Infinity On High - Fall Out Boy
Metascore
75 out of 100

Generally favorable reviews - based on 23 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 18 out of 23
  2. Negative: 0 out of 23
  1. Lo and behold, it turns out these pasty emo boys are a pretty great blue-eyed soul band.
  2. So when you see Infinity On High getting praised, don't bother scoffing. This deserves to get praised. There's a lot on here that's great and pretty much nothing that's bad.
  3. FOB could've cut an album's worth of club hits and still found an audience. Its refusal to do so shows it still knows the difference between selling records and making fans.
  4. Gleaming with instant hooks, this is a uniformly radio-friendly album. It's also a hugely addictive and likeable one. [Mar 2007, p.108]
  5. 80
    Infinity on High reveals a group that has grown so confident with success that the members are willing to give in to their every musical whim. [Feb 2007, p.83]
  6. Some of the band's most gut-wrenching and powerful melodies to date. [Mar 2007, p.133]
  7. It requires a certain level of self-denial to hate Fall Out Boy, as in, "No, I don't like huge hooks, soaring choruses or wild-eyed expressions of youthful ambition." If so, congratulations, you're 800 years old. Or a Joanna Newsom fan.
  8. A shamelessly melodic, wild and powerful pop record. [10 Feb 2007]
  9. 70
    While none of the new album's hooks match the taurine-mainlining rush of "Sugar, We're Goin Down," there's still lots to love.
  10. For a band that was once so self-assured and able to utilize its talents so compellingly, the album is regrettably haphazard.
  11. On Infinity on High, they expose the secret life of boys, in hilariously bloodcurdling detail.
  12. They may not be happy, but they haven't forgotten to be catchy.
  13. The band's unusual songwriting method generally works.
  14. Essentially, Infinity On High is From Under The Cork Tree, except this time done well.
  15. Like Maroon 5... Fall Out Boy has found a middle ground where its raffish charm is edgy enough to engage teens in love with angst, and safe enough for the mass consumption that's sure to follow.
  16. Infinity on High is notably better than their previous installment.
  17. So once you get over the fact it's farcically emo, this album turns out to be a decent enough record to get you in the mood for the Saturday night indie disco.
  18. It's a CD stuffed to the gill with great tunes, but little else. There's nothing to hang your heart on, as much as there's a huge amount to move your head and feet to.
  19. 60
    A brave endeavour. But unlike My Chemical Romance's Black Parade, Infinity On High has critically little sense of its own ridiculousness. [Mar 2007, p.79]
  20. With a unique Backstreet Boys meets Bon Jovi production sheen, every track holds its own.
  21. Fall Out Boy hasn't turned into a band of rock-star blowhards yet; it's still too hyperactive and catchy. But the songs were more fun when it was a band of underdogs. [5 Feb 2007]
  22. Anthems are plenty on "Infinity on High," and odds are good the fans are so well versed in bassist/lyricist Pete Wentz's pun-saturated, self-referential verbiage that they'll simply surrender -- as they should -- to the familiar burly riffs and candied hooks.
User Score

Generally favorable reviews- based on 137 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 66 out of 106
  2. Negative: 37 out of 106
  1. OrlandoM
    10
    I liked this album simply because nobody but Fall Out Boy can create this awesomeness.
  2. DanielM
    9
    This album has been sorely underrated. Sure, it's not the best album ever, but one of the best pop records of the decade. This album contrasts with From Under The Cork Tree in that that album was a broad stroke of very catchy pop music with little depth, and this album is a tight referendum on the state of music and pop culture, with equally catchy pop rock music. Credits to Babyface, Neal Avron, and Butch Walker production, not to mention work from Patrick Stump. If this is not their magna opus, I can't wait to hear what is. Full Review »
  3. SamW
    10
    The Best Album Ever Made So Far!....But that might change when Folie A Deux is released.