Metacritic Games

Turning Point: Fall of Liberty (Xbox 360)

The game supposes that the incident in which a car struck Winston Churchill in New York on December 13th 1931 actually proved fatal – and that without his inspirational speeches to galvanise the Allies, the course of the Second World War took a very different route, with the Axis Powers even invading America.

Codemasters
First-Person Shooter
Players: Multi
T (Teen)
Developer: Spark Unlimited
Released February 26, 2008

Overall Metascore

This is a weighted, normalized average of all individual scores given by critics, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).

43 / 100

Critic Reviews

76 Xbox360Achievements
I truly believe that, had they given the development at least another few months to beef up the visuals and sounds and maybe even add a bit to the campaign itself, this could have been a great game, possibly making a few top 10 lists along the way.
70 Gaming Nexus
Despite Turning Point having a potentially good story it does nothing else than introduce the player to new levels filled with enemies that do not grow in intelligence or difficulty.
68 IC-Games
This is a game for rent without a shadow of a doubt. The shortness and the general issues with it mean I can’t really recommend anything else.
65 NZGamer
Unfortunately, the overall polish on the title can only be described as "a quick buff".
65 Official Xbox Magazine
But ultimately, the choppy multiplayer options and ultra-disbelief-suspending campaign deliver an uneven "What If" history lesson. [Apr 2008, p.74]
60 360 Gamer Magazine UK
And while it’s a solid enough shooter that’ll largely cure the itch for frag-heads, it just fails to do anything to particularly excite.
59 GamingExcellence
The glitches and poor level design don’t quite ruin a game that should have been so much more than the sum of its parts. Still, there’s some fun to be had here with a weekend rental.
58 1UP
Aside from the frustrating control inconsistencies and the abbreviated storyline, this is still a well-made trek through a history that thankfully never happened. Though the sluggish multiplayer mode doesn't even deserve a glance, the predominantly solid mechanics and terrifying premise make this a more than competent deviation for someone itching to kill more Nazis.
56 Da Gameboyz
Overall, Turning Point: Fall of Liberty is game which had some fantastic ideas and concepts. Unfortunately, the great ideas did not transform into a solid shooter.
56 Da Gameboyz
Overall, Turning Point: Fall of Liberty is game which had some fantastic ideas and concepts. Unfortunately, the great ideas did not transform into a solid shooter.
55 MS Xbox World
Turning Point: Fall of Liberty is a novel idea on paper, but is ultimately let down by its shooter by numbers gameplay and under par presentation.
53 Team Xbox
The innovation potential was in the story, though that only provides the setting for the gameplay. Outside of that, it’s pretty basic fare.
52 Extreme Gamer
Turning Point: Fall of Liberty is an excellent game idea that doesn’t live up to its potential. Turning Point is filled with dull missions, simplistic artificial intelligence, dated graphics, and a whole pile of over used mojo.
52 Gamer 2.0
After playing through just a bit of Turning Point, we were completely disappointed. The old feeling to it completely ruined the original concept.
50 Games Radar
Turning Point's minimalist approach to everything - from its stale levels and sticky controls to its thin plot and absent character development - killed what could've been a really unique and engaging shooter and will disappoint hardcore fans of the genre across the board.
50 Play Magazine
Turning Point's theme of an alternate reality had some possibilities, but even within this fiction you just end up doing uninspired and overworked shootouts. [Apr 2008, p.63]
50 IGN
Shooting Nazis in the streets of three major U.S. cities should be a non-stop thrill ride that has me on the edge of my seat. This game provides the opposite experience.
50 Official Xbox Magazine UK
The game's ultimate wrong turning is that it looks and plays like something released several years ago. [May 2008, p.88]
45 Worth Playing
The gameplay, graphics and multiplayer were all substandard, given today's expectations.
45 GameSpot
