Metascore
60

Mixed or average reviews - based on 8 Critics

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 3 out of 8
  2. Negative: 0 out of 8
  1. 70
    The rest of this album intersperses originals with classics--a respectful "First Noel," an aptly baby-making take on "O Little Town of Bethlehem," and "Here Comes Santa Claus (Right Down Santa Claus Lane)" as routed through a strip club. But nothing beats "All I Want for Christmas Is You," from her 1994 album Merry Christmas," one of the great modern holiday albums.
  2. 40
    It's 16 years since Mariah Carey's first Christmas album, and there's nothing here to suggest she's developed significantly since then.
  3. Dec 14, 2010
    80
    It's not particularly clever, but it is expectedly big: if you're a Carey fan with a stocking that needs filling this year, this'll perk you up better than any alternative speech or sherry trifle could.
  4. Nov 24, 2010
    40
    The near-crazed desperation to please listeners for her own sake is all over Merry Christmas II You: A "gift" to her fans (or so she claims) that they, of course, must pay for, it's her fascinating, career-long saga of self-obsession in a nutshell.
  5. Nov 8, 2010
    60
    Apart from that pair of stiff originals, the whole thing is cheerful and engaging, a worthy sequel to its predecessor.
  6. Nov 3, 2010
    60
    It's hard to figure out what's "extra festive" (as the full song title promises) about her "All I Want for Christmas Is You" update, and far easier to determine what's wrong with "Auld Lang Syne" (an awkward dance beat), but the LP's warm heart is in the right place.
  7. Nov 3, 2010
    50
    It's an attempted rewind. As such, it's probably one of the most revealing and none-too-flattering approximations of the mindset of a certain sort of adult's Christmas spirit.
  8. 83
    Carey's second holiday collection leavens soaring takes on traditional hymns with a handful of funkier originals. [5 Nov 2010, p.71]
User Score
6.2

Generally favorable reviews- based on 32 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 5 out of 6
  2. Negative: 0 out of 6
  1. Nov 6, 2010
    10
    Mariah's covers on Christmas classics are nice and different from the originals. What's more notable, is her original song ''Oh Santa!''. The song has a catchy and upbeat tune which makes people want to keep listening to it. The album's best gift, though, is Mariah's duet with her mother, Patricia Carey, in the song ''Oh Come All Ye' Faithful / Hallelujah Chorus''. Her mother's vocals are nice and it is nice seeing her in Mariah's songs. Not to forget all of Mariah's falsettos and whistle registers in the song towards the end.
    ''All I want for Christmas is You'' is, needless to say, a timeless classic. Mariah just made it better by adding in some falsettos and whistle registers here and there, and I think that this is a better version than the 1994 version. ''Auld Lang Syne - The New Year's Anthem'' is a catchy song with its dance beat.
    ''One Child'' is, probably, the nicest song on the album, save ''All I want for Christmas is You''. The song talks about God and the lyrics are nice and meaningful. The choir during the chorus is extremely organized and is one of the nicest choir singings I have heard. Overall, this album deserves a 10/10 rating, despite some songs which may have been sang in the incorrect style. But, the good points of this album can cover up for the minor little bits that are mistakes.
    Full Review »
  2. Nov 21, 2010
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click full review link to view. This is the second Mariah Carey's Christmas album, and I think it is one of her best album ever. There are four songs written by Mariah and I love these. The first single "Oh Santa!" is very joyful and I think it should do very well on charts. I also like the new edition of "All I Want for Christmas Is You". One of the most touching moment is the duet whit her mother, Patricia Hickey, that sings whit Mariah "O Come All Ye FaithFul/Halleluja Chorus". PS. Excuse me if I wrong something, but I am not English. Full Review »
  3. Jun 25, 2012
    9
    After many years of sticking to the R&B route for her albums, Mariah Carey proves she can still rule adult contemporary with this satisfying sequel to her 1994 classic "Merry Christmas". Cleverly titled "Merry Christmas II You" and released in 2010, the album sees Mariah covering many holiday standards, and, in typical Mariah fashion, delivering a few originals. The album kicks off with the up-tempo "Oh Santa!", which, thematically, is pretty much the sister to "All I Want for Christmas is You", her holiday perennial. But "Santa" offers an irresistible charm of its own, bouncing playfully from beginning to end with the aid of cheerleaders, chimes, whistle notes, and an attitude that feels more cheery and hopeful than that of its '94 counterpart. But then Mariah takes us to the fireplace with the light and dreamy "O Little Town of Bethlehem / Little Drummer Boy", fluctuating between soft, creamy singing and vocal dynamics that show Mariah sounding better than she has in years. Produced by Broadway composer Marc Shaiman, the next track - "Christmas Time Is in the Air Again" lifts us into a holiday waltz. We haven't heard Mariah sound this classy since the 1990s, yet she sounds as natural and inviting as if she'd been singing like this for the past decade. Keeping in the same relaxed, dreamy state, Mariah serenades us with another medley, this time "The First Noel/Born Is the King". The first part of the medley is arranged in traditional fashion, before seamlessly transitioning into the latter, R&B-driven "King". After soothing us with those three laid-back jingles, MC brings it home with "When Christmas Comes", a song that sounds instantly like a classic. The jazzy verses entice you to sway side to side before elevating into a fully-belted out-pour of choral magic. Of course, it can't be a Mariah Carey album if there's not a song that makes you want to shake your thang, even on a Christmas album. Mariah hits the dance floor with "Here Comes Santa Claus / Housetop Celebration", but instead of imagining a club, you totally get the feeling that it's the night before Christmas and you're partying around the house with your family and friends, and the warm, festive feelings set in.

