User Score
Generally favorable reviews- based on 77 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 44 out of 77
-
Mixed: 11 out of 77
-
Negative: 22 out of 77
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
PaulNov 1, 2007haven't even heard this record, but the fact that it is only being sold at wal mart is disgusting. talk about out of touch. 2007 will go down in history as the year radiohead got it right and the eagles got it wrong.
-
-
JustinZ.Nov 4, 2007This could be the best album of the year, but the fact that it's only available at Walmart makes me sick. Shame on the Eagles.
-
-
JasonF.Nov 5, 2007Very very boring.
-
-
jjuveliNov 1, 2007horrible
-
-
brianr.Nov 4, 2007Could have been shortened to one disc.
-
-
TomHJan 3, 2009I loved the album. I thought it was fantastic! I was appalled by all the low ratings it got from the magazines, but I loved it.
-
-
DaveS.Nov 1, 2007
-
-
EdP.Nov 2, 2007A great testament to the enduring talent of the best American band of all time.
-
-
mikeNov 3, 2007Excellent Vocals and Depth of songs. The second and third listen is even better!
-
-
GeorgeP.Nov 5, 2007If you loved the Eagles in the 70's You'll love this new album. Incredble music, lyrics and vocals. The Eagles are the Beatles of Southern Rock and that's a fact. The album is a creative masterpiece.
-
-
ToddW.Nov 5, 2007
-
-
ToddNNov 7, 2007
-
-
DaveLNov 9, 2007I've been a huge Eagles fan all my life. They were the staple of my youth and the inpration for my music career. But this is not the Eagles I grew up loving so much. They made a HUGE mistake getting rid of Felder. He was THE SOUND. He gave them an edge that defined them from other country rock artists. Bring back Don baby, they really need him.
-
-
RyuDec 1, 2007Boring! They never were interesting anyways.Now velvet underground reunion album...that would be nice.
-
-
JeffT.Dec 6, 2007
-
-
BMJan 10, 2008I have been an Eagles fan since the early 70's. This album is terrible. There are only a couple of songs worth listening to. I kept advancing the cd to find a song that reminded me why I loved the Eagles so much. Never found one.
-
-
GregPOct 3, 2008A few stinkers, but otherwise some very good Eagles music. Some of the reviews posted to this site read like critics whining for a stage on which to spout their musical "gravitas" and intellect. Over analyzing music from the Eagles is probably a waste of time, whereas simply enjoying their music is good enough for me. It's just the Eagels for crying out loud.
-
-
MartinD.Aug 25, 2009A fantastic double CD that warrants and rewards frequent playing. As good as anything they did 30+ years ago.
-
-
NoelLo.Nov 1, 2007unlistenable (if such word even exist. if not, then it should be added to english dictionary because of this record) poor effort by eagles...
-
-
JimM.Nov 1, 2007
-
-
DougWNov 20, 2007As much as I hate to say it- it's crap. As Dave L. has already said: "...this is not the Eagles I grew up loving so much." It sure ain't. Tired old men.
-
-
DowJ.Nov 3, 2007
-
-
NiallNov 3, 2007Some reviewers I've read have been unimpressed & I originally decided not to buy. Having done so the melodies & harmonies are as if the last 25 years never happened. Not a classic but it does all you would want from an Eagles CD.
-
-
eddieNov 3, 2007A little less of Glenn's ballads and more tunes like "How Long" & BBF Joe Walsh rocks!
-
-
JyotiL.Nov 4, 2007I can now die happy! This CD is pure joy! A mix of sweet love songs, ballads obviously written to their children, and social commentary. The voices are great, the harmonies truly sweet, and the instruments well-seasoned. I've not in a long time heard as funky a song as "Fast Company"!!! These guys still have still got it going on and I just can't stop listening.
-
-
LidiaRNov 5, 2007Fabulous! as usual for the Eagles!
-
-
JimTNov 8, 2007Fantastic and long time comin'.
-
-
ToddVDec 25, 2007The track "How Long" fools you into thinking that you're getting the old Eagles sound. After what seemed to be 2 hours getting through the rest of the album - you find out you were tricked. I don't hear even one more radio track. Wish it was much better.
-
-
HalS.Dec 4, 2007I love the Eagles. I have been listening to the Eagles for over 20 years. I was really looking forward to this album. Then I listened to it. Very disappointing. This album is a shadow of the band's former work. Flat, sedate, cliche, and boring. Don't bother with it. I like to think it would have been better with Felder. But who knows?
-
-
SamuelLJan 11, 2008
-
Awards & Rankings
-
The album is savvier still, crafted to evoke the spirit and feel of the Eagles' biggest hits.
-
It's all a testament to the durable Eagles footprint on the pop landscape.
-
It is an auspicious beginning for a double album so strong it's almost irritating that it took so long to release it.