another beautiful, creative, and technically unbelievable entry into Coheed and Cambria's montage of art work. Did Claudio sell his soul to the devil to get his uncanny writing ability and guitar-riffing mastery?
-
-
SamH.Oct 11, 2008Absolutely unbelievable. This is by far the best CD that I own, and is my favorite of them so far. Exciting and intelligent guitar work and the beautiful, yet strange vocals combine to create an incredible album that I would recommend to ANYONE that has even a passing interest in quality music.
-
-
CalvinP.Jun 3, 2008Frankly i don't understand the people giving this album a 0 if you do not enjoy this music in the slightest i don't think i would listen to ANY music you recommend have fun with your hip hop garbage
-
-
FoxM.Nov 17, 2007People who just say they're a crappy emo band don't know what they're talking about. Disregard their ignorant opinions and form your own.
-
-
KevinB.Oct 23, 2007Exactly what you would expect from C&C.
-
-
AlCOct 23, 2007
-
-
JohnU.Oct 27, 2007Honestly, if you don't like the guy's voice, don't listen to it. don't go and give it a bad score when you haven't even listened to it, but just that you know you won't like it because you don't like their other "garbage." I do like coheed, and I do like this album, therefore, I give my score
-
-
JasonS.Mar 27, 2008Beautiful album from an intelligent and talented band (both in songwriting and in lyrical mastery). Once again, Coheed & Cambria prove that it is one of a kind.
-
-
Apr 11, 2011Absolutely amazing. Claudio's vocals are just incredible, and Mic and Travis do great on bass and guitar. Taylor Hawkins does great as a fill-in for Chris Pennie. Songs mix radio rock like Feathers with hardcore like The Hound. A fine album, and the second best they've made in my opinion.
-
CurtisROct 30, 2007I think this is a great album, probably their best yet
-
-
gMay 4, 2008
-
-
BobJ.Jun 7, 2008Everyone that is giving this a 0 is just a huge D-bag. Their favorite band is probably Matchbox 20 or Nickelback.
-
-
TomLanceNov 30, 2007This album has been very unfortunately gilted from the limelight it so richly deserves! Most reviews against it are merely written by people who don't like their style of music. Which is frankly stupid, if you have something preferential about their music, do not review them. (ie. spin)
-
-
RJWOct 23, 2007
-
-
PatrickOct 24, 2007Give it many listens and time. You'll discover that this is a superb album regardless of your previous Coheed experience.
-
-
RobertA.Oct 24, 2007Loving it. Want more, but every excellent album should leave you wanting more - that's a PLUS, not a negative.
-
-
ShawnM.Oct 24, 2007
-
-
AndrewM.Dec 7, 2007
-
-
EricCOct 29, 2007A very solid effort and possibly their best to date. You can really tell how much attention they've given to these songs and the album as a whole. Combining pop and prog is always a difficult affair and they pull it off quite well.
-
Awards & Rankings
-
Alternative PressCoheed's fourth album simply doesn't deliver on the suspense that's been loaded into it. [Nov 2007, p.155]
-
Coheed have found their sweet spot.
-
Entertainment WeeklyC&C infuse their expansive music with enough grit and melody that you don't give a hoot what, say, 'The Hound (Of Blood And Rank)' is about. [26 Oct 2007, p.67]