Hands down their best since Pinkerton. The playfulness and humor found in the blue album has returned!

Awful awful stuff, this record will destroy this band.

This album has a lot more life than people are giving it credit for. The first 4 songs are going to be Weezer classics. "Cold Dark World" is a let down an sounds like something that could have been written by a high school kid, but that was really the lowest point of the album for me.

I just bought the album today ($6 at Wal-Mart, the same on Amazon.com for you bargain hunters) and listened to it three and a half times on the ride home from a road trip. It has a lot of decent tracks, but no great ones, and little flow. This is not the Weezer album I had hoped for after hearing "Pork and Beans" for the last month. "Troublemaker," while making it clear as day that Rivers Cuomo is no longer a skillful lyricist, is still a fun song. It doesn't have any depth whatsoever, but who cares? It's a good Weezer song. The verse in "Everybody Get Dangerous" is Cuomo's best stab at anything hip-hop since the vocals of "El Scorcho." "The Greatest Man That Ever Lived" starts off as a pretty awesome song, but past the first three minutes, it becomes one great big black mark on the whole album. Rivers tried to make his own "Jesus of Suburbia," to a lesser extent, and it falls flat on its face. The jerky turn-arounds left and right in its six minute runtime completely throw (and in my case, turn) the listener off. "Dreamin'," while not as extreme, has some very awkward, uncomfortable structural issues (although I won't deny that it's kind of rockin'). "Thought I Knew" is a throwaway track and a disappointment for those looking forward to hear what the other members of Weezer are capable of. "Automatic" is a little better, but nothing great. I think Cuomo is better off going with the whole control freak thing. "The Red Album" is a great improvement over "Make Believe" and even a step or two above "Maladroit." If nothing else, it serves as a very interesting record to the band's fanbase. Sadly, instead of the triumphant return we've been hoping for, this is more so the final nail in the coffin---Weezer is never coming back. Few tracks can be identifiable to the band's crunchy pop-rock of the nineties, and Cuomo and Co. don't seem to be looking back. If this "different" music was better, I wouldn't be complaining.… Expand

Yeah, it's not perfect. But, it's different. I personally bought the itunes deluxe version, and some of the bonus tracks like pig and miss sweeney are actually better than songs like let's get dangerous and one of my least favorites, cold dark world. But songs like greatest man, dreamin', automatic, etc...are totally worth it. better than make believe and green in my opinion.

This is the CD weezer fans have been waiting for. There is a plethora of sounds on this album that all seem to work. I think 'Pig' and 'King' from the deluxe version should have been included.

Biggest let down since Make Believe.

A lifelong Weezer fan, I must admit that while "Pork and Beans", "The Greatest Man", and "Automatic" had me listening happily, the rest of the album was only slightly above average, maybe bar "Troublemaker". The other two non-Cuomo entries have not been played through once on my media player thus far. Yes "Make Believe" was panned but as far as Cuomo handing out songwriting duites, the old addage "if it's not broken don't fix it" may be needed to put in effect, although Wilsons attempt was quite catchy.… Expand

I'm so disappointed by this album!! I'm afraid that I'll finally have to line up with the reviewers who claim they haven't made any great record since Pinkerton. Make believe at least gave some hopes!!

Bland and boring.

These guys should just quit. This music is disgusting.

Best satire on the industry in years. They took the best formulas out there and reinvented them Weezer style.... great stuff.

Worst album in the Weezer catalog. 2 good songs on standard album, 1 extra on the Limited Edition. Cuomo rapping, really?

In short, Weezer has continued it's trend of making each new release worse than all their previous albums (Blue Album > Pinkerton > Green Album > Maladroit > Make Believe > Red Album). 1.Troublemaker - 2.5/5 2.The Greatest Man That Ever Lived (Variations on a Shaker Hymn) - 2.5/5 3.Pork and Beans - 3/5 4.Heart Songs - 2/5 5.Everybody Get Dangerous 2/5 6.Dreamin' - 2.5/5 7.Thought I Knew - 1.5/5 8.Cold Dark World - 1.5/5 9.Automatic - 1.5/5 10.The Angel and the One 2/5.… Expand

All songs are good if you don't expect it sound like pinkerton or blue.......don't let the reviewers discourage you!

