Another Gay Movie

Film Threat Phil Hall

The idea of a gay version of "American Pie" might not seem too tasty, but Another Gay Movie offers a fabulous surprise in not only matching that rude boy classic's unapologetic rude humor but by establishing its own identity as a genuinely funny and often touching coming of age comedy.

New York Post Lou Lumenick

A fabulous and often hilarious variation on "American Pie" that substitutes quiche, gerbils and various sex toys for apple pie.

Entertainment Weekly Owen Gleiberman

Stephens stages Another Gay Movie in a style of low-budget fluorescent overkill, but a handful of the gags are low-down funny.

Philadelphia Inquirer Tirdad Derakhshani

Likable-to-a-point.

Seattle Post-Intelligencer Paula Nechak

The film, despite the occasional gross-out joke, can't disguise the fact that it's a sweet old sappy -- even dated -- love story. Only Molly Ringwald is missing.

The Hollywood Reporter Frank Scheck

In his director's statement, filmmaker Todd Stephens proclaims that he wants his latest effort to be "the gayest movie ever made." Damn if he doesn't succeed.

San Francisco Chronicle G. Allen Johnson

An over-the-top, rollicking, candy-colored raunchfest.

Variety Robert Koehler

This is son-of-John-Waters with most of the grossness but none of the essential anarchism -- silly pop trash set for vid-classic status in gay households.

Los Angeles Times Kevin Thomas

Writer-director Todd Stephens set out to make the raunchiest gay teen movie ever, which this picture most certainly is, but the result is far more frenetic than funny.

TV Guide Ken Fox

There's a fine line between subversively transgressive and just plain gross, and this coming-of-age-movies parody from Todd Stephens, who wrote and directed the charming and underrated "Gypsy 83," crashes right over it.

Boston Globe Michael Hardy

You get the impression that the cast and crew of Another Gay Movie could have made a genuinely funny film if they weren't obsessed with out-grossing the already gross "American Pie."

Chicago Tribune Sid Smith

Combine the uninhibited raunchiness of John Waters with the gross-out zeal of the Farrelly brothers and you get Another Gay Movie, a parody and comedy more numbingly disgusting than funny.

The Onion (A.V. Club) Scott Tobias

Arriving late to the scene, Another Gay Movie coughs up the same awkward gags about coming of age via false starts and sexual humiliation, only the genuine sweetness and camaraderie that made the first "Pie" movie bearable has been replaced by glib self-awareness.

Village Voice R. Emmet Sweeney

Boasting a "Scary Movie" rate of scatalogical jokes-per-minute, it fails to match that franchise's low yield of guffaws.

LA Weekly Tim Grierson

Making a gay film only slightly less intolerable than its straight counterparts isn't much to be proud of.

The New York Times Nathan Lee

A rude, rollicking and exceedingly raunchy attempt to turn "American Pie" into "American Quiche."

Chicago Reader J.R. Jones

The word "raunchy" doesn't begin to describe this.

Washington Post Ann Hornaday

Whether or not it's crucial for the gay community to have its own "Porky's" is a question for the ages; but please, not Another Gay Movie.

Miami Herald Peter Debruge

A devastating disappointment. Badly acted, amateurishly directed and woefully unfunny.