Metacritic Books

Darkly Dreaming Dexter
by Jeff Lindsay

ISBN: 038551123X
Doubleday, 304 pages, $22.95
Fiction Mystery & Thrillers
Released 07/20/2004

Meet Dexter, a polite wolf in sheep's clothing...a monster who cringes at the site of blood...a serial killer whose one golden rule makes him immensely likable: he only kills bad people. [Doubleday]

Overall Metascore

This is an average of all individual scores given by critics, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).

77 / 100

Critic Reviews

Outstanding Library Journal David Wright
Lindsay brings the same refreshing ebullience to serial killers that Anne Rice once brought to vampires. A macabre gem. [15 June 2004, p.59]
Outstanding Publishers Weekly
A gripping, deliciously offbeat novel that announces the arrival of a notable new talent.
Outstanding The Globe And Mail [Toronto] Margaret Cannon
This is a smart, witty novel with a premise that keeps the action moving and the reader entranced. Dexter is a terrific character, and the plot twists along so cleverly that we don't know exactly what he's going to do until the end.
Outstanding The Guardian Maxim Jakubowski
You'd think coming up with an original variation on the serial killer novel would be tough going by now, but Lindsay applies the thumbscrew with witty relish and draws the reader in from the outset.
Outstanding Booklist David Pitt
After finishing this debut novel, readers will have only one thing to say: wow! [May 15, 2004, p.1601]
Favorable Daily Telegraph Susanna Yager
A psychopath with a sense of irony and even a vestigial conscience is a novelty and so is this tasteless but witty, entertaining romp.
Favorable The New York Times Book Review Marilyn Stasio
The plot has some nice twists, and the Miami setting contributes its own eccentric flavor. But the real appeal of this macabre tour-de-force is Dexter's sardonic voice, so snappy and smart, and yet so full of self-loathing that we hate ourselves for laughing.
Favorable The New Yorker
Dexter Morgan, the namesake of Lindsay's first novel, is one of the most likable vigilante serial killers in recent thriller literature.
Favorable USA Today Carol Memmot
Lindsay's tale is daring and unexpectedly comedic. The writing is lively and the plot steps away from the common ground in which many thrillers are rooted.
Favorable Kirkus Reviews
Cheap fun: a guilty pleasure few monster-addicts will be able to resist.
Unfavorable Entertainment Weekly Jennifer Reese
The novel unravels in a nasty, campy denouement that leaves little doubt: Avowed serial killers, however tame, do not make appeaing protagonists over the long haul.
Unfavorable The New York Times Janet Maslin
The book has attracted advance praise for its ghoulish ingenuity, but its degree of cleverness is questionable. Really, how witty is a killer who takes truncated body parts and arranges them to spell out "Boo?"

CLOSE THIS WINDOW

©2008 CNET Networks Inc. All rights reserved.