MojoJul 18, 2012The grain and gravitas of Jones's voice is perfectly suited to this diverse material. [Jun 2012, p.82]
UncutMay 21, 2012It doesn't always work, but when it does, it suggests a great artist finding new and surer ground. [Jun 2012, p.77]
Q MagazineJun 20, 2012He thrives when bringing gravitas to the sparse blues of Soul Of a Man and extraordinary tenderness to the Low Anthem Charlie Darwin. [Jun 2012, p.105]
Aug 8, 2012Tom Jones has had a long and nearly legendary career, reinventing himself time and time again over the decades in his bid for relevance. AndTom Jones has had a long and nearly legendary career, reinventing himself time and time again over the decades in his bid for relevance. And he has done remarkably well. A cartoon icon of the sexy sixties, he's the last man standing of his Easy Listening contemporaries.
But music has changed - not just in style and tempo, but in connection. Jones predates the Singer/Songwriter, and has made his career singing the songs of other men. In the past, his range, bombast and verve has carried him through. With "Spirit in the Room," however, the veneer has been stripped away enough to expose his disconnection with the material.
The notes are there, the presentation is there... but all too often, it feels like he's singing phonetically in a language foreign to himself. The emotional underpinning of the songs he covers here feel unsupported; they are words to music without resonance in his soul.
They are acoustic Sussudio.
I have heard this album - this style - compared with Johnny Cash's later works, and the comparison is valid, And, at 70, it is understandable why Jones would vector his career in this direction. But Cash was a songwriter, and knew as well as any real troubadour the connection between the story and the heart. Where Cash could internalize another man's song and transmute it to his own, Jones is only able to present it. He presents it well - but presentation alone is not enough to make this release anything more than a novelty in his catalog.… Expand
- By user score
|Master of Puppets [Remastered & Expanded Edition] - Metallica|
|Melodrama - Lorde|
|Masseduction - St. Vincent|
|OK Computer: OKNOTOK 1997-2017 - Radiohead|
|Flower Boy - Tyler, The Creator|
|Rainbow - Kesha|
|Across the Multiverse - Dent May|
|Native Invader - Tori Amos|
|Tell Me You Love Me - Demi Lovato|
|American Dream - LCD Soundsystem|
|Rest - Charlotte Gainsbourg|
|The Architect - Paloma Faith|
|Soul of a Woman - Sharon Jones & the Dap-Kings|
|Big Fish Theory - Vince Staples|
|Sleep Well Beast - The National|
|A Deeper Understanding - The War on Drugs|
|Take Me Apart - Kelela|
|Colors - Beck|
|Painted Ruins - Grizzly Bear|
|To the Bone - Steven Wilson|