Metacritic Books

Public Enemies
by Bryan Burrough

ISBN: 1594200211
Penguin Press, 592 pages, $29.95
Nonfiction History, True Crime
Released 07/15/2004

Acclaimed Vanity Fair contributor Bryan Burrough brings to life the most spectacular crime wave in American history: the two-year battle between J. Edgar Hoover's FBI and John Dillinger, Bonnie and Clyde, Baby Face Nelson, Pretty Boy Floyd, and the Barkers. [Penguin Press]

Overall Metascore

This is an average of all individual scores given by critics, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).

92 / 100

Critic Reviews

Outstanding Chicago Sun-Times Roger K. Miller
It is quite superb -- readable, thorough and critical -- with masses of new information from FBI files that were opened only in the late 1980s.
Outstanding Chicago Tribune Matthew Dallek
Burrough's narrative is fast-paced, his prose captivating. Drawing upon several hundred-thousand FBI documents, Burrough has conducted important new research. He re-creates in vivid detail the criminals' whereabouts, characteristics and ignominious rise to Depression-era fame.
Outstanding Entertainment Weekly Bob Cannon
Enemies is an amazingly detailed true-life thriller that puts us on a stakeout alongside the feds, inside the banks while bullets fly, and inevitably, next to the criminals' bloody corpses.
Outstanding Kirkus Reviews
Iconoclastic and fascinating. A genuine treat for true-crime buffs, and for anyone interested in the New Deal era.
Outstanding Publishers Weekly
[Burrough] successfully translates years of dogged research, which included thorough review of recently disclosed FBI files, into a graceful narrative.
Outstanding The Spectator David Hughes
The air of an old movie pervades these pages, an early talkie, with scratchy soundtrack, slightly overacted, as creaky as its cast's own ethics. The delight lies always in the detail.
Outstanding Wall Street Journal Richard Tofel
Mr. Burrough does a remarkable job of reportorial reconstruction, drawing from hundreds of thousands of pages of FBI files released only in the past quarter-century. He seems to have absorbed every detail.
Outstanding Washington Post Lawrence M. Friedman
It is a wild and amazing story, and Burrough tells it with great gusto... It is easy to toss around terms like "definitive," but this book deserves it. It is hard to imagine a more careful, complete and entrancing book on this subject, and on this era.
Favorable The Guardian Clare Longrigg
A rollicking ride through an endless series of bank heists and car chases.
Favorable San Francisco Chronicle Chuck Leddy
Excellent reading for fans of American history and true crime.
Favorable The New York Times Edward P. Lazarus
Fascinating but also a bit numbing. At some point one well-told stickup and getaway begins to run into another.
Favorable The New York Times Book Review Mark Costello
As the story of the F.B.I.'s emergence from the 10-ring circus that was 1934, Public Enemies is excellent true crime with all the strengths and limitations this implies. Burrough's stirring book goes easy on the Ph.D. conclusions.

CLOSE THIS WINDOW

©2008 CNET Networks Inc. All rights reserved.