Metacritic Books

Blackbird House
by Alice Hoffman

ISBN: 0385507615
Doubleday, 240 pages, $19.95
Fiction Short Stories
Released 07/20/2004

Twelve interconnected stories that take place at a Cape Cod farmhouse over the course of several generations.

Overall Metascore

This is an average of all individual scores given by critics, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).

69 / 100

Critic Reviews

Outstanding Kirkus Reviews
A quiet but deeply moving achievement of lyric power.
Outstanding Publishers Weekly
Hoffman's lyrical prose weaves an undeniable spell.
Favorable Library Journal Starr E. Smith
Haunted--and haunting--characters populate the tales, which are also notable for their intense sense of place. Hoffman's many fans should welcome this little gem with enthusiasm. [July 2004, p. 76]
Favorable Los Angeles Times Bernadette Murphy
Life is beautiful and heart-rending, [Hoffman's] tales remind us, often in quick succession. [20 July 2004, E7]
Favorable Booklist Donna Seaman
As the stories leapfrog from colonial times toward the present, Hoffman, a subtle conjurer of telling details and ironic predicaments, orchestrates intense romances and profound sacrifices. [15 May 2004, p. 1579]
Favorable Boston Globe Valerie Miner
As the stories leapfrog from colonial times toward the present, Hoffman, a subtle conjurer of telling details and ironic predicaments, orchestrates intense romances and profound sacrifices. [15 May 2004, p. 1579]
Favorable Daily Telegraph Patrick Gale
There is sentimentality in [Hoffman's] trust in the essential virtues of country living, but it is constantly spiked by her keen observations of the way people are. Her writing is abuzz with scents, tastes and textures.
Favorable The Guardian Elaine Showalter
Hoffman is a skilled and experienced writer. Her stories are beautifully constructed, with subtle echoes and thematic links that repay close attention, while casual readers will respond to Hoffman's haunting characters, and to her lyrical setting.
Favorable The New York Times Book Review Emily Barton
Hoffman lets Blackbird House stand as an emblem for the transforming power of any long-established home, while reveling in the haunting quality of her own distinctive literary style.
Favorable USA Today Anita Sama
Hoffman peels away layers of time, painstakingly sifting through two centuries to expose all that can occur by one field of pink sweet peas at the end of the world.
Mixed Houston Chronicle Sharan McBride
The trouble with Hoffman's linked narrative is that tragedy and losses that seem moving and affecting early in the book begin to feel manipulative and programmed by the 12th story.
Mixed San Francisco Chronicle Irene Wanner
The book is something of a jigsaw puzzle. Some readers may find Hoffman's approach satisfying, others may not, but all have been presented with pieces they must join themselves to fully appreciate "Blackbird House."
Terrible Entertainment Weekly Henry Goldblatt
The characters are so unrefined and underwritten it would take a genealogist to untangle their relationships. That leaves you rooting for the return of a very hungry halibut, who makes a meal of a fisherman early in the book, to put the rest of these folks out of their (and your) misery.

CLOSE THIS WINDOW

©2008 CNET Networks Inc. All rights reserved.