Matt and Shelby, a couple from Los Angeles, leave the city and move into a mysterious house in North Carolina, where strange things begin to occur.

While the Millers discover some of their house's history, Lee falls into old habits and her daughter, Flora, makes a new friend.

The search for Flora continues as the situation grows more and more dire. The Millers talk to a paranormal expert to help them with their problem.

Shelby and Matt are saved from someone who could help them find Flora. More is learned about the colonist and the Witch.

The Butcher and her mob arrive at the house, with intent on killing Matt and Shelby, who are saved by an unlikely ally. The origins of the house are revealed.

After the wrap of the show My Roanoke Nightmare, the producer creates a follow up show called Return to Roanoke, bringing the actors of the previous show and the real Shelby, Matt, and Lee, back to the house.

Audrey, Lee, and Monet find themselves in grave danger as they search for Sydney; Agnes comes back for revenge; Matt and Shelby deal with the ramifications of their situation.

Audrey, Monet, and Lee remain hostages of the Polks, while Shelby and Dominic try to think of a way to escape the wrath of The Butcher back at the house.

A new actor shows up to the house per Sidney's request; three young adults enter the woods to shoot footage of the blood moon and the history of the house for the web. Meanwhile Lee, Monet and Audrey remain on the run.

Lee Harris, the lone survivor of Return to Roanoke: Three Days in Hell, agrees to an interview live on television, the Lana Winters Special.