I don't know why all the indie-poseur freaks are so obsessed with "Pinkerton" as this seminal classic of rock music. It was a nice departure for a pop band, but the results weren't nearly as catchy as the Blue Album; nor were they as arena-ready and fine-tuned as "Maladroit." I agree with another poster: it grows awfully tiring to hear people crap upon all post-Pinkerton Weezer records, because frankly, they've done better music since. That being said, this will probably go down as their worst record. That doesn't make it crap; it just makes it not brilliant. But maybe, just maybe, it will age as well as "Make Believe" has -- and for all the haters out there, go back and listen to "Make Believe" now that the hype's been removed. It's not a bad record at all. This one... Don't know if it's got anything (besides the glorious "Greatest Man") that's as memorable.… Expand

Why are they pretending they're still in high school (troublemaker)? The tunes ain't bad (dreaming's the best), but the lyrics are so asinine and childish. Grow up, peoples. There's more to life than just doin' what you wanna do. Let's get past the "I'm me, if you don't like it, kiss my a**, rolling stone." Can't keep my attention when you';re singing about how cool and different you are.… Expand

Great album,4 ok songs,better than the majority of the 70+ reviews!if you heard another band play a song like the greatest man that ever lived..you would be amazed.but the fact that its weezer and does not sound like the blue album or pinkerton; people complain!great album tho!!

Horrendous. A malformed abortion of an album with no focus, no themes, no art. The biggest waste of $1 million ever spent by humanity.

The problem is that these brilliant boys have become legends & people expect unreasonable results. The Album is brilliant and no bands these days can say they go #1 on the sixth CD. Most will be washed up after 1 or 2. there are 4 soon to be classics which is allot. Having other members singing may come off as a downfall, but not so. After 6 CDs, There is room around. They already have a live setlist of hits. This helps build Character. I smell a KIss legion of fans, without the $$$ grubbing ideals of KISS. Truth be told, they are charting #1 still... Yet, have never sold out. They are quirky, always have... They rock and people agree. Truth be told. If something is cool, then we all want to be cool by disagreeing that this is cool. Well. Weezer is real. They continue to stay fresh, Bizarre & somewhat unpredictable. Thats why we all still talk about them. They are too good to die off like every other band with their years of history.… Expand

First 6 tracks are excellent the rest are a bit so-so.

While it is a step up from the god awful "Make Believe" it is still a very very bad record. It leaves one wondering the eternal question, "How did weezer get this bad?"

I am surprised at the negative editorial reviews. I think intrinsically most critics are unable to enjoy weezer. Weezer's real core audience is that kid in us that is nerdy and airguitars and sings along to our favorite rock songs and pretend to be rock stars. Weezer makes the music that kid would have made, not the same as his heroes, but a little more more honest. I think critics want Rivers to be that indie/emo/pop rock hero of theirs they remember from their youth, when he is in fact has never been that guy, and they've all grown out of it. Some of us thankfully haven't grown out of it, and just want enjoyable, honest, quirky music that speaks to us big self-aware (not self consious) kids. I'll leave the critics to tell me what is "clever" or "fresh" or "meaningful" or "original" they are good at that cause they've made it their job to do so, but they aren't really good at telling me whats enjoyable. I'm brave enough to enjoy this new Weezer album the way it is supposed to be, singing out loud in my car with the windows down, just like I was when I was 16.… Expand

I really enjoyed this album. at first i listened to it and was like "this doesnt even sound like weezer", I was shocked at how foreign. Yet after listening to it a second time, I started to like it more and more. Finally I was jammin' along with each song, just like I do with all the old weezer songs. I thought this was a great album, yet very diffrent from Weezer's other works, only 3 songs on the album seem like classic weezer songs, yet i think any Weezer fan will still enjoy it, and maybe its new sound will attract new fans.… Expand

Let's not forget that Pinkerton was once voted one of the worst albums ever and now it is hailed as one of the best...i think many people want too badly to claim that they love the "old school" everything...it's the popular thing to do...despite the band-wagon opinion, weezer has stayed consistent since the blue album...yeah, they're experimental, but they always have the same happy, rock feeling in every song...i'm not a huge fan of the three songs that Rivers doesn't sing in, but I think the rest is nothing short of a magnus opum.… Expand

I get a kick out of the critics who first say a band is not stretching their limits or trying new or innovative sounds, only to complain when they do.

I agree word for word with the NME review. This is a fun, light hearted album in the vien of Maladroit . . . which I also enjoyed. Nobody does power pop better; weezer is one of the truly funny bands out there. Not many records can intentionally make me laugh out loud.

