- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
The end result is a great album, albeit one more lighthearted than its myth would suggest.
-
This is a brilliant record, just as it's always been.
-
SMiLE has arrived as incredible and ground-breaking a record as any of us could have hoped.
-
It's looser and messier than Sgt. Pepper and, one suspects, always would have been. But its sui generis Americanism counterbalances its paucity of classic pop songs.
-
It’s spellbinding.
-
Smile is quite simply the greatest triumph in the history of pop music.
-
Infectious and hummable, to be sure, and a remarkably unified, irresistible piece of pop music, but no musical watershed on par with Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band or Wilson's masterpiece, Pet Sounds.
-
Despite the hype, it is hard not to be impressed with the new Smile.... The music flows beautifully - no mean feat when it encompasses barbershop singing, acid rock, early pop, Hawaiian chanting and mock-religious plainsong.
-
While it may not be the ultimate symphonic confection nearly four decades of hyperbole have all but guaranteed, Smile is nonetheless an arresting, audacious, unabashedly whimsical slice of junk-drawer Americana and can-do pop craftsmanship.
-
Hearing the newly recorded album as a completed work instead of dismembered modules is a rollicking reassertion of Wilson's compositional genius.
-
Smile's post-adolescent utopia isn't disfigured by Brian's thickened, soured 62-year-old voice. It's ennobled--the material limitations of its sunny artifice and pretentious tomfoolery acknowledged and joyfully engaged.
-
While undeniably ambitious and moving in parts--with sunny harmonies and layered production--it also happens to be a little kitschy.
-
The magic of the album lies in the way Wilson's complex, challenging sonic vision can evoke the optimism, hope, and wonder that gave birth to this album decades ago.
-
Against all expectations, Brian Wilson has achieved what should have been impossible, and has produced what may be the year's most thrilling album.
-
Turns out those hypothetical comparisons to Sgt. Pepper's weren't so far off the mark.
-
This is pop music like nothing before it, or since.
-
The new Smile not only justifies its bearing, but also serves as a major triumph.
-
Whatever it was supposed to achieve originally, right now SMiLE sounds like a beautifully modulated, funny, sometimes unintentional meditation on a failed United States and counterculture, and the lost paradise, real or imagined, of Southern California, and the collapse and reinvention of the male ego.
-
The most obvious aspect that takes away from Smile's luster however, is an uncomfortable sense that the album has morphed into a quaint piece of nostalgia rather than the masterwork it was expected to be.
-
Under The RadarOther than the fact that it came out a little late, there isn't a single thing wrong with it. [#8, p.113]
-
New Musical Express (NME)'Smile' stands up with any of the great music of the 20th century. [25 Sep 2004, p.63]
-
Los Angeles Times"Smile" emerges as a beautiful and cohesive work, at times deeply moving, at others oddly whimsical, at still others eerily disturbing but celebratory. [27 Sep 2004]
-
UncutA unique and unlikely moment of retrieval, restoration and renaissance. [Nov 2004, p.98]
-
MojoThere is a remarkable consistency about Smile's complex tapestry of delights. [Oct 2004, p.98]
-
BlenderDespite Wilson's wrecked voice, it's surprisingly grand and moving. [Nov 2004, p.146]
-
Q MagazineThe real revelation of this new Smile is its melodic depth, even if lyricist Van Dyke Parks's oblique ruminations seem unnecessarily flowery. [Nov 2004, p.114]
-
FilterOne of the most inspiring and triumphant projects of the year, and perhaps the last 30 years. [#13, p.89]
-
Entertainment WeeklyIt's a gorgeous trip back to a time when anything seemed possible. [1 Oct 2004, p.73]
-
The WireThe music has an originality that sounds remarkable even now. [#248, p.52]
Awards & Rankings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 398 out of 522
-
Mixed: 39 out of 522
-
Negative: 85 out of 522
-
FeidoVApr 12, 2010A great album.
-
BrianEMar 26, 2010Perfection in Sound
-
AnthonyLMar 26, 2010Best album ever.