This alternate-history shooter is proof that an interesting premise can't compensate for boring and broken gameplay.
45 PTGamers
Our worries have been confirmed, and Turning Point turns out as a mediocre FPS, with a lot of problems that shouldn't appear on a so called next-gen game.
42 Cheat Code Central
Although Turning Point had an interesting storyline, it still ends up being an incredibly limited and generic WWII shooter.
42 MEGamers
A good story made into a terrible game.
41 Planet Xbox 360
Sadly, you will battle nearly as many bugs as Nazis through the course of Turning Point. For all the game gets wrong, which marks about ninety-eight percent of the game, they deserve credit for at least writing a solid, heroic ending to the game. The trick is plodding through four to five hours of bad to get to the thirty-seconds of goodness.
40 PALGN
A lackluster first person shooter, the game is not only let down by the disappointingly forgettable story, but the horrendous gameplay.
40 Thunderbolt
A lack of direction within the gameplay and narrative ensures that this is one gamers will overlook like so many before.
40 AceGamez
So much potential is wasted in poor execution, unfinished code and sloppy graphics that I can only recommend this game if you really have nothing else to play or are simply aching for a new WWII style shooter.
35 Ferrago
It's ugly, it's poorly executed, it's riddled with technical glitches, its A.I. is laughable, it's boring, unoriginal and thoroughly unrewarding.
33 GameShark
The opening sequence is one of the most memorable in recent memory but it is almost as if the developers spent all of their creative energy on it leaving the rest of the game to degenerate into a bland, plot-less mess.
31 Xbox World 360 Magazine UK
A terrible, dreary, teidous mess. [June 2008, p.82]
30 games(TM)
As a catalogue of all the errors you can ever expect to see in a clunky first-person shooter Fall Of Liberty excels. [May 2008, p.120]
30 X360 Magazine UK
Turning Point falls so short of its potential it makes us shed a tear. [Issue#32, p.82]
30 Edge Magazine
While the likes of Call Of Duty 4 and Halo have made console joypads feel snappy and responsive enough to challenge the PC mouse and keyboard, Turning Point has sloppily regressed the cause by a few years. [May 2008, p.93]
30 VideoGamer
It feels a little wrong to be so down on a game that seemed genuinely interesting when it was first announced, but Turning Point is so devoid of the qualities needed in a modern FPS that it's impossible to sugar coat. It's just a very bad game, plain and simple.
30 Game Informer
With the number of average-to-outstanding FPS titles available on next-gen consoles, there’s absolutely no reason to waste your time with this disaster.
30 GameSpy
It also runs poorly, replete with graphical glitches and technical hiccups that make the game feel shoddy and unfinished. At a moment when so many excellent shooters are on the market and thriving in the multiplayer scene, there's very little incentive to endure something like this.
30 EuroGamer
If Churchill had died, we might all be speaking German, but at least we wouldn't have to put up with nonsense like this.
30 Total Video Games
Hats off to Spark Unlimited, we really thought that Conflict: Denied Ops would be the worst first-person shooter of the year...but Turning Point: Fall of Liberty snatches that award with both hands.
30 GameTap
Irredeemably awful.
30 GameDaily
A blown opportunity.
25 Game Revolution
The ugly unpolished moments and Looney Tunes character animations are so silly, especially when the dead civilians everywhere are much more depressing than whimsical.
21 Jolt Online Gaming UK
Avoid Turning Point, even if it means running in front of a taxi.
20 G4 TV
The game tells its story horribly, your character is both improbable and without any personality, the AI is terrible, the gameplay lackluster, and graphics middling. Even as a budget title, which Turning Point is certainly doomed to become, the game is hardly worth the bother.
10 Gamestyle
In many ways Turning Point: Fall of Liberty is playable, but there’s so much unredeemable dross that you should seriously question why you purchased the game when every other FPS on the system is far more deserving of your money.

CLOSE THIS WINDOW

©2008 CNET Networks Inc. All rights reserved.