    Perhaps the only flaw in the album is the next track, Mariah's attempt at "Charlie Brown Christmas". There's nothing glaringly wrong with the song, but it feels incomplete, still in its demo version, and Mariah's singing somehow doesn't quite connect like in the other songs. That, and Mariah's decision to include a live recording of "O Holy Night" from a decade prior, which doesn't really add anything to the original version that is worth listening to.

    Partly inspired by her pregnancy while recording the album, Mariah gets back to top form in the album's final new original, the made-for-children's-Christmas-performances "One Child". Elegantly sung, MC takes us to the true meaning of Christmas, telling the story and the impact of baby Jesus, but perhaps also indicating that her offspring will one day rule the world, so watch out.

    How can you make a classic even better? Instead of tempering with the song itself, add a new beginning and ending and blend them effortlessly with the original. That's exactly the approach Mariah took with her new recording of "All I Want for Christmas", the penultimate track on the album. Shaiman is back, sprinkling his Broadway magic in a new instrumental introduction that kicks off the song from a new and equally exciting launch point. Mariah's singing then takes us onto a familiar but fresh-as-ever ride, sounding almost exactly the same as the original version except for layered vocals here and there. Mariah extends the ending of the song in this version, however it's a shame she didn't include the ending whistle notes she did in the 2011 version with Bieber (although that was the only good part about that duet).

    Suddenly and effortlessly, Mariah's voice roars out of her chest in the final track "Auld Lang Syne", as if she's signaling the closure of a good show. Then it disappears behind a dance beat from the 90's and repeat background singing of the chorus. The song's carefree atmosphere is emphasized by Mariah stopping her singing to tease her listeners, saying "does anybody really know the words?" and laughing. Her first Christmas album, 1994's "Merry Christmas", may have spawned a classic, contained better vocals, and certainly the best songs on that album outweigh the best songs on this one -- still, "II You" is a stronger album overall, with all but two or three songs being constructed beautifully, sung passionately, and most importantly, evoking the emotional highs that are unique to the holiday season. It's also a testament to Mariah's artistry that her originals sound as good as the classics she covered.
    Full Review »