Metacritic Books

Every Man A Speculator
by Steve Fraser

ISBN: 0066620481
HarperCollins, 752 pages, $29.95
Nonfiction Business & Professional, History
Released 02/01/2005

Fraser's epic-length book chronicles not the history of the actual Manhattan street, but of America's attitudes toward what Wall Street represents--chronicling two centuries worth of American capitalism and financial markets in the process.

Overall Metascore

This is an average of all individual scores given by critics, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).

80 / 100

Critic Reviews

Outstanding The Nation Mike Wallace
Fascinating.... Though the title suggests a focus on financial affairs, it belongs on the shortlist of books that encompass and illuminate the entire trajectory of the American experience.
Outstanding Booklist David Siegfried
Fraser gives a thorough analysis of this scandal-ridden menagerie as reflected in books, movies, and the political arena. [15 Dec 2004, p.696]
Outstanding Kirkus Reviews
Comprehensive, considered, and literate: a real accomplishment. [1 Dec 2004, p.1130]
Favorable Library Journal Richard Drezen
This scholarly and entertaining encyclopedic history documents an important part of U.S. business history. [1 Mar 2005, p.96]
Favorable Publishers Weekly
Almost every page contains wildly mixed metaphors and other excesses of enthusiasm over clarity, but Fraser tells a monumental story with real energy. [3 Jan 2005, p.46]
Favorable Christian Science Monitor Carlos Lozada
Thoroughly researched and compelling.
Favorable Los Angeles Times Jeff Madrick
Fraser's detailed book would have benefited from tighter organization, but its accumulation of information is fascinating. [6 Feb 2005, p.R3]
Favorable San Francisco Chronicle Tom Gallagher
[A] work of tremendous erudition.
Favorable The New York Times Book Review Harold Evans
Fraser... has a keen grasp of his material, and his vivacious style and historical perspective carry us through the tumults.
Favorable Daily Telegraph Raymond Seitz
The inevitable discursiveness of this long survey is relieved by Fraser's punchy prose.
Favorable Daily Telegraph Martin Vander Weyer
He is certainly eloquent, and skilful at weaving diverse material into a coherent narrative.
Favorable The Guardian Larry Elliott
What could easily be a dry narrative is brought to life by drawing on the work of the writers, poets, dramatists, musicians and film-makers who have found Wall Street's violent mood swings between irrational exuberance and dark despair, the apparent contradiction of a society simultaneously wedded to both God and Mammon, and the murky activities of those quite happy to gull the innocent, all endlessly fascinating.
Favorable The Independent Eric Homberger
It is hard to image a more thoughtful, and urgent, book than Fraser's picture of a nation willingly seduced by greed.
Favorable Washington Post Paul Blustein
In the process of telling this sprawling tale, he sometimes goes on too long, and his attempt to draw sweeping conclusions about America's changed character is strained. But his prose is elegant, and his eye for historical detail is keen, carrying the reader through the many sagas that he entertainingly recounts.
Favorable The New Republic Jackson Lears
Every Man a Speculator demonstrates that the writing of American history does not have to be blandly celebratory to be accessible and forceful. Fraser certainly offers a bracing alternative to the bromides of Stephen Ambrose and David McCullough.

CLOSE THIS WINDOW

©2009 CNET Networks Inc. All rights reserved.