- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
It may be a spiritual cousin to Pinkerton, yet it's far removed from the raw, nervy immediacy of that album.... This has a lighter, brighter feel than any of its predecessors, not just in the music but in its outlook.
-
BlenderIn striving for Zen-like purity, the songs often end up eerily blank. [Jul 2005, p.122]
-
Make Believe finds Cuomo donkey-punching the formaldehyde-soaked corpse of his former glory.
-
"Make Believe" is classic Weezer, further refining the template of unthreatening heavy metal riffs... welded to smart lyrics, largely of satirical nature, and infectious melody.
-
You can hear them struggling on Make Believe to keep fans bouncing along to the power-pop anthems but also keep it interesting for themselves so frontman Rivers Cuomo won't put the whole thing on hiatus again.
-
Entertainment WeeklyWeezer's most conventional disc... a cleaner-sounding record heavy on way-earnest power ballads. [13 May 2005, p.85]
-
FilterThe thread that made Weezer everyone's favorite nerd-rock quartet--the soul and core behind the dramatic guitar crescendos--has unraveled completely, leaving us with a record full of, well, a lot of dramatic guitar crescendos. [#16, p.87]
-
Some songs are worth a listen, but the overall package sounds and feels redundant and, putting myself at the mercy of =W= fans everywhere, renders itself irrelevant.
-
MojoAnother patchily edifying addition to the Cuomo enigma. [Jul 2005, p.106]
-
Far from the unpredictable genius of old, it seems that Rivers Cuomo has returned lacking both edge and sparkle.
-
Many of these songs are thin schematics for “perfect” pop songs. They’re impressive in their commitment to formula--deploying catchy, whiny hooks, taut structure, loud-soft interplay, and well-timed guitar peals. Yet for all their nakedness, they offer little in the way of revelation.
-
Neither the best nor the worst album this band has recorded.
-
Sometimes an album is just awful. Make Believe is one of those albums.
-
You can feel how dreadful this record is from the very first bar.
-
It's the schizophrenic sound of a band starting over a decade later.
-
Q MagazineHints that Cuomo may be approaching some sort of personal epiphany about his place in the world. [Jun 2005, p.116]
-
Rolling StoneA breakthrough for Weezer... Cuomo's songs are his most plaintive and brilliant since Pinkerton. [19 May 2005, p.74]
-
Make Believe might sound more sincere if the clean, precision-metal production didn’t steamroll Cuomo’s lyrical misery in bombastic arrangements featuring factory-issue power chords and a MOR-safe rhythm section.
-
The truth is that any Weezer copycat band could have made this record.
-
Make Believe seems so simple compared to [Weezer's] other albums.
-
It's a sweet, open, daringly earnest album in which the sad old Cuomo does battle with the wise old soul Cuomo wants to become. By conventional wisdom, it should never work as a rock album, and most of the time, that conventional wisdom is dead on.
-
A chunk of almost straight-faced love/self-doubt songs show that while these geeks may not inherit the earth, they can play their competitors at their own game.
-
The New York TimesInfuriatingly plain. [16 May 2005]
-
Weezer's once unique aesthetic has been replaced by something formulaic and ultimately too safe.
-
UncutThe guitars still kick, but charm is thin on the ground. [Jul 2005, p.89]
Awards & Rankings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 183 out of 325
-
Mixed: 45 out of 325
-
Negative: 97 out of 325
-
Nov 24, 2017
-
May 5, 2016
-
Oct 15, 2014