Metacritic Film

Dudley Do-Right

Starring Brendan Frasier, Sarah Jessica Parker, Alfred Molina, and Eric Idle

MPAA RATING: PG for mild comic action violence, and for brief language and innuendo

Universal Pictures
Comedy
77 minutes | Color
USA
Released In Theaters August 27, 1999

Follows the hilarious exploits of the dedicated but hapless young Canadian Mountie (Frasier). (Universal Pictures)

WRITTEN BY
Hugh Wilson
Jay Ward (characters)

DIRECTED BY
Hugh Wilson

Overall Metascore

This is a weighted, normalized average of all individual scores given by critics, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).

44 / 100

Critic Reviews

80 Variety
One of the summer's more pleasant surprises. A silly bit of tiptop tomfoolery with cross-generational appeal.
75 Chicago Sun-Times
I enjoyed the film more than I expected to. It's harmless, simple-minded.
75 New York Post
A kindler, gentler comedy that's perfect for children and parents to see together.
75 San Francisco Chronicle
Eric Idle--a royal among sillies--turns in a wonderfully wacky performance.
75 New York Daily News
Mostly pitched at a new crop of children who will detect the movie's mildly sarcastic, audience-winking tone with no problem.
70 LA Weekly
This whole movie is fun, and smart too, a fitting tribute to Jay Ward's original cartoons.
60 The New York Times
Works well as family entertainment.
50 Dallas Observer M. V. Moorhead
Isn't great; it doesn't come within a Yukon mile of its TV namesake. But it's agreeably bizarre.
50 Entertainment Weekly
The balance of inspired idiocy to hackneyed buffoonery is out of whack.
50 San Francisco Examiner
The needle on the laugh-o-meter barely budges.
50 Boston Globe Betsy Sherman
Never gets horribly bad, but can't sustain its moments of inspiration either.
50 Washington Post
Performances feel too manufactured to be charming.
40 TV Guide
The plot is Kate-Moss thin. Basically agreeable stuff, but not much more. And that's a shame.
40 Salon.com
Enough flickers of Jay Ward's gloriously subversive sensibility to make it watchable, but it also has enough lengthy stretches of pure triteness to make it easy to skip altogether.
40 Film.com
As flat as the brim of a Mountie hat.
38 Chicago Tribune
Like an obnoxious uncle desparately trying to amuse the young'uns with poo-poo humor and dum-dum pratfalls.
35 TNT RoughCut Matt Kelsey
Follows the current trend of once-popular cartoons turned into mediocre live-action incarnations.
30 Chicago Reader
This terrible live-action comedy based on Jay Ward cartoons has its moments and its near misses.
26 Mr. Showbiz
You'd think creating confusion during something as woodenly simpleminded as Dudley Do-Right is no easy task, but you'd be wrong.
25 Seattle Post-Intelligencer
A big dud.
25 Miami Herald Phoebe Flowers
Wilson's plot compulsively leaps from paper-thin to near-incoherent.
25 USA Today
Dead-carcass spinoff of Jay Ward's animated TV favorite.
10 Los Angeles Times
Tiresome, inept farce that's not even a fraction as clever or entertaining as it likes to imagine it is -- a complete waste of time.

CLOSE THIS WINDOW

©2009 CNET Networks Inc. All rights reserved.