Metacritic Books

The Accidental Masterpiece
by Michael Kimmelman

ISBN: 1594200556
Penguin, 256 pages, $24.95
Nonfiction Art, Architecture & Photography, Essays
Released 08/18/2005

New York Times art critic Michael Kimmelman explores the art in everyday life (as well as the art made by professional artists) in this book of essays.

Overall Metascore

This is an average of all individual scores given by critics, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).

77 / 100

Critic Reviews

Outstanding Christian Science Monitor Marjorie Kehe
What Kimmelman has achieved is no small feat. He has somehow managed to write a book that is a meditation on art and yet is also a pageturner. His style is easy and accessible, and his colorful anecdotes guarantee a good read even to those doubtful about their taste for art criticism.
Favorable Kirkus Reviews
Ebullient brightness permeates these pages, illuminating even the darkest comers. [15 May 2005, p. 576]
Favorable Library Journal Cheryl Ann Lajos
Kitschy and candid yet thought-provoking and uniquely awesome. [1 Jun 2005, p.126]
Favorable Los Angeles Times Susan Salter Reynolds
Many... masterpieces are contained (although they are so powerful they threaten to burst the binding) in this collection of endless inspiration. [11 Sep 2005, p. R11]
Favorable New York Observer Choire Sicha
As a travelogue, The Accidental Masterpiece rings absolutely true, and just lovely. [22 Aug 2005, p. 18]
Favorable New York Review Of Books
Kimmelman is an enchanting writer and endlessly curious critic. He brings fresh perceptions to every work of art he discusses in this book. Each time he looks, it is as though he's never looked at a work of art before.
Favorable Publishers Weekly
Intelligent but not obscure, warm but not intrusively personal. [16 May 2005, p. 49]
Favorable San Francisco Chronicle Trey Popp
A consistently enlightening, often humorous and an occasionally exhilarating adventure.
Favorable The Economist
Read every word of Mr Kimmelman for ideas to think with... You won't regret it.
Favorable The New York Times Adam Phillips
The enthusiastic appreciations in "The Accidental Masterpiece" are well worth taking time over. And in his determination not to be earnest, Mr. Kimmelman is often more serious than he sounds.
Favorable The New York Times Book Review Adrian Searle
Art can be anonymous. It can be made by accident and with no apparent effort at all. It can also entirely consume a life. These are some of the lessons of Michael Kimmelman's ''Accidental Masterpiece,'' a book that captures very well the enigmatic status of art and how we might approach it.
Favorable Washington Post Jonathon Keats
[Kimmelman's] depictions are entertaining and insightful, as artful in their own way as many of the works he discusses.
Favorable Booklist Donna Seaman
Kimmelman himself, a receptive and creative observer, turns criticism into story, thus making art out of thought. [Aug 2005, p. 1980]
Favorable Boston Globe Barbara Fisher
While the essays appear almost accidental, the art, masterpieces or not, seems hardly the creation of chance.

CLOSE THIS WINDOW

©2008 CNET Networks Inc. All rights reserved.