User Score
Universal acclaim- based on 732 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 668 out of 732
-
Mixed: 22 out of 732
-
Negative: 42 out of 732
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
zacht.Dec 24, 2008A pretty bland album, nothing special or unique at all. It's not horrible album by any means but the scores it recieved do not represent what it really is. Beware if you are going to buy.
-
-
MattSep 27, 2004Ignore the hype - rip away the layers of this, what you get is background music. If you want something unassuming and unambitious that won't grab your attention too much, this is it. But if you're looking for something to grab you, the question "Is This It?", the answer is almost certainly no, though you may well ask yourself the same question.
-
-
AndrewGJun 29, 2006Desperately over-rated. Mostly forgettable and suprisingly dull. This album really isnt worth all the fuss that surrounds it. However there are several quality tracks on it such as the now classic Last Night and the brilliant Someday. At its best it shines. At its worse it drowns in repetative overproduction
-
-
DanielAApr 17, 2009The fact that it's been 8 years since this album was released and so far The Strokes haven't lived up to the hype the music press created around them, proves that all of those calling this album "overrated" were right.
-
-
AndrewRNov 21, 2003Catchy enough, I suppose, but Is This It? begs the question that its title poses-- that is, 11 tracks after the fact, there's little that sticks in the brain, except for maybe the Strokes's uncanny ability to make Television boring. For me, only "Trying Your Luck" really left an impression.
-
-
Jul 10, 2013
-
SalC.Oct 15, 2001The simple fact is that the best songs on the record are the (5) that had already been released on their (2) Rough Trade singles. As I had both them both months ago, the rest was dissapointing. If you have neither single, but my rating to an (8).
-
-
AaronL.Oct 7, 2002I can't figure it out. I've read the glowing reviews and listened to the disc many times, and I just can't understand the fuss. Although they have their good moments, I'm supposed to believe that these guys are the new gods of rock 'n roll? I don't think so. In either case, there is a lot riding on their next release - glad it's not me that has to do it!
-
-
EinarJ,Apr 30, 2008God, how overhyped, overrated and overplayed can you get ? Last Nite and Someday are the only songs worth mentioning, working as anthems of our time.
-
-
AlexF.Oct 14, 2001Most hyped band this year. Their music is ok but quite insubstantial. VU did this much better more than 30 years ago.
-
-
AlexF.Oct 14, 2001Most hyped band this year. Their music is ok but quite insubstantial. VU did this much better more than 30 years ago.
-
-
TomHAug 6, 2003Mediocre at best. So simple it's sickening, but no horrible in it's own right
-
-
CharleneL.Nov 27, 2001
-
-
EricS.Dec 13, 2001Is this it? Really? This what bandwagons full of people are raving about? No, it's not awful...but it's far from great.
-
-
unicoAug 13, 2008I still don't get how the world thinks the strokes re-invented rock'n'roll. this is a decent album, indeed! it may have brought indie/rock music to a broader audience aging, but that doesn't make it better music. clever album above average, but nothing more. 6.
-
Awards & Rankings
-
Apr 24, 2013Simply put, Strokes have every quality rock'n'roll requires from its finest exponents and Is This It is where they come together.
-
Able to make the timeworn themes of sex, drugs, and rock & roll and the basic guitars-drum-bass lineup seem new and vital again, the Strokes may or may not be completely arty and calculated, but that doesn't prevent Is This It? from being an exciting, compulsively listenable debut...
-
Their album is little more than thirty minutes and eleven versions of the same song. But damn if that one song isn't a good one.