Can't say I love this album, but I do love at least "Heart Songs" - it's a great power ballad homage to so many influences. I also like "Pork and Beans," it's not bad, and surprisingly "Everybody get Dangerous" isn't bad either. But that's about all you can say, "not bad" but also not great. Except for Heart Songs. It saves the album for me. It's a decent album and good for the car.… Expand

I can't think of a positive thing to say about this album. It does make me feel bad for Weezer though. The one point I gave them was a pity point.

Yes, sad to say, it's over for weezer. Blue album and pinkerton were defining for the 90s, but other 90s heroes have lapped the hell out of weezer. This album makes me think they should hang it up... Thom Yorke, Stephen Malkmus and Beck have all released much better stuff than this in 2008. Hell, Kurt Cobain could probably best this effort.

Amazing and honest album. The follow-up we needed after the subpar Make Believe. This album will generate many singles over the summer that will power our radios!

Weezer is Weezer. Always have been, always will be. I can't understand how people think they've changed. It's been the same distortion, the same Cuomo, and the same power chords for just about 15 years now. But giving this a 0? It sure doesn't deserve a zero I mean come on it's better than hip hop or rap. It's pop rock. Leave it at that.

I'm going to give it a 10 because a) it's a great improvement from make believe, b) it shows the growth of weezer through its past albums, c) rehabilitation to the improvement towards the blue album sound, d) the sounds in general are pretty all right, with a lot of experimental stuff which should be acknowledged.

Didn't like it at first but it has grown on me a lot after a few listens. "Greatest man..." "Heart Songs" and "Dreamin'" are all great tracks. It's certainly not their best album by any measure but it's comparable to maladroit and I'd at least put it above the Green album, which I think is their weakest release. Of course, I'm in the minority of Weezer fans because I absolutely loved Make Believe. (best breakup album ever)… Expand

Horribly underrated. It doesn't click the first time through, but after a couple listens you get used to the change.

Amazing return to form after Make Believe. "Dreamin'" and "The Greatest Man That Ever Lived" are future Weezer classics, and they may have taken a few more listens than the other songs, but the non-Rivers entries are nowhere near as bad as some of the reviews make out. Get the deluxe version.

I have done a full listen scott v And this album is a complete let down. What happened to this band?

Though certainly not as good as the other two weezers, it's aninteresting change from the abysmal make believe. rivers did good on "the greatest man in the world"

What happened to this band? thought they were better than this... they seem so pathetic on this album! wat a shame. i liked thembetter a long time ago.

Based on the user reviews, this is really a love-it-or-hate-it album but, then again, Weezer's always been a love-it-or-hate-it-band. Put me in the love it column. This is a fun album with a lot of catchy hooks, great riffs, and Rivers' has never sounded as soulful. It reminds me of why I liked Weezer in the first place when I heard "Sweater" for the first time. Like the Blue Album, these songs aren't going to change the world and can't be dissected for any deeper meaning. But they're fun, and Rivers' always has his tongue firmly planted in his cheek.… Expand

Everyone giving this a low score without any reasoning doesn't know what they're talking about. Everyone's saying how much they wish Weezer would be just like they were in the 90's. Well wake up, it's 2008 and people should realize that Weezer is changing. While they may not be the same Weezer you remember listening to years ago they are still the bad we all love. Now, about the album. While not all the songs are perfect, many are very, very good. I recommend that you get this CD because it's definitely Weezer's best in a while.… Expand

I think people are being way to hard on this cd, especially on the other band mates who contributed songs. I thought their songs were pretty good. The last song on the deluxe cd is actually my favorite song on the cd and it's sung by another member. No, this is not the masterpiece all Weezer fans wanted, but it is the best cd they have done since Pinkerton. For the masterpiece we will keep waiting, but I recommend this cd to any Weezer fan.… Expand

The first four songs are all great...Weezer is still one of the best bands out there.

This album was not as good as previous Weezer albums. But it does have some good songs on it like Troublemaker and Thought I knew. It also has some memorable and catchy lyrics on the vast majority of the tracks. So do yourself a favor and give it a listen. JJ Thailand

They are fantastic in red album! Love it!

