Private Practice

New York Daily NewsDavid Hinckley

Private Practice at first glance looks like it's about to die. But by the end of its premiere tonight it has miraculously come back to life, apparently without even the aid of a tall, handsome, mysterious script doctor.

SalonHeather Havrilesky

Ultimately, asking if Private Practice is good is like asking if a Twinkie is good. The answer is "No" and "Of course!" and, also, "Give me another one."

Los Angeles TimesRobert Lloyd

New beginnings can be difficult; there are problems here, though they are not irremediable. By and large the show improves on its pilot.

USA TodayRobert Bianco

Still, for all the show's flaws, here's the good news: Practice is far better than the dismal Grey's episode that introduced it.

VarietyBrian Lowry

ABC's eagerly awaited spinoff of "Grey's Anatomy" initially qualifies as a disappointment -- hitting completely familiar medical-drama beats while pursuing a whimsical tone it never fully achieves.

Kansas City StarAaron Barnhart

I was disappointed by the opening episode, which left me with the distinct impression that Taye Diggs (playing a newly divorced doctor in the practice) and Tim Daly (Walsh’s first love interest on the show, but I’m sure not the last) were simply working off their ABC contracts that began on other, now-canceled shows. The portrayals of alternative medicine were unfortunate and too much forced zaniness.

Hollywood ReporterRay Richmond

The talented cast isn't quite as successful in getting past the shortcomings of a teleplay (from Rhimes, naturally) that's typically light on believability and heavy on the outrageous.

Pittsburgh Post-GazetteRob Owen

Kate Walsh seemed like a guest star in what should be her show.

Detroit Free PressMike Duffy

Even with Walsh's star sizzle and an attractive, talented supporting cast that includes Tim Daly, Amy Brenneman, Taye Diggs and Audra McDonald, Rhimes still hasn't found her spinoff's storytelling groove

Philadelphia Daily NewsEllen Gray

The good news is that the show's first non-"Grey's" episode is a decided improvement and recaptures the sense of humor that the mothership seemed to lose last season. The bad news is that as a medical show, it's so predictable that anyone who's watched any David E. Kelley show in the past 15 years or so, from "Chicago Hope" to "Boston Legal," will see certain plot points coming a mile (or two) away.

San Jose Mercury NewsCharlie McCollum

Tonight's opening episode is somewhat better than the pilot, although it's clear there is still work to be done in defining the characters and setting an overall tone.

The New York TimesAlessandra Stanley

The premiere showcases seven different women, doctors and their patients, in various states of anger, insecurity and neediness. It’s like a Hogarth engraving of the seven stages of womanly despair, “A Surgeon’s Progress.”

Entertainment WeeklyKen Tucker

The pleasure to be extracted from Private Practice--well, not so much pleasure as cringey curiosity--resides entirely in trying to figure out what's really going on inside the actors' heads as they skip through this latest Adults Are the New Spoiled Brats fantasy from "Grey's Anatomy" creator Shonda Rhimes.

Newark Star-LedgerAlan Sepinwall

Addison isn't very strong or decisive in her professional capacity either, spending most of the pilot waffling on whether she should have left Seattle Grace.

Miami HeraldGlenn Garvin

Fans of Grey's Anatomy femme fatale Addison Montgomery may find her a little dull now that she doesn't have a husband or boyfriend or intern to cheat on or with in ABC's spin-off Private Practice.

Baltimore SunDavid Zurawik

While the series created by Shonda Rhimes brings some outstanding performers like Amy Brenneman and Audra McDonald back to weekly TV, tonight's season opener is not very appealing.

Chicago TribuneMaureen Ryan

The problem is that Private Practice attempts to drum up comedy from things that aren’t funny and to wring drama from situations that are melodramatic, predictable or reek of barely repressed anger.

Seattle Post-IntelligencerMelanie McFarland

Private Practice manages to turn the viewer off in an entirely different way from the moment it starts.

NewsdayVerne Gay

Private Practice is hugely disappointing, and in so many ways that a mere review can't even begin to do all the problems injustice.

TV GuideMatt Roush

This lightweight medical drama still needs serious script surgery.

Washington PostTom Shales

Spun clumsily and greedily off "Grey's Anatomy," the new series seems shallow and smirky.

Chicago Sun-TimesDoug Elfman

You can see the script and directional tone holding back the actors.

San Francisco ChronicleTim Goodman

Private Practice is bad. Not "worse than "Grey's Anatomy bad" in the sense that Rhimes really is good at pulling people's heart strings with melancholy and humor.

Philadelphia InquirerJonathan Storm

It's amazing there's no orthopedist, since the show's so lame.

Boston GlobeMatthew Gilbert

Private Practice is just plain McLousy, from its stock cast of whiny healers down to the hokey, gimmicky medical cases of the week.