Metacritic Books

Fantastic
by Laurence Leamer

ISBN: 0312333382
St. Martin's Press, 432 pages, $24.95
Nonfiction Biographies & Memoirs, Current Events & Politics
Released 06/07/2005

Leamer, who has written extensively on the Kennedys, turns his attention to Kennedy-by-marriage Arnold Schwarzenegger with this biography, which is based on first-hand access to both the California governor and his wife, Maria Shriver.

Overall Metascore

This is an average of all individual scores given by critics, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).

40 / 100

Critic Reviews

Favorable The Economist
To his credit, Mr Leamer does not dodge the issues that Mr Schwarzenegger's PR people would like to airbrush out of the picture.
Favorable The New York Times Book Review Lou Cannon
[A] balanced and insightful biography.
Mixed USA Today Deirdre Donahue
Fantastic is not fantastic all the time.... There is simply too much information on bodybuilding, Sly Stallone, action flicks and California politics.
Mixed Wall Street Journal John H. Fund
[Leamer's] book is not hagiography.
Mixed The Spectator Frederic Raphael
Laurence Leamer’s low-down becomes a pedestal on which Arnie’s occasionally lovable hunkishness is jacked up even higher.
Mixed Washington Post Peter Schrag
One of the strengths of Leamer's book is his awareness of Schwarzenegger's arrogance, his dependency on adulation, his will to dominate.
Mixed Daily Telegraph Nigel Farndale
Although this biography is sympathetic, it is not sycophantic.
Mixed Publishers Weekly
His book is not fantastic, but it's well researched and moves along at a pleasantly robotic clip.
Unfavorable Daily Telegraph Robert Hanks
Leamer comes over as sycophantic.
Terrible The New Republic
Schwarzenegger's sexual peccadilloes... provide Leamer many opportunities to ply his craft as an excuse-maker.
Terrible Los Angeles Times Richard Schickel
These desperately humorless pages will send any reasonably sentient reader into the streets, barking like a dog. [17 July 2005, p. R3]
Terrible Kirkus Reviews
Leamer halfheartedly dresses this cocky suprahuman in an underdog's cloak of self-deprecation, shilling anecdotes about Schwarzenegger's crippling need to be admired.

CLOSE THIS WINDOW

©2008 CNET Networks Inc. All rights reserved.