Although the non-Cuomo songs really lack the delicious weez-groove I've come to adore, I think relinquishing a bit of control was an awesome move on Rivers' part. It shows that he's capable of checking his ego and letting his mates have their chance in the spotlight. That said, the rest of the album is wonderful. I would've given it a solid 10 if not for the lackluster performance on the aforementioned tracks. "The Greatest Man Who Ever Lived," "Heart Songs," "Dreamin'," and "The Angel and the One" are genius. The experiments in form and composition that Rivers has undertaken are evidence of his brilliance, yet they're still infused with that infectious weezer flavor. Don't believe the haters - this album kicks ass!… Expand

This album is good stuff. For years I refused to submit to Weezer. But Rivers and crew rarely disappoint. This album continues to grow on me the more I listen to it. It’s WAY better than "Make Believe". And although a few pieces made my eyebrows twitch, as a whole it’s a great record. “Fans” are so weird about Bands. Stay with the same formula and people bitch that a band never progresses, but when they change or try new things, people bitch that they’re somehow different, sold out, whatever. For years Weezer has managed to craft great songs while, changing, improving, and yet still keeping a common thread. The “Red Album” is a great addition to the Weezer catalogue.… Expand

Mediocre at best, but it is an improvement over Make Believe. A couple stand out tracks, but many songs are forgettable, while others are just duds.

You guys are pop whores - Oh well, it's hard to surf the net and listen to music. Guess what, I bought the album instead of listening to a few "random" songs that may have got you laid that night.

If I didn't already know it was Weezer, I'd be saying, "Who's this awful band that's trying to sound like Weezer?" What a shame. The most ironic thing is that Rivers specifically wrote a song about refusing to sell out, and ended up making the most contrived piece of garbage imaginable. I could have tolerated this from any other band. Not Weezer.

Anything less than a 6 for this album would be a straight-up lie. You must do a FULL listen! It is fun, upbeat, poppy, rocky, clever, and geeky! The songs taken over by Brian Bell do not sound like Weezer, but are delicious on their own. And add a beautiful disconnect to the album. The Greatest Man That Ever Lived is a raging, instant-classic anthem for anyone who's ever sung along to a song. Weezer has brought it! But can you handle it?… Expand

Critics are way off, they have no clue. Best album since Pinkerton.. oh yeah, they missed the boat on that one too. Now it makes a lot more sense. Excellent album; nice to see these guys having a good time again.

Best album since Pinkerton in my mind.

I find the critic reviews hilarious in their range. It's almost as if they haven't paid attention to Weezer's discography other than just the Blue Album. You may not find too many top 40/video songs here, but the song writing and arrangement are extremely entertaining. Songs twist and turn direction, seldom staying on pace for more than a few minutes at a time. My only beef is the second track, it seriously disrupts the tempo and would probably fit better latter in the disc with the B sides. Check it out, and force yourself not to skip any songs, they will string you a long just for a later payoff.… Expand

Just really disappointing. When I saw the Pork and Beans video I thought that this album would be awesome, but in the end it just didn't work out.

"The Greatest Man", "Troublemaker", "Dreamin", and "Pork and Beans" (the singles) are by far the best Weezer has done in a long time, the other songs take some getting used to, but will grow on you. (Don't forget Pinkerton took a while to achieve it's cult status).

You know it's bad when the best song on the album is the one you let the drummer sing.

I love this cd. Weezer has been a favorite of mine for a long time, but they almost lost me with efforts like "maladroit." But every "color" album has been great, with the "red" album finishing a close 2nd to the incredible debut "blue." So come on folks, "everybody get dangerous."

I'm sick of people trashing on all post-Pinkerton Weezer. The fact is that Pinkerton is unrepeatable. And I love Pinkerton just like the last guy, but I'm pleased they're not trying to hold onto that. As for the red album, I think it's a great CD, and definitely better than Make Believe (although I appreciated that CD). The interesting thing with this album is that it's a more "mature" collaborative Weezer, with 5 minute songs, and band members alternating instruments and vocals. This is something I've always been curious about. Starting with Make Believe, it seems as if River's has started to loosen the reigns, and I this is the loosest album yet. Yet, Weezer holds up to all their fun pop melodies, power chord rock, with lyrics that at times make you snicker in amusement. Maybe I'm a sucker, or just too much of a hardcore Weezer fan. But I'm pumped on the Red Album. Also, if there's one place that Make Believe specifically fell short, it was with the slower mellow numbers. While the slower songs on the Red Album still are'nt my favorite selections, they do have a life that was absent from the previous CD. I really enjoy the cut loose feel of this album. So suck it Weezer critics. Long live the Weeze, all the way till the end!… Expand

Weezer has become the pit of jokes in the music community, and this album is a perfect reason why. The band claims to be experimenting by allowing other members to provide lead vocals, but instead it comes off as some sort of mid life crisis, a band trying desperately to appear cool, but instead failing to do so. The album may have 1 or 2 decent tracks, but as a whole it fails - miserably (Cold Dark World, Heart Songs are some of the worst material I have heard all year).… Expand

It's truly remarkable how critics will bash a band for being too predictable, only to complain when their next album is wildly different. The criticism for "Make Believe" was mostly deserved, but critics are way off-base for this one. This album is without a doubt the band's best since Pinkerton and needs time to grow. The songwriting is daring and succeeds on most fronts. Cuomo could have easily churned out another Green Album or Make Believe, but takes the band in a bold new direction. The deluxe edition is certainly recommended since it contains 3 of the best tracks that Cuomo has ever written. Erase all expectations for what a Weezer album should sound like and give it a fresh listen. It's a grower. This album will be hailed as one of their best many years from now.… Expand

One of the best albums I've heard in years. My favorites are Pork & Beans, Greatest Man that ever Lived, and Heart Songs. Great Weezer album!

Why is everyone bashing this disk? It's got everything that EVERY Weezer disk has.. Geekiness: check Angst: check Wall of Screaming Guitars: check Tounge in cheek lyrics: check Uh, sounds like Weezer to me. Cold Dark World, Automatic, Pork and Beans, The Angel and the one, Heart Songs are the standouts for me. Good but not great album not all that bash worthy. Thanks Weezer for another entertaining effort..… Expand

When it's good, it's good, but when it's bad, it's really bad. The best songs are "Pork and Beans", "The Greatest Man That Ever Lived," "Automatic," and from the bonus tracks, "It's Easy" and "Pig." Two other songs are pretty decent, but have a few issues: "The Angel and the One" is some of Cuomo's best lyrical work since Pinkerton, but the song drags on for too long and becomes boring; "Dreamin'" is great until it enters a long, slow, unnecessary bridge that drags on for two minutes or so, and really takes away from the rest of the song. "Troublemaker" is OK if you can live with the middle school-level rhyming lyrics. The other tracks, "Cold Dark World," "Thought I Knew," and "Heart Songs" annoy me, and are forgettable. The lack of guitar solos really annoys me as well, especially since a few of these songs are built so perfectly for them that you can easily tell where they should have gone, such as around 3:20 or so into "The Angel and the One" and after the bridge in "Pork and Beans." Guitar solos have been staples of Weezer songs for so long, it's a shame that they excluded them entirely from this album.… Expand

Great Album all around, the Deluxe addition adds 3 solid tracks with "King" being possibly the best on the album. "The Greatest Man That Ever Lived" gets better and better each time I hear it! This album is fun, catchy and an all around great time.

if weezer's debut was a 10 and pinkerton an 8.5 this is a 3 at best. weezer was the first album i ever bought and i'm embarassed that 14 years later this is what they've come up with. "everybody get dangerous"? who do they think they're singing to?

This album is slightly better than their last two album combined; but it still plays to the masses a little too much. They seem to have lost their creative edge they had on Weezer (Blue) and Pinkerton.

This album is underrated, but it's true that the album have a few bad songs. The extra track make the album so much better! They version of the greatest man are the best thing I've heard this year after the new Mindless Self-Indulgence album.

without the bonus tracks on this cd the rating would be lower. There are exactly 4 songs on this cd worth a damn. The drummer song hasnt made it past 5 seconds after the 1st time I heard it. wow is it bad.

You have to really put yourself in Rivers' shoes. This album is as perfectly honest as it gets. Beautiful.

Wow, I'm surprised by the amount of ratings above 5. This album is truly terrible. It goes one step further into the mindset that Weezer writes material that is witty, humorous and ironic, where in fact there was a time that Cuomo honestly adored music and wrote his true feelings without attempting to relate to the mainstream and it was matched by music that wasn't remastered pop rock. The new sound doesn't bode well for the future, as that the majority of 90's fans have been completely rejected. Please breakup.… Expand

Nothing like the bands beginning, and far more immature, which is weird for a bunch of old dudes. Obnoxious at times.

I only enjoyed Pork & Beans, The Angel and the One, and King from the Deluxe version. Do Not Spend Money This Album!

Didn't like anything past the Blue Album, do not like the bands modern sound and this album is by far the worst. Thanks Weezer. Does anyone remember Undone?

I feel like I cannot relate to this band anymore. Make Believe was terrible, terribly pop, but this, man, I can't even comprehend some of this drool.

This is a great album from top to bottom. Sit down with no preconceived notions and the deluxe version and you will surely enjoy this album.

This album and its promotions were what made me a Weezer fan, and since then they have become my favourite band. A great album on its own, though it cannot be compared to Blue or Pinkerton. The low points are the songs not sung by Cuomo and I feel if they were replaced by some of the Deluxe tracks this could have truly been a great album.